Read 1 of 5

Economic value and exchange

When does an economic exchange occur?

Any bilateral economic exchange has two sides: a buyer who wants something and a seller who has it. Whether they end up trading depends on how much each of them values the good or service. So we start with the most fundamental concept: economic value.

We look at value from both sides. The buyer's value sets the most they would pay, which we'll call their willingness to pay. The seller's value sets the least they would accept, their willingness to accept. Comparing these two values tells us if and when an exchange can happen.

1.1

Why begin with value?

Every exchange involves a buyer and a seller. Whether they can trade depends on how much each of them values the good or service. If the buyer values it more than the seller does, there is room for both of them to come out ahead. If not, there isn't.

This is why value comes before price. Price is a term of exchange: one of the things the buyer and seller agree on when they trade. Its job is to split the gains from the exchange between them, not to create those gains. A higher price shifts some of the gain from the buyer to the seller, and a lower price shifts it back, but as long as the trade goes ahead, the total gain stays the same. That gain exists only because the buyer values the good more than the seller does.

Later, we'll use these same ideas to build demand and supply. For now, our question is narrower: in a single exchange between one buyer and one seller, what do their values tell us?

1.2

Economic value

The of a good or service is the benefit it provides to a person. We usually measure this benefit in money. That doesn't mean value is about money. Dollars are just a common yardstick. Without one, it would be hard to say whether a dinner out is worth more to you than a new pair of shoes. Measuring both in dollars lets you compare them directly when you decide what to do.

Economic value is subjective. The same good can be worth a lot to one person and very little to another, because people have different preferences, needs, and circumstances. Value can also change for the same person depending on the situation. An umbrella is worth more to you when it's pouring than on a sunny day, even though it's the same umbrella.

The value of a good is not its market price. Value and price answer different questions. Value tells us how much benefit a person gets from the good. Price tells us how much money changes hands if an exchange takes place. The two are connected, since the price affects whether someone decides to buy or sell, but neither determines the other. Two people can pay exactly the same price for a good and value it very differently.

1.3

Value to the buyer and value to the seller

For a buyer, value is the maximum amount the buyer is willing to pay for the good or service. We call this and denote it by \(\mathrm{WTP}\). If the price is above the buyer's WTP, buying the good isn't worthwhile for that buyer.

For a seller, value is the minimum amount the seller is willing to accept. We call this and denote it by \(\mathrm{WTA}\). For a producer, WTA is determined by the economic cost of supplying the good or service. We develop economic cost in Reading 4.

WTP and WTA are reservation values. They identify the limits within which the buyer and seller are prepared to exchange. Neither is determined by the price that the parties eventually agree upon.

Value to the buyer\(\mathrm{WTP}\)

Maximum amount the buyer is willing to pay.

Value to the seller\(\mathrm{WTA}\)

Minimum amount the seller is willing to accept.

1.4

Surplus makes exchange possible

Suppose the buyer values a good more than the seller does. Then moving the good from the seller to the buyer creates value, because the good ends up with the person who gets more benefit from it. The difference between the two values is called the surplus from the exchange. This is the gain from exchange we mentioned earlier, and it's what the buyer and seller end up sharing.

Surplus from exchange\(S=\mathrm{WTP}-\mathrm{WTA}\)

An economic exchange can occur only when this surplus is positive, that is, when the buyer's WTP is greater than the seller's WTA. A positive surplus means the exchange creates something worth sharing. Because the buyer values the good more than the seller does, that extra value can be divided between them so that both end up better off than if they hadn't traded. If the surplus is zero, the exchange creates nothing to share. If it's negative, the exchange would destroy value. Either way, there is no way for both sides to gain.

Economic exchange is possible when\(S>0\), or\(\mathrm{WTP}>\mathrm{WTA}\)

This condition answers whether exchange is possible. It doesn't tell us the price. The method of exchange determines the price and therefore how the surplus is allocated.

1.5

In-class exercise: Anne and Brook's bicycle

Anne has owned her 1953 Bianchi Fulmine, a classic road bicycle, for years. Lately, though, she has had her eye on a new road-racing bike that costs $1,600, and she's started to wonder whether it's time to let the Bianchi go. She isn't in a hurry. After thinking it over, she decides she won't part with it for less than $1,300. She has also heard that a similar bicycle recently sold for $1,450 in a nearby town.

Brook's eighteenth birthday is coming up, and her grandmother has given her $2,000 to spend on something special. When Brook sees Anne's Bianchi, she falls in love with it. Still, she doesn't want to get carried away, so she sits down and thinks carefully about what the bike is really worth to her. She decides that the most she is willing to pay for it is $1,500.

We will discuss this problem in class.

Summary

Economic value is the benefit a good or service provides. WTP and WTA measure the buyer's and seller's values and determine whether exchange is possible.

Concept atlas