Week 01 · Complete notes
Value, exchange and economic cost
What makes an exchange possible?
This print edition combines all five readings. Interactive definitions become ordinary text when printed.
01
Economic value and exchange
When does an economic exchange occur?
Any bilateral economic exchange has two sides: a buyer who wants something and a seller who has it. Whether they end up trading depends on how much each of them values the good or service. So we start with the most fundamental concept: economic value.
We look at value from both sides. The buyer's value sets the most they would pay, which we'll call their willingness to pay. The seller's value sets the least they would accept, their willingness to accept. Comparing these two values tells us if and when an exchange can happen.
1.1
Why begin with value?
Every exchange involves a buyer and a seller. Whether they can trade depends on how much each of them values the good or service. If the buyer values it more than the seller does, there is room for both of them to come out ahead. If not, there isn't.
This is why value comes before price. Price is a term of exchange: one of the things the buyer and seller agree on when they trade. Its job is to split the gains from the exchange between them, not to create those gains. A higher price shifts some of the gain from the buyer to the seller, and a lower price shifts it back, but as long as the trade goes ahead, the total gain stays the same. That gain exists only because the buyer values the good more than the seller does.
Later, we'll use these same ideas to build demand and supply. For now, our question is narrower: in a single exchange between one buyer and one seller, what do their values tell us?
1.2
Economic value
The of a good or service is the benefit it provides to a person. We usually measure this benefit in money. That doesn't mean value is about money. Dollars are just a common yardstick. Without one, it would be hard to say whether a dinner out is worth more to you than a new pair of shoes. Measuring both in dollars lets you compare them directly when you decide what to do.
Economic value is subjective. The same good can be worth a lot to one person and very little to another, because people have different preferences, needs, and circumstances. Value can also change for the same person depending on the situation. An umbrella is worth more to you when it's pouring than on a sunny day, even though it's the same umbrella.
The value of a good is not its market price. Value and price answer different questions. Value tells us how much benefit a person gets from the good. Price tells us how much money changes hands if an exchange takes place. The two are connected, since the price affects whether someone decides to buy or sell, but neither determines the other. Two people can pay exactly the same price for a good and value it very differently.
1.3
Value to the buyer and value to the seller
For a buyer, value is the maximum amount the buyer is willing to pay for the good or service. We call this and denote it by \(\mathrm{WTP}\). If the price is above the buyer's WTP, buying the good isn't worthwhile for that buyer.
For a seller, value is the minimum amount the seller is willing to accept. We call this and denote it by \(\mathrm{WTA}\). For a producer, WTA is determined by the economic cost of supplying the good or service. We develop economic cost in Reading 4.
WTP and WTA are reservation values. They identify the limits within which the buyer and seller are prepared to exchange. Neither is determined by the price that the parties eventually agree upon.
Maximum amount the buyer is willing to pay.
Minimum amount the seller is willing to accept.
1.4
Surplus makes exchange possible
Suppose the buyer values a good more than the seller does. Then moving the good from the seller to the buyer creates value, because the good ends up with the person who gets more benefit from it. The difference between the two values is called the surplus from the exchange. This is the gain from exchange we mentioned earlier, and it's what the buyer and seller end up sharing.
An economic exchange can occur only when this surplus is positive, that is, when the buyer's WTP is greater than the seller's WTA. A positive surplus means the exchange creates something worth sharing. Because the buyer values the good more than the seller does, that extra value can be divided between them so that both end up better off than if they hadn't traded. If the surplus is zero, the exchange creates nothing to share. If it's negative, the exchange would destroy value. Either way, there is no way for both sides to gain.
This condition answers whether exchange is possible. It doesn't tell us the price. The method of exchange determines the price and therefore how the surplus is allocated.
1.5
In-class exercise: Anne and Brook's bicycle
Anne has owned her 1953 Bianchi Fulmine, a classic road bicycle, for years. Lately, though, she has had her eye on a new road-racing bike that costs $1,600, and she's started to wonder whether it's time to let the Bianchi go. She isn't in a hurry. After thinking it over, she decides she won't part with it for less than $1,300. She has also heard that a similar bicycle recently sold for $1,450 in a nearby town.
Brook's eighteenth birthday is coming up, and her grandmother has given her $2,000 to spend on something special. When Brook sees Anne's Bianchi, she falls in love with it. Still, she doesn't want to get carried away, so she sits down and thinks carefully about what the bike is really worth to her. She decides that the most she is willing to pay for it is $1,500.
We will discuss this problem in class.
Summary. Economic value is the benefit a good or service provides. WTP and WTA measure the buyer's and seller's values and determine whether exchange is possible.
02
Price, surplus and methods of exchange
How are the terms of exchange determined?
In the previous reading, we saw that an exchange is possible when it creates a positive surplus. But knowing that both sides could gain doesn't settle the deal. The buyer and seller still have to agree on the terms of exchange: what the buyer pays and, sometimes, other conditions as well. Most of the time, the key term is the price.
There are several ways to arrive at the terms. Markets, auctions, and bargaining each do it differently, and we look at each below. Whatever the method, the price it produces determines how the surplus is divided between the buyer and the seller.
2.1
Price allocates the surplus
When the buyer's WTP exceeds the seller's WTA, there isn't just one price that works. There is a whole range of prices at which the exchange is worthwhile for both sides. The price must be above the seller's WTA, since otherwise the seller would rather keep the good. It must also be below the buyer's WTP, since otherwise the buyer would rather keep their money. Any price between these two limits leaves both sides better off than if they didn't trade. Writing \(p\) for the price, we can express this as follows.
At any price in this range, both sides come out ahead, and we can measure by how much. The buyer pays less than the most they were willing to pay. The difference between their WTP and the price is buyer surplus. Think of it as what the buyer saves compared with the most they'd have paid, and so how much better off the exchange makes them. Likewise, the seller receives more than the least they were willing to accept. The difference between the price and their WTA is seller surplus, which measures how much better off the exchange makes the seller.
Adding buyer surplus and seller surplus gives:
The price cancels out. This makes sense: every dollar the buyer pays is a dollar the seller receives, so the price simply moves money from one side to the other. A higher price adds to seller surplus exactly what it takes away from buyer surplus. So the price changes how the surplus is divided, but not how much surplus the exchange creates. That total is the same surplus we met in the previous reading, and it depends only on the buyer's WTP and the seller's WTA.
2.2
Markets
A is any system or setting where buyers and sellers come together to exchange goods and services. Markets for raw materials such as wheat or oil, online marketplaces and shopping malls are all markets, but each organizes exchange in its own way. How a market is organized determines how the price is set.
A stock exchange is a highly organized market with many buyers and sellers. Suppose a company's shares are trading at $50 each. An investor who places an order to buy 100 shares at the current price pays $50 per share, or $5,000 in total. A shareholder who sells 100 shares at that price receives $5,000.
The buyer and seller never meet or negotiate. The exchange matches buy orders with sell orders, and no single buyer or seller sets the $50. It's the price at which orders are currently being matched. Each trader simply takes this price as given and decides whether to trade at it. An investor buys only if a share is worth more than $50 to them, and a shareholder sells only if it's worth less than $50 to them. Either way, the $50 market price is the term of exchange, and it determines how the surplus from each trade is divided.
2.3
Auctions and tenders
An uses a set of announced rules to decide who gets the good and what they pay. The rules matter. Different auction formats give bidders different reasons to bid high or low, so they can lead to different prices and therefore a different division of the surplus.
Consider a first-price sealed-bid auction. Each bidder submits a single bid in secret, without seeing anyone else's. Once all the bids are in, they are opened together. The highest bidder wins and pays exactly what they bid, so the winning bid is the price.
Think about what this means for the winner. Their surplus is their WTP minus their bid. A bidder who bids their full WTP gains nothing from winning, since they pay the most they were willing to pay. So bidders in this format have a reason to bid less than their WTP. How much less depends on what they expect the others to bid.
A tender works the same way in reverse. A buyer invites several potential sellers to submit bids, and the sellers compete for the business. The lowest bid usually wins, although the buyer may weigh other factors, such as quality or delivery time, alongside price. Governments often use tenders when they buy goods and services, and so do large businesses. In a tender, the winning seller's bid is the term of exchange, and the seller's surplus is their bid minus their WTA.
2.4
Bargaining
In , the buyer and seller settle the terms by dealing with each other directly. One side makes an offer, the other responds, and each can adjust their position as they go. If they reach terms both find acceptable, the exchange takes place. If not, it doesn't.
Consider a salary negotiation. The job seeker is the seller here, offering their labor, and the employer is the buyer. The job seeker opens by asking for $80,000. The employer counters with $70,000. The job seeker then proposes $77,000 plus some additional benefits. After several more rounds, they settle on $75,000 plus a performance-based bonus.
This compensation package is the price, or term of exchange, for the job seeker's labor. Notice that the opening positions are not WTP and WTA. The job seeker asked for $80,000 but ended up accepting less, so $80,000 was not their WTA. The employer offered $70,000 but ended up paying more, so $70,000 was not their WTP. Opening offers are moves in the negotiation, and neither side has a reason to reveal their true limit, since doing so would help the other side claim more of the surplus. What we can say for sure is that the final package is worth more to the job seeker than their WTA and less to the employer than their WTP. Otherwise, one of them would have walked away.
The example also shows that the terms of exchange don't have to be a single payment. Here they combine a salary and a bonus.
2.5
The dolabra dealer: exchange, allocation and incentives
You're an antique dealer who specializes in Roman antiquities. One week, two people approach you separately, each hoping to sell a dolabra, the axe-and-pick tool Roman legionaries carried for digging and building their camps. One belongs to Dr. Elizabeth Harrow, a respected historian. The other belongs to Dr. Nathan Calder, a well-known archaeologist. You inspect both and find them in comparable condition, so to a buyer, one is as good as the other. Dr. Harrow tells you she won't sell hers for less than $25,000. Dr. Calder won't part with his for less than $50,000.
Next, you go looking for buyers and find two interested collectors, Mr. Smith and Mrs. Blackwood. Each wants one dolabra. After long conversations and a close look at both pieces, you work out that Mr. Smith would pay up to $40,000, while Mrs. Blackwood would pay up to $60,000.
Your role is to bring a buyer and a seller together so they can negotiate a sale. You decide who meets whom.
Select a pair to compare the buyer's WTP with the seller's WTA.
Questions
Use the interactive graph to answer the following questions.
Which buyer-seller pairs could make an economic exchange?
Three pairs can create a positive surplus. Smith and Harrow create $15,000, Blackwood and Harrow create $35,000, and Blackwood and Calder create $10,000. Smith and Calder can't make an economic exchange because Smith's $40,000 WTP is below Calder's $50,000 WTA.
Is there a single price at which both dolabras could be sold?
No. To sell both dolabras, Smith must buy from Harrow and Blackwood must buy from Calder. A price for the Smith-Harrow exchange must lie between $25,000 and $40,000. A price for the Blackwood-Calder exchange must lie between $50,000 and $60,000. These ranges don't overlap, so no single price works for both sales.
Which pairs should you bring together to maximize the total surplus of all four people?
Bring Blackwood and Harrow together. Their exchange creates $35,000 of surplus. If both dolabras are sold, Smith must buy from Harrow and Blackwood from Calder. Those two sales create only $25,000 in total surplus. So one sale creates more total surplus than two.
You earn $1,000 for each completed sale, with $500 paid by the buyer and $500 by the seller. Which pairs do you bring together?
Arrange two sales: Smith buys from Harrow and Blackwood buys from Calder. Each pair creates enough surplus to cover the $1,000 fee. You earn $2,000 in total, which is more than the $1,000 you would earn from arranging only the Blackwood-Harrow sale. Smith and Calder cannot trade because Smith's WTP is below Calder's WTA.
Suppose instead that you earn 5% of the surplus each sale creates. Which pairs do you bring together now?
Bring Blackwood and Harrow together. Their $35,000 surplus pays you $1,750. The two-sale matching creates $25,000 in total surplus and pays you $1,250. The percentage fee makes the single high-surplus exchange more profitable for you.
Compare your answers to Questions 3, 4, and 5. What does this suggest about how an intermediary should be paid?
A fee per transaction rewards the number of exchanges, even when arranging more exchanges creates less total surplus. A percentage of surplus rewards the intermediary for creating more total surplus. If the goal is to align the intermediary's choice with the interests of the group, the percentage fee works better in this example.
Summary. WTP and WTA determine the available surplus. Price allocates it, while the method of exchange determines how the parties reach the terms.
03
Determinants of economic value
Why does economic value differ across people and organizations?
So far, we've used WTP and WTA to measure how much a good or service is worth to a buyer and to a seller. These measures tell us how large each side's value is, but not where it comes from. Why is a bicycle worth a lot to one person and very little to another? Why can one firm supply a product more cheaply than another? This reading looks at what lies behind these values.
For consumers, value comes from their preferences: what they like, what they need, and the situation they're in. For producers, value comes from what it takes to supply the good or service, namely the resources and technology used to make it and bring it to buyers.
3.1
Value, price and income
Earlier in our discussion, we saw that value and price are different things. It's worth returning to this, because the two are easy to confuse. The market price is the amount paid if an exchange takes place. A lower price is good news for the buyer, since it leaves them a larger share of the surplus. But it doesn't change how much the good is worth to them, so their WTP stays the same. Likewise, a higher price is good news for the seller, but it doesn't change the least they would accept, so their WTA stays the same. Price affects how the surplus is allocated, not the values that create it.
Income is also different from value. Someone may value a good highly and still be unable to afford it. Their budget limits what they can buy, while their WTP measures how much the good is worth to them. The two can differ in either direction. A person with a large budget may place little value on a particular good, and a person with a small budget may value it highly. A budget tells us what someone can spend, not what a good is worth to them.
There are two exceptions to keep in mind. First, when you're unsure how much a good is worth, its market price can tell you something, because it reflects what other people were willing to pay. In that case, the price can shape your value. Second, if you buy something planning to resell it, the price you expect to get later is part of what it's worth to you. Outside these cases, we treat price the way we did in the previous reading: it allocates the surplus from an exchange but doesn't create value.
3.2
Preferences and needs
A basic source of consumer value is personal preference: what a person likes and dislikes. Preferences are shaped by culture, upbringing, and personal experience, and they can change over time. All of these affect the benefit a person expects to get from a good. A vegetarian and someone who enjoys meat, for example, can place very different values on the same steak.
Needs matter too, because a good's value depends on what it allows a person to do. A medicine that treats an illness is highly valuable to someone who has that illness. To someone who doesn't, the same medicine may be worth little or nothing.
These differences aren't mistakes, and they aren't random noise around some "true" value. There is no single correct value for a good. Because economic value is subjective, it's entirely natural for different consumers to have different WTPs for the same good. As economists, we take people's preferences as they are, rather than judging whether they should value something more or less.
3.3
Situation, behavior and market conditions
Value can change with the situation. As we saw in the first reading, an umbrella is worth more on a rainy day than on a clear one. The umbrella hasn't changed. What has changed is the person's circumstances, and with them the benefit the umbrella provides.
Behavioral factors can also affect value. Branding, advertising, and other psychological influences can change how much a person values a good. Someone may value a handbag more highly because it carries a luxury brand name, even when an unbranded bag of the same quality is available. In that case, the brand isn't just a label. It's part of what the consumer values.
Market conditions can matter as well. When a good is hard to get, having it now can be worth more, because the chance may not come again. When a good is plentiful, there's no rush, and that urgency fades. Limited-edition goods are a familiar example: part of their appeal is that few people own them. Be careful not to confuse this with price. A shortage can also push the market price up, and we'll study that effect in Week 2. The point here is different. Scarcity can change how much the good is worth to the consumer, which changes their WTP, not just what they end up paying.
3.4
Substitutes and complements
The value of a good also depends on other goods related to it. Related goods come in two kinds.
A substitute is a different good that meets the same need. Tea can substitute for coffee, and a bus can substitute for a taxi. When a good has close substitutes, the consumer has other options. If they couldn't get this particular product, they could turn to another that does the job almost as well. That makes this one product worth less to them than it would be if nothing else could take its place.
A complement is a good that is used together with another good. A printer and its ink cartridges are complements: a printer is useful only if you have ink for it. So a printer is worth more when compatible cartridges are easy to get. If the cartridges become hard to find, the printer provides less benefit, even though the printer itself hasn't changed.
Substitutes and complements will come back when we study how consumers decide to spend their income across different goods and services in Week 2.
3.5
Producer value
A producer makes a good or service in order to sell it, not to use it. So the least a producer will accept is set by what it costs to supply the good. That cost depends on the resources used in production and the technology used to combine them. If the price doesn't cover this cost, the producer is better off not supplying at all. The market price still matters, since it determines how much the producer gains from a sale. But, as with consumers, price isn't the source of value. It only allocates the surplus.
Not every seller is a producer. When someone sells something they already own, as Anne does with her bicycle, their WTA comes from how much they value keeping it. That is consumer value, and everything in the previous sections applies.
Several factors shape a producer's cost of supply, and therefore their WTA.
Production cost. Producers use inputs such as labor, capital (machinery, equipment, and buildings), and raw materials. Together, these determine the cost of supplying the good. If an input the producer needs becomes more costly, the producer's WTA is likely to rise.
Technology. Better technology lets a producer make the same output with fewer resources. Automation, for example, can reduce the amount of labor needed, which lowers the cost of supply and therefore lowers WTA.
Rules and regulations. Laws and regulations can change what production requires. Stricter environmental rules, for example, may mean new equipment or extra monitoring. Meeting these requirements uses resources, which raises the cost of supply and therefore raises WTA.
Access to markets. Getting a product to buyers also takes resources, such as transport and storage. Good distribution networks, and trade agreements that make it easier to sell in other countries, lower these costs and therefore lower WTA.
So far, we've used "cost" loosely. To be precise, we need to know exactly what economic cost includes. That is the subject of the next reading.
Summary. Preferences, needs and circumstances shape value to the buyer. Resources and technology shape value to the seller.
04
Economic cost
Which resources are relevant, and what value should be attached to them?
In the previous reading, we saw that a producer's WTA is determined by the economic cost of supplying a good. Now we need to be precise about what that cost is.
A natural first guess is to look at the firm's accounts. Accounting records tell us what a firm has paid for things. A business decision, though, asks a different question: how would the firm's costs change if it went ahead? Answering it takes two steps. First, we identify the resources the decision actually affects. Then we put a value on each of them using its opportunity cost, which is the value of what the firm gives up by using the resource this way.
4.1
Accounting cost and economic cost
are the expenses a firm records in its financial statements, such as salaries, rent, and materials. These records are essential for running a business, but on their own they don't tell us which costs matter for a new decision. Economic cost differs from accounting cost in two ways.
First, economic cost includes costs that never appear on an invoice. When a firm uses a resource for one purpose, it gives up the chance to use it for something else. The value of that lost opportunity is a real cost, even if no money changes hands. We include it because the only sensible way to judge one use of a resource is to compare it with the best alternative. A building the firm owns still has a cost if it could have been rented out to someone else. An owner's time still has a cost if they could have earned a salary working elsewhere.
Second, economic cost leaves out payments that the decision doesn't change. A payment the firm has already committed to, such as rent on a lease it has already signed, shows up in the accounts whether or not the project goes ahead. Since the decision doesn't affect it, it shouldn't affect the decision.
Both points come from the same idea: economic cost is specific to the decision being made. To find it, we compare the firm's position with the project and without it. Anything that differs between the two belongs in the economic cost. Anything that stays the same doesn't.
4.2
Two questions
We work out the economic cost of a project in two stages. First, we identify which resources are relevant to the project. Then we decide how much each relevant resource is worth. Each stage answers one question.
Which resources can be avoided if the project isn't undertaken?
What is the opportunity cost of each avoidable resource?
The first question sorts resources into and unavoidable. Only avoidable resources count toward the project's cost, because unavoidable ones stay the same whether or not the project goes ahead. The second question puts a value on each avoidable resource using its . Together, the answers give us the economic cost of the project.
4.3
Avoidable and unavoidable resources
A resource is avoidable if, without the project, the firm could either stop paying for it or put it to another use. Either way, it's the project that ties the resource up. Its opportunity cost is a consequence of taking on the project, so it belongs in the project's economic cost.
A resource is if, without the project, the firm would neither save any money on it nor find another use for it. The firm's position with respect to that resource is the same whether or not the project goes ahead, so it doesn't count toward the project's economic cost.
The Wood Whisperer
The Wood Whisperer, established in 1927 in South Melbourne, produces custom furniture. The company has received an offer for a new project involving its best-known chair design. The project may require the following resources.
| Resource | Examples |
|---|---|
| Raw materials | Wood, adhesives and finishing materials |
| Labor | Skilled carpenters |
| Machinery and tools | Saws, sanders, drills, screwdrivers, paint sprayers and planers |
| Facility | Workshop or factory space |
| Utilities | Electricity, heating and cooling |
| Safety equipment | Goggles, gloves and masks |
| Packaging | Boxes and wrapping materials |
| Transportation | Transporting inputs to the factory and finished chairs to the customer |
Decide whether each statement is true or false before opening the explanation.
1. Raw materials are avoidable.
True. If the project is not implemented, the company does not need the wood, adhesives or finishing materials.
2. The current salaried carpenters are an avoidable resource.
False. The employees are paid a monthly salary and currently have enough unused time to complete the project. The company will pay their salaries whether or not it implements the project.
3. The underutilized workshop is unavoidable.
True. The company will continue paying for the workshop whether or not it implements the project.
4. Packaging is unavoidable.
False. The company needs boxes and wrapping materials only if it produces the chairs, so packaging is avoidable.
The classification depends on the circumstances. If the current carpenters were working at capacity, the project might require contract carpenters paid by the hour. That additional labor would be avoidable.
Which other resources in the table are avoidable? State the assumption behind each answer.
4.4
Opportunity cost
Once we have identified the relevant resources, we need to value them. The of a resource is the highest value it can generate among its alternative uses. Using the resource in the project means giving up that alternative value.
4.5
Economic cost
We can now put the two stages together. Start with a list of all the resources the project would use. Set aside the unavoidable ones, since the project doesn't change them. Then value each remaining resource at its opportunity cost and add these values up. The total is the project's economic cost.
Calculating cost this way is what makes it useful for decisions. Every item in the total reflects something the firm would actually give up by taking on the project, measured against the alternatives it really has. Nothing is included just because it appears in the accounts, and nothing is left out just because no money changes hands.
From this point onward, when we say cost without a qualifier, we mean economic cost. A cost function \(C(q)\) is therefore an economic cost function: it gives the economic cost of producing each quantity \(q\) for the decision and period we are studying. Average cost and marginal cost are calculated from that same economic cost function.
4.6
Prepare for class: Ted's Future
Read the Ted's Future case and its two questions before the session. Come to class ready to solve them with your syndicate group.
Summary. Identify the avoidable resources required by the decision and value each one at its opportunity cost.
05
Cost functions, average cost and marginal cost
How does economic cost change with output?
In the previous reading, we worked out the economic cost of a single project. Firms usually face a broader question: how much should they produce? To answer it, we need to know the economic cost of every possible level of output. A cost function gives us exactly that.
We start with a simple case, a bakery whose cost rises by the same amount with every extra loaf. Then we look at what happens when each extra loaf costs more than the one before.
Finally, we introduce two tools for analyzing a cost function, each answering a different question. Average cost tells us the cost per unit. Marginal cost tells us how much cost increases when we produce more.
5.1
The economic cost function
Let \(q\) stand for the quantity of a good or service a firm produces. We write the economic cost of producing \(q\) units as , read “\(C\) of \(q\).” For example, \(C(100)\) is the cost of producing 100 units. A cost function lets us compare different production plans and see how cost changes when output changes.
Costs come in two kinds. A stays the same no matter how much the firm produces, like the rent on a shop. A rises or falls with output, like the ingredients a bakery uses. Two qualifications matter. A cost is fixed only over a given period: rent may be fixed for a month but not over five years. It is also fixed only over a given range of output: if the bakery grew enough to need a second shop, its rent would change.
Total cost is fixed cost plus variable cost. Variable cost depends on \(q\), so we write it as \(VC(q)\), while fixed cost is written simply as \(FC\):
Fixed isn't the same as . The two words answer different questions. A cost is fixed if it doesn't change with how much the firm produces. A cost is if the firm could escape it by making a different decision. So a cost can be fixed and avoidable at the same time. Take a bakery's rent. It's fixed because it doesn't depend on how many loaves the bakery bakes. But if the owner is deciding whether to stay open at all and could end the lease or sublet the shop, the rent is avoidable.
Fixed costs often arise because some commitments can't be changed quickly. A signed lease or an equipment contract ties the firm in for a while, even if it would like to get out. Over a longer period, these commitments can be renegotiated or ended. We'll return to this distinction between the short run and the long run in Week 2.
Every term in \(C(q)\) is an economic cost in the sense of the previous reading. The cost function includes only the costs relevant to the production decision we're studying, not every expense that appears in the firm's accounts. That's why it matters which decision we have in mind. Fixed costs don't change with how much the bakery produces, so they can't help it choose between baking 100 loaves and 200. They do matter when the question is whether to open for the month at all.
5.2
The bakery's fixed and variable costs
Consider a small bakery that makes specialty sourdough bread. Each month, it pays $2,000 in rent, $500 to lease a commercial oven and $300 for insurance. It also pays its full-time manager a salary of $3,000 a month. None of these costs depends on how many loaves the bakery bakes, at least over the month and the range of output we're considering. They are the bakery's fixed costs.
| Monthly fixed cost | Amount |
|---|---|
| Rent | $2,000 |
| Equipment lease | $500 |
| Insurance | $300 |
| Manager's salary | $3,000 |
| Total fixed cost | $5,800 |
The bakery also has costs that depend on how many loaves it bakes. For each loaf, it spends $0.50 on flour, $0.10 on yeast, $0.05 on salt, $0.15 on other ingredients, $0.20 on packaging and $0.25 on utilities such as electricity for the oven. It also needs labor. The bakery employs part-time bakers at $15 an hour, and each loaf takes 0.25 hours (15 minutes) of their time. Because the bakers are paid only for the hours they work, labor is a variable cost too: \(\$15\times0.25=\$3.75\) per loaf.
| Variable cost per loaf | Amount |
|---|---|
| Ingredients | $0.80 |
| Packaging | $0.20 |
| Part-time labor | $3.75 |
| Utilities | $0.25 |
| Total per loaf | $5.00 |
Each loaf therefore adds $5.00 to the bakery's variable cost. If the bakery bakes 100 loaves, its variable cost is \(100\times\$5=\$500\). If it bakes 200 loaves, its variable cost is $1,000. Doubling output doubles variable cost. In other words, variable cost rises in direct proportion to output, and we can write it as \(VC(q)=5q\).
5.3
A linear cost function
Putting the pieces together, the bakery's fixed cost is $5,800 a month and its variable cost is $5 per loaf. If \(q\) is the number of loaves it bakes in a month, its cost function is:
At 100 loaves, total cost is \(C(100)=5{,}800+5(100)=\$6{,}300\). At 200 loaves, it's \(C(200)=5{,}800+5(200)=\$6{,}800\). Baking the extra 100 loaves adds $500 of variable cost, but the fixed cost of $5,800 stays the same.
More generally, a linear cost function has the form \(C(q)=a+bq\), where \(a\) and \(b\) are numbers that describe a particular firm. We call them parameters. The parameter \(a\) is the fixed cost, what we wrote as \(FC\) earlier, and \(b\) is the variable cost per unit. For the bakery, \(a=5{,}800\) and \(b=5\).
The function is called linear because its graph is a straight line. The line starts at \(a\) when \(q=0\): even if the bakery bakes nothing, it still pays its fixed costs. From there, each extra unit adds \(b\) to total cost, so \(b\) is the slope of the line. Raising \(a\) shifts the whole line up without changing its slope. Raising \(b\) makes the line steeper because each extra unit now adds more to total cost.
The linear form works well when each extra unit costs the same amount to produce, at least over the range of output we care about. It's a simplification. Whether it's a good one depends on the production process. For some businesses, the cost of each extra unit really is roughly constant. For others, as we'll see next, it isn't.
5.4
Crowding and a quadratic cost
So far, we've assumed that every loaf costs the same $5 to make. That isn't always realistic. The bakery has one oven, one proofing area and limited bench space, and none of these grows when the bakery bakes more. With each extra loaf, the kitchen gets a little busier. Bakers wait longer for the oven, work around each other and spend more time moving trays between batches. As a result, each additional loaf takes slightly more labor time than the one before, and so costs slightly more to make.
A convenient way to capture this is to add a term \(cq^2\) to the cost function, where \(c\) is a positive number. Because the new term contains \(q\) squared, we call the result a quadratic cost function:
The fixed cost is still \(a\). The term \(bq\) covers the costs that are the same for every loaf: ingredients, packaging, utilities and the labor a loaf would need in an uncrowded kitchen. The term \(cq^2\) captures the extra cost of crowding. Because \(q\) is squared, this extra cost grows faster than output: doubling the number of loaves quadruples the crowding cost. The parameter \(c\) measures how severe the crowding is. A bigger kitchen or a second oven would mean a smaller \(c\).
For the bakery, \(a=5{,}800\) and \(b=5\). Setting \(c=0\) takes us back to the linear cost function, an uncrowded kitchen where every loaf costs the same. A positive \(c\) adds the cost of crowding. Use the interactive cost explorer to change all three parameters and see how the cost function responds.
5.5
Average cost
A cost function tells us the total cost of producing \(q\) units. Often we also want to know the cost per unit. That's , and we find it by dividing total cost by the number of units:
For the bakery, \(C(q)=5{,}800+5q\). Dividing each term by \(q\) gives:
At 100 loaves, average cost is \(\frac{5{,}800}{100}+5=58+5=\$63\) per loaf. At 200 loaves, it falls to \(29+5=\$34\) per loaf.
The two pieces of this formula have names. The first, \(5{,}800/q\), is average fixed cost: the bakery's fixed cost spread across all the loaves it bakes. The second, \(5\), is average variable cost: the variable cost per loaf, which for the bakery is the same at every level of output.
Notice what drives the fall in average cost. Average variable cost stays at $5. What changes is average fixed cost. When the bakery bakes only a few loaves, the $5,800 is shared among a small number of them, so each loaf carries a large share. As output grows, the same fixed cost is spread over more loaves, and each loaf's share shrinks. In general, average fixed cost \(a/q\) falls as \(q\) rises.
Average fixed cost falls; average variable cost is constant.
Average fixed cost falls while the quadratic component rises.
5.6
Marginal cost
tells us how much total cost rises when a firm produces more. How we calculate it depends on how output is measured.
Some goods come in whole units that we count, such as cakes, cars or loaves of bread. We call this discrete output. Here, the marginal cost of producing one more unit is the difference between two total costs:
Read \(MC(q)\) as the cost of going from \(q\) units to \(q+1\). So the marginal cost of the tenth unit is \(MC(9)=C(10)-C(9)\).
Suppose a firm can make nine units for $180, and the tenth unit has a marginal cost of $40. Then ten units cost $180 + $40 = $220. Notice what happens to average cost: it rises from $180/9 = $20 to $220/10 = $22. The tenth unit cost more than the average of the first nine, so it pulled the average up. We return to this later in the reading.
Other outputs, such as electricity, water or chemicals, can be produced in any quantity, not just whole units. We call this continuous output. Here, it makes more sense to look at a small change in output, which we write as \(\Delta\), the Greek letter delta, commonly used to mean “change.” If output rises from \(q\) to \(q+\Delta\), marginal cost is the change in cost per unit of extra output:
As \(\Delta\) gets smaller and smaller, this ratio settles on a single number: the rate at which cost is rising at exactly \(q\). In calculus, this number is called the derivative of the cost function. The next two sections work it out step by step for our two cost functions.
The results are simple. For a linear cost function, marginal cost is \(b\): every extra unit adds the same amount to cost. For the bakery, that's $5 per loaf. For a quadratic cost function, marginal cost is \(b+2cq\), which rises as \(q\) grows. This is the crowded kitchen at work: the more loaves the bakery is already baking, the more the next one costs.
Each additional unit adds the same amount to cost.
Marginal cost changes with output.
5.7
Deriving marginal cost for the linear function
Apply the change-in-cost formula to \(C(q)=a+bq\). First replace \(q\) with \(q+\Delta\) and expand:
Subtract \(C(q)=a+bq\):
Divide by \(\Delta\):
The result doesn't depend on the size of the output change. Each additional unit adds \(b\) to total cost. The fixed cost \(a\) cancels because it doesn't change with output.
5.8
Deriving marginal cost for the quadratic function
We can see where \(b+2cq\) comes from by applying the change-in-cost formula to \(C(q)=a+bq+cq^2\). First replace \(q\) with \(q+\Delta\), then expand and collect terms:
Now subtract \(C(q)=a+bq+cq^2\):
Divide by \(\Delta\):
When output is continuous, \(\Delta\) approaches zero. The final term disappears, leaving \(MC(q)=b+2cq\). Notice that fixed cost \(a\) doesn't appear in marginal cost because it doesn't change when output changes.
5.9
The relationship between average and marginal cost
Average cost and marginal cost answer different questions. Average cost asks: at the current level of output, how much does each unit cost on average? Marginal cost asks: if we produce more, how much does total cost go up?
The two are linked by the same logic that applies to any average. If the next unit costs less than the current average, adding it pulls the average down. If it costs more, it pushes the average up. We saw this in the previous section: the tenth unit cost $40, well above the $20 average, and average cost rose to $22.
So there is a simple rule. When marginal cost is below average cost, average cost is falling. When marginal cost is above average cost, average cost is rising.
This rule tells us where average cost is lowest. Suppose average cost first falls and then rises, as it does with the bakery's quadratic cost function. At the very bottom, average cost is neither falling nor rising. Marginal cost can't be below average cost there, or the average would still be falling. It can't be above it either, or the average would already be rising. So at the output \(q^*\) where average cost is lowest, the two are equal:
(If you know calculus, you can show that this is the first-order condition for minimizing average cost.)
This equality holds only when average cost actually reaches a lowest point within the range of output the firm can produce, and that isn't always the case. Take the linear cost function \(C(q)=a+bq\) with a positive fixed cost. Average cost is \(a/q+b\) and marginal cost is \(b\). Since \(a/q\) is positive at any output, average cost is always above marginal cost. For the bakery, average cost is always more than $5 per loaf, getting closer to $5 as output grows and the fixed cost is spread more thinly. Average cost keeps falling and never reaches a lowest point, so the two never meet.
The equality can also fail in other situations: when output comes in whole units, so it jumps rather than changing smoothly; when average cost is lowest at the largest output the firm can produce; or when the average-cost curve has a sharp corner. In all of these cases, though, the basic rule still holds. Marginal cost below average cost pulls the average down, and marginal cost above average cost pushes it up.
Summary. C(q) is a cost function. \(AC(q)\) is the cost per unit when \(q\) units are produced, and \(MC(q)\) is the cost of additional output at production level \(q\). If \(AC(q)\) is differentiable and reaches its minimum at \(q^*\) inside the feasible output range, then \(MC(q^*)=AC(q^*)\). This equality need not occur with discrete output or a boundary minimum.