Read 3 of 5
Determinants of economic value
Why does economic value differ across people and organizations?
So far, we've used WTP and WTA to measure how much a good or service is worth to a buyer and to a seller. These measures tell us how large each side's value is, but not where it comes from. Why is a bicycle worth a lot to one person and very little to another? Why can one firm supply a product more cheaply than another? This reading looks at what lies behind these values.
For consumers, value comes from their preferences: what they like, what they need, and the situation they're in. For producers, value comes from what it takes to supply the good or service, namely the resources and technology used to make it and bring it to buyers.
3.1
Value, price and income
Earlier in our discussion, we saw that value and price are different things. It's worth returning to this, because the two are easy to confuse. The market price is the amount paid if an exchange takes place. A lower price is good news for the buyer, since it leaves them a larger share of the surplus. But it doesn't change how much the good is worth to them, so their WTP stays the same. Likewise, a higher price is good news for the seller, but it doesn't change the least they would accept, so their WTA stays the same. Price affects how the surplus is allocated, not the values that create it.
Income is also different from value. Someone may value a good highly and still be unable to afford it. Their budget limits what they can buy, while their WTP measures how much the good is worth to them. The two can differ in either direction. A person with a large budget may place little value on a particular good, and a person with a small budget may value it highly. A budget tells us what someone can spend, not what a good is worth to them.
There are two exceptions to keep in mind. First, when you're unsure how much a good is worth, its market price can tell you something, because it reflects what other people were willing to pay. In that case, the price can shape your value. Second, if you buy something planning to resell it, the price you expect to get later is part of what it's worth to you. Outside these cases, we treat price the way we did in the previous reading: it allocates the surplus from an exchange but doesn't create value.
3.2
Preferences and needs
A basic source of consumer value is personal preference: what a person likes and dislikes. Preferences are shaped by culture, upbringing, and personal experience, and they can change over time. All of these affect the benefit a person expects to get from a good. A vegetarian and someone who enjoys meat, for example, can place very different values on the same steak.
Needs matter too, because a good's value depends on what it allows a person to do. A medicine that treats an illness is highly valuable to someone who has that illness. To someone who doesn't, the same medicine may be worth little or nothing.
These differences aren't mistakes, and they aren't random noise around some "true" value. There is no single correct value for a good. Because economic value is subjective, it's entirely natural for different consumers to have different WTPs for the same good. As economists, we take people's preferences as they are, rather than judging whether they should value something more or less.
3.3
Situation, behavior and market conditions
Value can change with the situation. As we saw in the first reading, an umbrella is worth more on a rainy day than on a clear one. The umbrella hasn't changed. What has changed is the person's circumstances, and with them the benefit the umbrella provides.
Behavioral factors can also affect value. Branding, advertising, and other psychological influences can change how much a person values a good. Someone may value a handbag more highly because it carries a luxury brand name, even when an unbranded bag of the same quality is available. In that case, the brand isn't just a label. It's part of what the consumer values.
Market conditions can matter as well. When a good is hard to get, having it now can be worth more, because the chance may not come again. When a good is plentiful, there's no rush, and that urgency fades. Limited-edition goods are a familiar example: part of their appeal is that few people own them. Be careful not to confuse this with price. A shortage can also push the market price up, and we'll study that effect in Week 2. The point here is different. Scarcity can change how much the good is worth to the consumer, which changes their WTP, not just what they end up paying.
3.4
Substitutes and complements
The value of a good also depends on other goods related to it. Related goods come in two kinds.
A substitute is a different good that meets the same need. Tea can substitute for coffee, and a bus can substitute for a taxi. When a good has close substitutes, the consumer has other options. If they couldn't get this particular product, they could turn to another that does the job almost as well. That makes this one product worth less to them than it would be if nothing else could take its place.
A complement is a good that is used together with another good. A printer and its ink cartridges are complements: a printer is useful only if you have ink for it. So a printer is worth more when compatible cartridges are easy to get. If the cartridges become hard to find, the printer provides less benefit, even though the printer itself hasn't changed.
Substitutes and complements will come back when we study how consumers decide to spend their income across different goods and services in Week 2.
3.5
Producer value
A producer makes a good or service in order to sell it, not to use it. So the least a producer will accept is set by what it costs to supply the good. That cost depends on the resources used in production and the technology used to combine them. If the price doesn't cover this cost, the producer is better off not supplying at all. The market price still matters, since it determines how much the producer gains from a sale. But, as with consumers, price isn't the source of value. It only allocates the surplus.
Not every seller is a producer. When someone sells something they already own, as Anne does with her bicycle, their WTA comes from how much they value keeping it. That is consumer value, and everything in the previous sections applies.
Several factors shape a producer's cost of supply, and therefore their WTA.
Production cost. Producers use inputs such as labor, capital (machinery, equipment, and buildings), and raw materials. Together, these determine the cost of supplying the good. If an input the producer needs becomes more costly, the producer's WTA is likely to rise.
Technology. Better technology lets a producer make the same output with fewer resources. Automation, for example, can reduce the amount of labor needed, which lowers the cost of supply and therefore lowers WTA.
Rules and regulations. Laws and regulations can change what production requires. Stricter environmental rules, for example, may mean new equipment or extra monitoring. Meeting these requirements uses resources, which raises the cost of supply and therefore raises WTA.
Access to markets. Getting a product to buyers also takes resources, such as transport and storage. Good distribution networks, and trade agreements that make it easier to sell in other countries, lower these costs and therefore lower WTA.
So far, we've used "cost" loosely. To be precise, we need to know exactly what economic cost includes. That is the subject of the next reading.
Summary