Read 3 of 5

Choosing price and output

How does a firm with market power choose its price?

We now have both halves of the comparison. Marginal cost, from Week 1, tells Ride On what one more ride adds to cost. Marginal revenue, from the last reading, tells it what one more ride adds to revenue.

The monopolist's question is the same one Auto Eco asked in Week 2: should I sell one more unit? The logic doesn't change. Only the revenue side does, because Ride On's revenue from one more ride is marginal revenue rather than the price.

We'll find Ride On's best output and price, and then look at what the answer says about price and cost, the most common errors, what happens when costs change, and what happens when the firm can't produce as much as it wants.

3.1

Expand while marginal revenue exceeds marginal cost

Profit is revenue minus economic cost, \(\pi(Q)=R(Q)-C(Q)\). Rather than search every output, pick one and ask whether Ride On could do better by moving.

Start at 40 rides. Marginal revenue is \(MR(40)=3.5-2=1.50\), and marginal cost is 0.50. One more ride adds about $1.50 to revenue and 50 cents to cost, so it adds about $1 to profit. Ride On is leaving money on the table, and it should expand.

Start at 80 rides. Marginal revenue is \(MR(80)=3.5-4=-0.50\). One more ride now lowers revenue by about 50 cents and still costs 50 cents to run. Going the other way, one ride fewer raises revenue by about 50 cents and saves 50 cents of cost, so profit rises by about $1. Ride On should contract.

The same comparison works at any output.

  • If \(MR(Q)>MC(Q)\), the next unit adds more to revenue than to cost. Expanding raises profit.
  • If \(MR(Q)\lt MC(Q)\), the last unit added more to cost than to revenue. Contracting raises profit.
  • If \(MR(Q)=MC(Q)\), neither change helps. Profit is at its peak.

Put differently, the change in profit from one more unit is \(MR(Q)-MC(Q)\), and profit peaks where that change is zero. This gives the :

Monopoly pricing rule\(MR(Q^m)=MC(Q^m),\qquad p^m=p(Q^m)\)

Choose the output \(Q^m\) at which marginal revenue equals marginal cost. Then charge the price \(p^m\) that demand allows for that output. The superscript \(m\) marks the monopoly choice.

For a price-taker, marginal revenue is the price, so the same rule becomes \(p=MC\), the condition we used for Auto Eco in Week 2. It's one rule, applied to two different revenue curves.

Drag the point along demand to find the number of rides that makes daily profit largest. Then turn on \(MR\) and \(MC\) and check where they cross.

3.2

Ride On, worked through

Ride On's marginal revenue is \(MR(Q)=3.5-Q/20\), and its marginal cost from \(C(Q)=40+0.5Q\) is 0.5 at every output.

Step 1. Set marginal revenue equal to marginal cost.

\(3.5-\dfrac{Q}{20}\)\(=\)\(0.5\)\(MR=MC\).\(\dfrac{Q}{20}\)\(=\)\(3\)Add \(Q/20\) and subtract 0.5 on both sides.\(Q^m\)\(=\)\(60\)Multiply both sides by 20.

Step 2. Read the price off demand. Go up from 60 rides to the demand curve, not to the marginal-revenue curve:

\(p^m\)\(=\)\(3.5-\dfrac{60}{40}\)Inverse demand at \(Q=60\).\(=\)\(2\)

Step 3. Calculate profit.

\(\pi(60)\)\(=\)\(2\times60-(40+0.5\times60)\)Revenue minus cost.\(=\)\(120-70\)\(=\)\(50\)

Step 4. Check that the firm should operate at all. As in Week 2, the marginal rule finds the best output if the firm operates. It doesn't say whether operating is better than shutting down. If Ride On shuts down, it saves its whole cost, including the rental, and earns nothing, so its profit is zero. Operating earns $50 a day, so Ride On should operate.

So Ride On sells 60 rides a day at $2 each and earns a daily economic profit of $50.

3.3

Two things the answer says

Price is above marginal cost. At 60 rides, marginal cost is 50 cents, but the price is $2. This isn't a quirk of Ride On's numbers. At the optimum, marginal revenue equals marginal cost. Marginal revenue is below the price, as we saw in the last reading. So the price must be above marginal cost. A monopolist keeps a margin over marginal cost that no price-taker can. Reading 5 shows what determines how large that margin is.

Price is not as high as possible. It's tempting to think a monopolist charges whatever it can get away with. At $3 a ride, Ride On would sell only 20 rides and earn \(3\times20-(40+0.5\times20)=10\) dollars a day. A higher price means a larger margin on each ride but fewer rides. Ride On has to balance the margin on each ride against the number of rides, and the demand curve tells it how many rides it loses when it raises the price.

3.4

The most common errors

The first error is to use the competitive rule. Setting \(p=MC=0.5\) gives \(Q=140-40\times0.5=120\) rides. Revenue is \(0.5\times120=60\) and cost is \(40+0.5\times120=100\), so Ride On would lose $40 a day, exactly its rental. The competitive rule fails here because Ride On isn't a price-taker. It can sell 120 rides only by charging every child 50 cents.

The second error is to read the price off the wrong curve. At \(Q^m=60\), marginal revenue equals 0.5. That's the value of marginal cost, not the price. The price comes from the demand curve. On the graph, go up from 60 rides past the point where \(MR\) meets \(MC\), all the way to demand.

The third error is to think that a fixed cost, such as the rental, should change the price. A fixed cost is the same at every output, so it doesn't change marginal cost. It changes profit, but not the output where \(MR=MC\). Try it with a question.

Check the logic

Question 1 of 1

The mall raises Ride On's daily rental from $40 to $60. Electricity, maintenance and demand don't change. What should Ride On do?

Choose one answer.

3.5

When marginal cost changes

A change in marginal cost is different. Suppose the electricity price rises and the cost of one more ride goes from 50 cents to $1. Marginal revenue is unchanged, so

\(3.5-\dfrac{Q}{20}\)\(=\)\(1\)\(MR\) equals the new \(MC\).\(Q^m\)\(=\)\(50\)\(p^m\)\(=\)\(3.5-\dfrac{50}{40}=2.25\)Inverse demand.

Ride On sells ten fewer rides and raises its price from $2 to $2.25. Marginal cost rose by 50 cents, but the price rose by only 25 cents. Ride On passes on half the increase and absorbs the rest. Profit falls to \(2.25\times50-(40+1\times50)=22.50\) dollars.

Why not pass on all of it? A higher price loses customers, and Ride On was already balancing margin against volume. With linear demand, the monopoly price is halfway between the demand intercept and marginal cost, \(p^m=(3.5+MC)/2\), so it moves by half of any change in marginal cost.

Compare this with Week 3. When a battery component added $20,000 to the cost of every Auto Eco vehicle, the price rose by $10,000 in the short run and, once entry and exit had played out, by the full $20,000 in the long run. A monopolist's price changes because its \(MR=MC\) choice changes, not because firms enter or exit. So a monopolist absorbs part of a cost increase, while a competitive industry passes all of it on in the long run.

3.6

When capacity binds

Sometimes the firm can't produce the quantity the rule recommends. The logic still works, but the comparison happens at the limit, as it did for Auto Eco's capacity in Week 2.

A hotdog vendor holds the only license at a baseball stadium. At a sold-out game, demand is \(Q^d(p)=55{,}000-10{,}000p\), and the vendor's marginal cost is $1.50 a hotdog. Inverse demand is \(p(Q)=5.5-Q/10{,}000\), so by the linear rule \(MR(Q)=5.5-Q/5{,}000\). Setting \(MR=MC\) gives 20,000 hotdogs at $3.50.

Now suppose the vendor has a capacity to make 10,000 hotdogs in any given game. Should it sell them all? Compare marginal revenue with marginal cost at the limit:

\(MR(10{,}000)\)\(=\)\(5.5-\dfrac{10{,}000}{5{,}000}\)Marginal revenue at capacity.\(=\)\(3.5\)Above the marginal cost of 1.5.

Every hotdog up to the limit adds more to revenue than to cost, so the vendor sells all 10,000. It then charges the price at which 10,000 hotdogs sell, \(p(10{,}000)=5.5-1=4.50\). A tighter limit leads to a higher price, not to unsold hotdogs. The in-class exercise Fenway Hotdogs works through this case.

Summary

A monopolist expands while marginal revenue exceeds marginal cost. It produces \(Q^m\) where \(MR=MC\), charges \(p^m=p(Q^m)\) read from demand, and operates only if profit is at least zero. Ride On sells 60 rides at $2 and earns $50 a day. The price is above marginal cost but below the highest price buyers would pay. A fixed cost doesn't change the price; with linear demand, a monopolist passes on half of any change in marginal cost. With a capacity limit, compare \(MR\) and \(MC\) at the limit.

Concept atlas