Read 4 of 5
Economic cost
Which resources are relevant, and what value should be attached to them?
In the previous reading, we saw that a producer's WTA is determined by the economic cost of supplying a good. Now we need to be precise about what that cost is.
A natural first guess is to look at the firm's accounts. Accounting records tell us what a firm has paid for things. A business decision, though, asks a different question: how would the firm's costs change if it went ahead? Answering it takes two steps. First, we identify the resources the decision actually affects. Then we put a value on each of them using its opportunity cost, which is the value of what the firm gives up by using the resource this way.
4.1
Accounting cost and economic cost
are the expenses a firm records in its financial statements, such as salaries, rent, and materials. These records are essential for running a business, but on their own they don't tell us which costs matter for a new decision. Economic cost differs from accounting cost in two ways.
First, economic cost includes costs that never appear on an invoice. When a firm uses a resource for one purpose, it gives up the chance to use it for something else. The value of that lost opportunity is a real cost, even if no money changes hands. We include it because the only sensible way to judge one use of a resource is to compare it with the best alternative. A building the firm owns still has a cost if it could have been rented out to someone else. An owner's time still has a cost if they could have earned a salary working elsewhere.
Second, economic cost leaves out payments that the decision doesn't change. A payment the firm has already committed to, such as rent on a lease it has already signed, shows up in the accounts whether or not the project goes ahead. Since the decision doesn't affect it, it shouldn't affect the decision.
Both points come from the same idea: economic cost is specific to the decision being made. To find it, we compare the firm's position with the project and without it. Anything that differs between the two belongs in the economic cost. Anything that stays the same doesn't.
4.2
Two questions
We work out the economic cost of a project in two stages. First, we identify which resources are relevant to the project. Then we decide how much each relevant resource is worth. Each stage answers one question.
Which resources can be avoided if the project isn't undertaken?
What is the opportunity cost of each avoidable resource?
The first question sorts resources into and unavoidable. Only avoidable resources count toward the project's cost, because unavoidable ones stay the same whether or not the project goes ahead. The second question puts a value on each avoidable resource using its . Together, the answers give us the economic cost of the project.
4.3
Avoidable and unavoidable resources
A resource is avoidable if, without the project, the firm could either stop paying for it or put it to another use. Either way, it's the project that ties the resource up. Its opportunity cost is a consequence of taking on the project, so it belongs in the project's economic cost.
A resource is if, without the project, the firm would neither save any money on it nor find another use for it. The firm's position with respect to that resource is the same whether or not the project goes ahead, so it doesn't count toward the project's economic cost.
The Wood Whisperer
The Wood Whisperer, established in 1927 in South Melbourne, produces custom furniture. The company has received an offer for a new project involving its best-known chair design. The project may require the following resources.
| Resource | Examples |
|---|---|
| Raw materials | Wood, adhesives and finishing materials |
| Labor | Skilled carpenters |
| Machinery and tools | Saws, sanders, drills, screwdrivers, paint sprayers and planers |
| Facility | Workshop or factory space |
| Utilities | Electricity, heating and cooling |
| Safety equipment | Goggles, gloves and masks |
| Packaging | Boxes and wrapping materials |
| Transportation | Transporting inputs to the factory and finished chairs to the customer |
Decide whether each statement is true or false before opening the explanation.
1. Raw materials are avoidable.
True. If the project is not implemented, the company does not need the wood, adhesives or finishing materials.
2. The current salaried carpenters are an avoidable resource.
False. The employees are paid a monthly salary and currently have enough unused time to complete the project. The company will pay their salaries whether or not it implements the project.
3. The underutilized workshop is unavoidable.
True. The company will continue paying for the workshop whether or not it implements the project.
4. Packaging is unavoidable.
False. The company needs boxes and wrapping materials only if it produces the chairs, so packaging is avoidable.
The classification depends on the circumstances. If the current carpenters were working at capacity, the project might require contract carpenters paid by the hour. That additional labor would be avoidable.
Which other resources in the table are avoidable? State the assumption behind each answer.
4.4
Opportunity cost
Once we have identified the relevant resources, we need to value them. The of a resource is the highest value it can generate among its alternative uses. Using the resource in the project means giving up that alternative value.
4.5
Economic cost
We can now put the two stages together. Start with a list of all the resources the project would use. Set aside the unavoidable ones, since the project doesn't change them. Then value each remaining resource at its opportunity cost and add these values up. The total is the project's economic cost.
Calculating cost this way is what makes it useful for decisions. Every item in the total reflects something the firm would actually give up by taking on the project, measured against the alternatives it really has. Nothing is included just because it appears in the accounts, and nothing is left out just because no money changes hands.
From this point onward, when we say cost without a qualifier, we mean economic cost. A cost function \(C(q)\) is therefore an economic cost function: it gives the economic cost of producing each quantity \(q\) for the decision and period we are studying. Average cost and marginal cost are calculated from that same economic cost function.
4.6
Prepare for class: Ted's Future
Read the Ted's Future case and its two questions before the session. Come to class ready to solve them with your syndicate group.
Summary