Practice 01 · Week 01
Ted's Future
Read the case before class and come ready to solve it with your syndicate group.
Background
Like most of his classmates in the MBA program at Melbourne Business School, Ted was weighing his next career move with a mix of anticipation and anxiety. Before the MBA, he had spent seven years in the United States working for a successful real estate entrepreneur.
The business bought non-performing mortgage loans from banks at a discount, foreclosed on the properties, renovated them and sold them at a substantial profit. When that line of business tapered off, Ted returned to Melbourne and enrolled in the program to strengthen his management skills.
The Westpac offer
Nearly two years later, Ted had landed an attractive offer from Westpac's real estate finance team. The package included an annual salary of $125,000, a signing bonus of $25,000 and an expected first-year performance bonus of $25,000. The signing bonus was available only if Ted accepted the offer now. Like most roles of its kind, the job would demand about 60 hours a week.
The venture
Around the same time, with the real estate market on an upswing, a former business associate approached Ted with a proposal: a joint venture to develop a prime piece of real estate.
The project would cost $1 million in total, $400,000 to acquire the land and $600,000 to build a five-unit apartment building, the largest the zoning laws allowed. Ted and his associate would each contribute half, or $500,000. They projected that they could sell the finished property after one year for $1.4 million, and they would split the proceeds equally.
Financing
Ted had $200,000 in savings from his previous job. His mother, who headed the commercial lending division at ANZ, could arrange a loan secured against the property at 7% annual interest to cover the rest of his share. Alternatively, Ted could leave his savings where they were and earn 5% interest on them.
The trade-offs
The venture had real appeal. Ted could trade his suit for casual clothes, enjoy the freedom of working for himself and put his money into a promising project. But it would also be demanding. He expected to work about 70 hours a week, compared with around 60 at Westpac, which would eat into a good part of his weekends.
Ted wasn't worried about closing doors. Once the project was finished, he was confident he could return to Westpac or secure a comparable offer from another investment firm.
Exhibit 1 · Key figures (AUD)
| Westpac offer | Joint venture | Other |
|---|---|---|
| Annual salary: $125,000 | Total project cost: $1,000,000 | Interest available on savings: 5% per year |
| Signing bonus: $25,000, available only if Ted accepts now | Ted's contribution: $500,000 | |
| Expected first-year performance bonus: $25,000 | Projected sale price after one year: $1,400,000 | |
| About 60 hours per week | Ted's share of proceeds: 50% | |
| Funded from savings: $200,000 | ||
| Funded by loan at 7% per year: $300,000 | ||
| About 70 hours per week |
Questions
1. Should Ted accept the Westpac offer or join the joint venture? Explain your answer in detail, taking into account all relevant economic costs.
2. Suppose Ted's living expenses are $2,000 a month for rent and $1,000 a month for food. How does this information affect your answer to Question 1?
Prepare for class
Read the case and the two questions. Come to class ready to solve them with your syndicate group.
Reveal the solution
Ted's Future: Solution
What the case tells us
The venture is effectively risk-free: the builder's fixed-price contract holds the cost at $1 million, and the committed buyer will pay $1.4 million. Ted and his partner split the proceeds equally. Ted's venture income is taxed at the same rate as a Westpac salary, so we can compare everything before tax. Westpac's offer, including the signing bonus, will still stand in a year. The signing bonus is paid on acceptance, and the performance bonus is paid at the end of the first year. We compare the two options over one year.
Question 1
What Ted gains from the venture
Ted contributes $500,000 and receives half of the $1.4 million sale price, or $700,000. So the venture adds $200,000 to his wealth:
This isn't yet his profit. We still need to subtract everything the venture costs him.
What the venture costs him
By joining the venture, Ted gives up a year of Westpac pay: $125,000 in salary and $25,000 in performance bonus, or $150,000. He doesn't give up the signing bonus because he'll receive it when he joins Westpac a year later. But receiving it a year late has a cost. Had he received it now, he could have earned 5% on it, or $1,250. His $200,000 in savings go into the venture instead of earning 5%, so he forgoes $10,000 in interest. Finally, he borrows the remaining $300,000 of his share at 7%, which costs $21,000 in interest.
| Item | Type | Amount |
|---|---|---|
| Westpac salary and performance bonus | Opportunity cost | $150,000 |
| Interest on loan \(7\%\times\$300{,}000\) | Cash cost | $21,000 |
| Forgone interest on savings \(5\%\times\$200{,}000\) | Opportunity cost | $10,000 |
| Forgone interest on signing bonus \(5\%\times\$25{,}000\) | Opportunity cost | $1,250 |
| Total economic cost | $182,250 |
The answer
On these numbers, Ted should take the venture. But the margin is thin, so it's worth asking what the calculation leaves out.
Caveat 1: the 5% alternative
We valued Ted's money at the 5% interest rate given in the case. If his real alternative is an investment with a higher expected return, such as a diversified share fund, his opportunity cost is higher. The venture stays ahead only if that alternative returns less than about 12.9% a year. The $17,750 margin, spread over $225,000, is about 7.9 percentage points on top of the 5%. Be careful with this comparison, though. A share fund is risky, while the venture is essentially risk-free, so the two returns aren't directly comparable.
Caveat 2: Ted's time
The venture takes about 70 hours a week, compared with 60 at Westpac. One way to value the extra 10 hours is to use Westpac's pay. $150,000 for 60-hour weeks works out to $2,500 a year for each weekly hour, so 10 extra hours are worth $25,000. Adding this to the costs gives $207,250, and the venture's economic profit becomes \(-\$7{,}250\). Westpac now comes out ahead.
This calculation assumes Ted values every hour of free time at the same rate. That's doubtful. Free time becomes more valuable the less of it you have, so giving up hours 61 to 70 likely costs Ted more than $2,500 each. In the language of the previous reading, $2,500 is an average value, while the decision depends on the marginal value of those particular ten hours. This strengthens the case for Westpac.
On the other side, the case lists benefits of the venture: Ted can trade his suit for casual clothes and enjoy working for himself. If he values these, they offset part of the cost of his time. In the end, the decision comes down to how Ted weighs that freedom against his lost weekends.
Caveat 3: Ted's career
The case says Ted is confident he can return to Westpac or find a comparable job. If he's wrong, or if starting a year later delays his promotions, the venture costs him more than one year of pay because the effect carries into future years.
Question 2
Rent and food cost Ted $3,000 a month, or $36,000 a year. He pays these in either scenario, so they are unavoidable and don't change the economic cost of the venture.
They matter only through timing. At Westpac, Ted's salary covers his living expenses as he goes. In the venture, he earns nothing until the property sells, and his savings are tied up in the project, so he has to borrow. Borrowing the full $36,000 at the start of the year at 7% costs $2,520 in interest. Borrowing month by month, only as he needs it, costs less, about $1,365. Either way, the venture's economic profit falls slightly, to about $15,230 with upfront borrowing, but on its own this doesn't change the answer to Question 1.