Read 2 of 5
Price, surplus and methods of exchange
How are the terms of exchange determined?
In the previous reading, we saw that an exchange is possible when it creates a positive surplus. But knowing that both sides could gain doesn't settle the deal. The buyer and seller still have to agree on the terms of exchange: what the buyer pays and, sometimes, other conditions as well. Most of the time, the key term is the price.
There are several ways to arrive at the terms. Markets, auctions, and bargaining each do it differently, and we look at each below. Whatever the method, the price it produces determines how the surplus is divided between the buyer and the seller.
2.1
Price allocates the surplus
When the buyer's WTP exceeds the seller's WTA, there isn't just one price that works. There is a whole range of prices at which the exchange is worthwhile for both sides. The price must be above the seller's WTA, since otherwise the seller would rather keep the good. It must also be below the buyer's WTP, since otherwise the buyer would rather keep their money. Any price between these two limits leaves both sides better off than if they didn't trade. Writing \(p\) for the price, we can express this as follows.
At any price in this range, both sides come out ahead, and we can measure by how much. The buyer pays less than the most they were willing to pay. The difference between their WTP and the price is buyer surplus. Think of it as what the buyer saves compared with the most they'd have paid, and so how much better off the exchange makes them. Likewise, the seller receives more than the least they were willing to accept. The difference between the price and their WTA is seller surplus, which measures how much better off the exchange makes the seller.
Adding buyer surplus and seller surplus gives:
The price cancels out. This makes sense: every dollar the buyer pays is a dollar the seller receives, so the price simply moves money from one side to the other. A higher price adds to seller surplus exactly what it takes away from buyer surplus. So the price changes how the surplus is divided, but not how much surplus the exchange creates. That total is the same surplus we met in the previous reading, and it depends only on the buyer's WTP and the seller's WTA.
2.2
Markets
A is any system or setting where buyers and sellers come together to exchange goods and services. Markets for raw materials such as wheat or oil, online marketplaces and shopping malls are all markets, but each organizes exchange in its own way. How a market is organized determines how the price is set.
A stock exchange is a highly organized market with many buyers and sellers. Suppose a company's shares are trading at $50 each. An investor who places an order to buy 100 shares at the current price pays $50 per share, or $5,000 in total. A shareholder who sells 100 shares at that price receives $5,000.
The buyer and seller never meet or negotiate. The exchange matches buy orders with sell orders, and no single buyer or seller sets the $50. It's the price at which orders are currently being matched. Each trader simply takes this price as given and decides whether to trade at it. An investor buys only if a share is worth more than $50 to them, and a shareholder sells only if it's worth less than $50 to them. Either way, the $50 market price is the term of exchange, and it determines how the surplus from each trade is divided.
2.3
Auctions and tenders
An uses a set of announced rules to decide who gets the good and what they pay. The rules matter. Different auction formats give bidders different reasons to bid high or low, so they can lead to different prices and therefore a different division of the surplus.
Consider a first-price sealed-bid auction. Each bidder submits a single bid in secret, without seeing anyone else's. Once all the bids are in, they are opened together. The highest bidder wins and pays exactly what they bid, so the winning bid is the price.
Think about what this means for the winner. Their surplus is their WTP minus their bid. A bidder who bids their full WTP gains nothing from winning, since they pay the most they were willing to pay. So bidders in this format have a reason to bid less than their WTP. How much less depends on what they expect the others to bid.
A tender works the same way in reverse. A buyer invites several potential sellers to submit bids, and the sellers compete for the business. The lowest bid usually wins, although the buyer may weigh other factors, such as quality or delivery time, alongside price. Governments often use tenders when they buy goods and services, and so do large businesses. In a tender, the winning seller's bid is the term of exchange, and the seller's surplus is their bid minus their WTA.
2.4
Bargaining
In , the buyer and seller settle the terms by dealing with each other directly. One side makes an offer, the other responds, and each can adjust their position as they go. If they reach terms both find acceptable, the exchange takes place. If not, it doesn't.
Consider a salary negotiation. The job seeker is the seller here, offering their labor, and the employer is the buyer. The job seeker opens by asking for $80,000. The employer counters with $70,000. The job seeker then proposes $77,000 plus some additional benefits. After several more rounds, they settle on $75,000 plus a performance-based bonus.
This compensation package is the price, or term of exchange, for the job seeker's labor. Notice that the opening positions are not WTP and WTA. The job seeker asked for $80,000 but ended up accepting less, so $80,000 was not their WTA. The employer offered $70,000 but ended up paying more, so $70,000 was not their WTP. Opening offers are moves in the negotiation, and neither side has a reason to reveal their true limit, since doing so would help the other side claim more of the surplus. What we can say for sure is that the final package is worth more to the job seeker than their WTA and less to the employer than their WTP. Otherwise, one of them would have walked away.
The example also shows that the terms of exchange don't have to be a single payment. Here they combine a salary and a bonus.
2.5
The dolabra dealer: exchange, allocation and incentives
You're an antique dealer who specializes in Roman antiquities. One week, two people approach you separately, each hoping to sell a dolabra, the axe-and-pick tool Roman legionaries carried for digging and building their camps. One belongs to Dr. Elizabeth Harrow, a respected historian. The other belongs to Dr. Nathan Calder, a well-known archaeologist. You inspect both and find them in comparable condition, so to a buyer, one is as good as the other. Dr. Harrow tells you she won't sell hers for less than $25,000. Dr. Calder won't part with his for less than $50,000.
Next, you go looking for buyers and find two interested collectors, Mr. Smith and Mrs. Blackwood. Each wants one dolabra. After long conversations and a close look at both pieces, you work out that Mr. Smith would pay up to $40,000, while Mrs. Blackwood would pay up to $60,000.
Your role is to bring a buyer and a seller together so they can negotiate a sale. You decide who meets whom.
Select a pair to compare the buyer's WTP with the seller's WTA.
Questions
Use the interactive graph to answer the following questions.
Which buyer-seller pairs could make an economic exchange?
Three pairs can create a positive surplus. Smith and Harrow create $15,000, Blackwood and Harrow create $35,000, and Blackwood and Calder create $10,000. Smith and Calder can't make an economic exchange because Smith's $40,000 WTP is below Calder's $50,000 WTA.
Is there a single price at which both dolabras could be sold?
No. To sell both dolabras, Smith must buy from Harrow and Blackwood must buy from Calder. A price for the Smith-Harrow exchange must lie between $25,000 and $40,000. A price for the Blackwood-Calder exchange must lie between $50,000 and $60,000. These ranges don't overlap, so no single price works for both sales.
Which pairs should you bring together to maximize the total surplus of all four people?
Bring Blackwood and Harrow together. Their exchange creates $35,000 of surplus. If both dolabras are sold, Smith must buy from Harrow and Blackwood from Calder. Those two sales create only $25,000 in total surplus. So one sale creates more total surplus than two.
You earn $1,000 for each completed sale, with $500 paid by the buyer and $500 by the seller. Which pairs do you bring together?
Arrange two sales: Smith buys from Harrow and Blackwood buys from Calder. Each pair creates enough surplus to cover the $1,000 fee. You earn $2,000 in total, which is more than the $1,000 you would earn from arranging only the Blackwood-Harrow sale. Smith and Calder cannot trade because Smith's WTP is below Calder's WTA.
Suppose instead that you earn 5% of the surplus each sale creates. Which pairs do you bring together now?
Bring Blackwood and Harrow together. Their $35,000 surplus pays you $1,750. The two-sale matching creates $25,000 in total surplus and pays you $1,250. The percentage fee makes the single high-surplus exchange more profitable for you.
Compare your answers to Questions 3, 4, and 5. What does this suggest about how an intermediary should be paid?
A fee per transaction rewards the number of exchanges, even when arranging more exchanges creates less total surplus. A percentage of surplus rewards the intermediary for creating more total surplus. If the goal is to align the intermediary's choice with the interests of the group, the percentage fee works better in this example.
Summary