Read 1 of 5
Few firms, big stakes
What is an oligopoly, why do some markets end up with only a few firms, and how do we measure that?
A wheat farmer takes the price as given, and a monopoly sets its price facing only its customers. Most of the firms students go on to work for are in neither position. A handful of rivals share the market, and each one's best move depends on what the others do.
This reading defines oligopoly, looks at the forces that leave a market with few firms and introduces the two measures of concentration that competition agencies use.
1.1
Between monopoly and competition
An is a market with a few firms, each large enough that its choices move the market price or its rivals' sales. Global aluminum, Australian supermarkets, mobile networks, domestic airlines and memory chips are all oligopolies.
Neither of our earlier models fits. A competitive firm in Week 2 took the price as given, because its output was too small to move it. A monopoly in Week 4 faced the whole demand curve on its own. An oligopolist faces a demand curve that depends on its rivals: if a rival cuts its price or expands its output, the oligopolist sells less at every price it might charge. So its best decision depends on what it expects the rivals to do, and theirs depends on what they expect from it. That's a game, and Week 6 gave us the tools to solve it.
The products can be identical, as aluminum, crude oil and steel nearly are, or differentiated, as phones, cars and soft drinks are. The firms can compete on output, on price or on something else entirely, such as advertising, capacity or product design. This week we start from the two simplest cases, competition on quantity and competition on price, and then see what differentiation and capacity limits change.
1.2
Why so few firms
Oligopolies aren't accidents. Several forces keep the number of firms small, and they often reinforce one another.
- Large capital requirements. A smelter, a chip fabrication plant or a national mobile network costs billions. Few investors will commit that much to a market where one more firm's output would push the price down for everybody.
- Control of essential inputs. Firms with exclusive access to a mine, a spectrum license or prime retail sites have a cost advantage that a newcomer can't match.
- Legal restrictions and patents. Licenses limit entry in many utilities, and patents protect a few producers from imitation for years.
- Economies of scale. When average cost keeps falling over a large range of output, a few large firms can serve the market more cheaply than many small ones could. A small entrant starts at a cost disadvantage.
- Mergers. Firms combine to gain market power, share resources or reach a larger scale.
Memory chips show several of these at work. DRAM fabrication is expensive and has steep economies of scale, and prices swing with the business cycle. Around 2000, NEC and Hitachi merged their DRAM units into Elpida, and several other producers left the business after the dot-com crash. The 2008 crisis took out Qimonda, the memory spin-off of Infineon. Micron agreed to buy the bankrupt Elpida in 2012 and completed the purchase in 2013. Since then, three firms, Samsung, SK Hynix and Micron, have earned close to 90% of the world's DRAM revenue, according to the market researcher TrendForce. Their shares move from quarter to quarter, but the three stay on top.
1.3
Measuring concentration
How concentrated is a market? Two measures are in common use. Both start from market shares, the percentage of industry sales made by each firm.
The \(CR_n\) adds up the shares of the \(n\) largest firms, usually the top three or four. If the four largest firms hold 32%, 21%, 19% and 13%, then \(CR_4=32+21+19+13=85\%\). It's simple, but it ignores how the share is divided among the leaders and what happens outside them. A market where the top four hold 70%, 5%, 5% and 5% has the same \(CR_4\) as one where each holds 21.25%, but the first is much closer to a monopoly.
The uses every firm's share. Square each firm's share, in percent, and add the squares:
Three firms with 50%, 30% and 20% give \(50^2+30^2+20^2=2{,}500+900+400=3{,}800\). A monopoly gives \(100^2=10{,}000\). A market of 100 firms with 1% each gives 100. Squaring gives large firms more weight, so the two lopsided and even markets above get very different scores: \(70^2+3\times5^2=4{,}975\) against \(4\times21.25^2\approx1{,}806\), before counting the firms outside the top four.
A useful way to read the HHI: with \(n\) firms of equal size, it equals \(10{,}000/n\). An HHI of 2,500 is what four equal firms would give, and 5,000 is what two would give.
Competition agencies use the HHI to decide which mergers deserve a close look. The ACCC's merger assessment guidelines, published in 2025 for Australia's new merger regime, treat a market with an HHI above 2,000 as highly concentrated, and an increase of more than 100 points from a merger as significant. Five firms with 20% each give exactly 2,000. In the United States, the 2023 Merger Guidelines use 1,800 and 100. Both agencies say the HHI is one indicator among several, not a test that settles the question.
Keep in mind what the HHI measures. It describes the structure of a market, not how the firms behave in it. Two firms can compete so hard that the price falls to cost, as Reading 3 shows, and many firms can collude, as Reading 5 shows. A high HHI is a reason to look more closely, not proof of a problem.
1.4
Australian supermarkets
The ACCC's supermarkets inquiry, released in March 2025, estimated national supermarket sales shares for 2022–23. The report describes the industry as "an oligopoly".
| Supermarket | Share of sales |
|---|---|
| Woolworths | 38% |
| Coles | 29% |
| Aldi | 9% |
| Metcash (IGA and other independents) | 7% |
| Others | 17% |
Measure it
What is the three-firm concentration ratio?
\(CR_3=38+29+9=76\%\). Coles and Woolworths alone have 67%.
The four named firms contribute how much to the HHI?
\(38^2+29^2+9^2+7^2=1{,}444+841+81+49=2{,}415\). The 17% held by others adds at most \(17^2=289\) if it were one firm, and much less because it's spread across many. So the HHI is between about 2,400 and 2,700: above the ACCC's 2,000 line. It's close to what four equal firms would give.
Does an HHI above 2,000 show that Coles and Woolworths don't compete on price?
The HHI measures structure. The ACCC reached its conclusion that Coles and Woolworths have "limited incentive to compete vigorously with each other on price" from evidence on prices, margins and behavior, not from the HHI alone.
Concentration is only part of the story. The supermarkets also compete through differentiation: Aldi's small range of private-label products at low prices, the loyalty programs Everyday Rewards and Flybuys, store locations, online delivery and fresh food. Reading 4 shows why that kind of differentiation keeps prices above cost even with several rivals.
Summary