Read 5 of 5

Elasticity and the markup

How large a markup can a firm sustain, and what does it depend on?

The pricing rule in Reading 3 used Ride On's whole demand curve. Real managers rarely know their whole demand curve. What they often know, from past price changes or from a market study, is something narrower: how strongly customers respond to a small price change around the price they charged historically.

Knowing the whole demand curve would be better, but this narrower information already gives a good idea of how to set the price. This reading defines that responsiveness, the price elasticity of demand, and shows how it determines how far above marginal cost a firm should set its price.

5.1

Measuring how strongly buyers respond

Why not just use the slope of demand? Because slope depends on units. Ride On's demand has slope \(dQ/dp=-40\): each dollar of price changes rides by 40. Measure the price in cents and the same demand has slope \(-0.4\). A firm comparing its markets in different countries, currencies and pack sizes needs a measure that doesn't change when the units do.

The asks a question in percentages instead: by what percentage does quantity demanded change when the price rises by one percent?

Price elasticity of demand\(\varepsilon=\dfrac{\Delta Q/Q}{\Delta p/p}=\dfrac{\Delta Q}{\Delta p}\times\dfrac{p}{Q}\)

For infinitesimally small changes, \(\Delta Q/\Delta p\) becomes \(dQ/dp\), the slope of the demand function. The second factor, \(p/Q\), converts the slope into percentages, and that's what removes the units.

Here's what it means for Ride On at its current price of $2 and 60 rides. A 1 percent price rise is 2 cents. Rides fall by \(40\times0.02=0.8\), which is \(0.8/60\approx1.33\) percent of 60. So \(\varepsilon=-1.33/1=-4/3\). Using the formula directly:

\(\varepsilon\)\(=\)\(-40\times\dfrac{2}{60}\)Slope times \(p/Q\).\(=\)\(-\tfrac43\)

Because demand slopes down, \(\varepsilon\) is negative. We keep the sign and compare sizes with \(|\varepsilon|\), so "more elastic" means further from zero.

ElasticityNameA 1% price rise
\(|\varepsilon|>1\)Lowers quantity by more than 1%, so revenue falls
\(|\varepsilon|=1\)Unit elasticLowers quantity by exactly 1%, so revenue is unchanged
\(|\varepsilon|\lt 1\)Lowers quantity by less than 1%, so revenue rises

Two extreme cases are useful. A vertical demand curve has \(\varepsilon=0\): quantity doesn't respond to price at all. A horizontal demand curve, like the one a price-taker faces, has \(\varepsilon\to-\infty\): any price above the market price loses every sale.

5.2

What makes demand elastic

The main driver is the availability of substitutes, the same condition that limits market power in Reading 1. When buyers have good alternatives, a price rise sends many of them elsewhere, and demand is elastic. When they don't, demand is inelastic.

Two other things matter. The first is time. Right after a fuel price rise, most drivers can't change their car or their commute, so demand for fuel responds little. Over several years they can buy smaller cars, move closer to work or take public transport, so demand is more elastic in the long run. The second is the share of the budget. A price rise on something that takes a small share of a buyer's spending, like salt, barely registers. The same percentage rise on rent or school fees gets much more attention.

In practice, firms estimate elasticities from data on past prices and sales. Market studies and statistical models often report elasticities directly, because they're the natural unit-free summary of demand. The U-Strap exercise shows how a manager can act on one such estimate, and how a revised estimate can reverse the decision.

5.3

Slope is not elasticity

Ride On's demand, \(Q^d(p)=140-40p\), has the same slope everywhere: \(dQ/dp=-40\). Its elasticity changes at every point, because the ratio \(p/Q\) falls as we move down the line.

\(\varepsilon\text{ at 20 rides}\)\(=\)\(-40\times\dfrac{3}{20}=-6\)Near the top: elastic.\(\varepsilon\text{ at 70 rides}\)\(=\)\(-40\times\dfrac{1.75}{70}=-1\)The midpoint: unit elastic.\(\varepsilon\text{ at 120 rides}\)\(=\)\(-40\times\dfrac{0.5}{120}=-\tfrac16\)Near the bottom: inelastic.

Near the top of the line, the price is high and few children ride, so a one-dollar change is a small percentage of the price and a large percentage of the rides. Near the bottom it's the reverse. So along a straight demand curve, the slope stays the same but the elasticity changes from point to point.

The midpoint, 70 rides, is where demand is unit elastic. Go back to the revenue graph in Reading 2: 70 rides is also where revenue peaks and where marginal revenue is zero. These are three descriptions of the same point.

Slope does matter when we compare two demand curves through the same point. Suppose a second study of Ride On's demand also passed through \(p=2\), \(Q=60\), but was flatter. Then each dollar of price change would move more rides, \(p/Q\) would be the same, and elasticity at that point would be larger in size. At a given price and quantity, flatter demand is more elastic.

Drag along the demand curve. Watch \(|\varepsilon|\) fall as you move down, and find where revenue peaks in the lower panel.

5.4

Marginal revenue in terms of elasticity

Start from the formula for marginal revenue in Reading 2 and factor out the price:

\(MR\)\(=\)\(p+Q\times\dfrac{dp}{dQ}\)From Reading 2.\(=\)\(p\left(1+\dfrac{Q}{p}\times\dfrac{dp}{dQ}\right)\)Factor out \(p\).\(=\)\(p\left(1+\dfrac{1}{\varepsilon}\right)\)The term in brackets is \(1/\varepsilon\).

The last step uses the definition of elasticity turned upside down: \(\dfrac{Q}{p}\times\dfrac{dp}{dQ}\) is the reciprocal of \(\dfrac{dQ}{dp}\times\dfrac{p}{Q}\).

This formula ties marginal revenue to the elasticity table. Where demand is elastic, \(1/\varepsilon\) lies between \(-1\) and 0, so \(MR>0\): selling more raises revenue. Where demand is unit elastic, \(MR=0\). Where demand is inelastic, \(1/\varepsilon\lt -1\), so \(MR\lt 0\): selling more lowers revenue.

Check it at Ride On's optimum: \(MR=2\left(1-\tfrac34\right)=0.5\), which is exactly \(MR(60)\) from Reading 2, and exactly marginal cost.

5.5

The markup rule

Now substitute this form of marginal revenue into the monopoly pricing rule \(MR=MC\):

\(p\left(1+\dfrac1\varepsilon\right)\)\(=\)\(MC\)\(MR=MC\).\(p+\dfrac{p}{\varepsilon}\)\(=\)\(MC\)Multiply out.\(p-MC\)\(=\)\(-\dfrac{p}{\varepsilon}\)Subtract \(MC\) and \(p/\varepsilon\) on both sides.\(\dfrac{p-MC}{p}\)\(=\)\(-\dfrac1\varepsilon\)Divide both sides by \(p\).

This is the . The left side is the markup: price minus marginal cost, as a share of the price. It's also called the Lerner index, and it's a direct measure of market power. The rule says that at the profit-maximizing price, the markup equals one over the size of the elasticity.

Ride On confirms it. At the optimum \(\varepsilon=-4/3\), so the rule predicts a markup of \(3/4\). The actual markup is \((2-0.5)/2=0.75\). The two routes agree because they're the same condition written in different terms.

The rule is most useful turned around, as a price in terms of marginal cost:

Elasticity at the optimumMarkup \((p-MC)/p\)Price
\(-1.25\)80%\(5\times MC\)
\(-2\)50%\(2\times MC\)
\(-4\)25%\(\tfrac43\times MC\)
\(-10\)10%\(\tfrac{10}{9}\times MC\)

Customers with good alternatives make demand elastic and allow only a thin markup. Customers without alternatives make demand inelastic and allow a large one. As \(|\varepsilon|\) grows without bound, the markup goes to zero and the price goes to marginal cost. That's the competitive rule from Week 2, so perfect competition is the limiting case of this rule rather than a separate theory.

One caution. The rule holds at the optimum, where the elasticity is measured at the optimal price. If you measure elasticity at today's price and today's price isn't optimal, the rule doesn't give the optimal price in one step. It tells you which direction to move: compare \(p(1+1/\varepsilon)\) with marginal cost, as the second question below does.

5.6

Never on the inelastic part of demand

The markup rule has an important implication. Marginal cost can't be negative, so at the optimum \(MR=MC\geq0\). But \(MR=p(1+1/\varepsilon)\) is non-negative only when \(|\varepsilon|\geq1\). So a profit-maximizing firm with market power always operates where demand is elastic, or unit elastic if its marginal cost is zero.

The intuition needs no algebra. If demand were inelastic at the current price, a price rise would increase revenue and reduce the quantity sold. Selling less means lower cost. Higher revenue and lower cost can only raise profit. So the firm would keep raising its price until demand became elastic.

Ride On is consistent with this: \(|\varepsilon|=4/3>1\) at its optimum. The result also gives managers a quick diagnostic. If a firm with market power reports that its customers barely respond to price, it should be raising its price. If it isn't, either the estimate or the pricing is wrong.

Use elasticity without the demand curve

Question 1 of 2

A product manager estimates that demand for her product has elasticity \(-0.6\) at the current price. She proposes a price cut to grow revenue. What should she do?

Choose one answer.

Summary

Price elasticity of demand, \(\varepsilon=(dQ/dp)(p/Q)\), measures responsiveness without units. It depends mainly on substitutes, and also on time and budget share. So along a straight demand curve, the slope stays the same but the elasticity changes from point to point. Marginal revenue is \(MR=p(1+1/\varepsilon)\), so the monopoly rule becomes the markup rule \((p-MC)/p=-1/\varepsilon\): the more elastic demand is, the thinner the markup. Because \(MC\geq0\), a profit-maximizing monopolist never operates where demand is inelastic.

Concept atlas