Read 2 of 5
Firms in short-run equilibrium
What does the market equilibrium imply for one firm?
Solving for equilibrium gives a market price and a market quantity. But a manager runs one firm, not the market, and needs two answers about that firm. How much should it produce at the market price? And how much profit will it make?
Each answer uses a different cost measure from Week 1. Marginal cost, the cost of producing one more unit, decides how much to produce. Average cost, total cost divided by the number of units, decides how much profit the firm makes on each unit. Keeping the two apart avoids one of the most common mistakes in this topic: thinking that if price equals marginal cost, profit must be zero. That’s not true, and this reading shows why.
We’ll stay with Auto Eco, so nothing changes except our point of view: we move from the whole market back to a single firm.
2.1
The market gives the firm a price
In the short run, the number of Auto Eco firms is fixed at ten. Together, market demand and those ten firms’ market supply set the equilibrium price at \(p^e=90\) and the quantity at \(Q^e=80\), as we found in Reading 1.
Each firm is a price-taker. It doesn’t choose the price of 90, and it doesn’t bargain over it. It takes 90 as given and decides only how much to produce. Since the ten firms are identical, each makes one tenth of the market quantity. We write one firm’s equilibrium output with a lowercase \(q^e\):
That’s 800 vehicles per firm each month.
We can get the same answer from the firm’s own decision. A firm keeps expanding as long as the next unit adds more to revenue than to cost. At a market price of 90, each extra unit brings in 90, so the firm expands until the marginal cost of the next unit reaches 90. Auto Eco’s marginal cost is \(MC(q)=10+10q\), so
The price of 90 is also above the shutdown threshold of 50, so producing beats shutting down, and 8 is the firm’s best choice.
The two methods agree, and that isn’t a coincidence. Market supply was built by adding up each firm’s best output at every price. Solving for the market price and then asking what one firm does simply runs that adding-up in reverse.
2.2
Calculate economic profit
A firm’s economic profit is its revenue minus its economic cost.
Here \(pq\) is revenue, the price times the quantity sold, and \(C(q)\) is the cost of producing that quantity.
At \(p=90\) and \(q=8\), revenue is \(90\times 8=720\). Cost is
So profit is
What does 240 mean in dollars? Price is in thousands of dollars per vehicle and quantity is in hundreds of vehicles, so price times quantity is measured in units of $100,000. Costs and profit are measured the same way. So each firm earns revenue of $72 million a month, pays costs of $48 million and makes a profit of $24 million. The units matter when you report the numbers, but the reasoning is the same whatever units you use.
2.3
The margin method gives the same answer
Recall the second way to calculate profit: take the gap between price and average cost, and multiply by output. Recall that average cost is total cost divided by output, \(AC(q)=C(q)/q\). Turning that around, total cost is average cost times output, \(C(q)=AC(q)\times q\). Substituting this into the profit formula gives
At an output of 8, average cost is \(480/8=60\), or $60,000 per vehicle. Each vehicle sells for 90, so the firm makes a margin of \(90-60=30\), or $30,000, on every vehicle. Multiply by output:
That’s $30,000 on each of 800 vehicles, or $24 million, the same answer as in 2.2.
This version is useful because it splits profit into two parts that come from different places. How much the firm produces, 8, comes from marginal cost. How much it makes on each unit, 30, comes from average cost. Profit is the two multiplied together. On a graph, you can picture profit as a rectangle: its width is the quantity produced, and its height is the gap between price and average cost.
2.4
Why price equal to marginal cost doesn't imply zero profit
At the firm’s chosen output, price equals marginal cost: \(p=MC(8)=90\). But average cost is only 60, so the firm makes a profit. How can both be true?
The two cost measures answer different questions. Marginal cost is the cost of producing one more unit. It tells the firm whether expanding is worthwhile: if the next unit adds more to revenue than to cost, produce it. Average cost is total cost spread evenly over all the units produced. It tells the firm how much it makes per unit overall.
Setting price equal to marginal cost only says that the last unit just breaks even. The earlier units were much cheaper to make. At low output, Auto Eco’s marginal cost is close to 10, far below the price of 90. Add up all eight units: they bring in 720, and the part of cost that depends on output, \(10\times8+5\times8^2=400\), is much less than that. The firm comes out 320 ahead on its production. It then pays its fixed cost of 80 out of that and keeps 240 as profit, the same answer as in 2.2.
So there are two separate checks, and it helps to keep them apart.
\(p=MC(q)\) identifies the profit-maximizing output, as long as the price is above the shutdown threshold.
\(p\gtreqless AVC(q)\) determines whether producing or shutting down is better in the short run.
Zero profit requires price to equal average cost, not just marginal cost. Price can equal both at once only at the output where average cost is at its lowest. For Auto Eco, that’s an output of 4, where marginal cost and average cost both equal 50, the shutdown threshold. In Reading 4, we’ll see why competition pushes firms to that point in the long run.
2.5
Identical firms and firms with different costs
All ten Auto Eco firms have the same cost function, so at the equilibrium price each one makes the same output and earns the same profit. That’s a feature of this example, not something competitive equilibrium requires.
When firms use different technologies, they still sell a homogeneous good at a single market price. But their costs differ, so their profits differ too. A low-cost firm has average cost well below the price and earns a large profit. A higher-cost firm may only just cover its costs. A firm with even higher costs may not produce at all.
You’ve already seen this in Week 2’s medication market. Suppose the price is $40 a pack. A small producer like Apex has an average cost of $20 at capacity, so it makes $20 on each of its 100 packs, a profit of $2,000 a month. A large producer like Boulder has an average cost of $40 at capacity, so it just breaks even. Both are price-takers selling the same pack at the same price. Apex earns more only because its costs are lower.
So differences in profit don’t come from differences in price, because there aren’t any: every firm gets the same price. Differences in profit come entirely from differences in cost.
This will matter in the exercise “Portakal.” There, low-cost farms on the island and higher-cost farms on the mainland both behave competitively. New mainland farms can keep entering until the market price settles at a level that just covers their costs. Island farms still earn positive profit at that price, because low-cost island land is scarce and newcomers can’t get more of it.
2.6
Which cost function belongs in the calculation?
Before calculating anything, ask which decision you’re analyzing and over what period. The right cost function depends on both.
Auto Eco’s cost function \(C(q)\) includes only the costs the firm can avoid by not producing that month. That’s why the shutdown rule works so simply: if the price is below the threshold, the firm produces nothing, because producing would mean a loss it could avoid.
Over a shorter period, some payments may already be locked in. Recall the lease example from Week 2: once a lease is signed for this month, the firm pays the rent whether it produces or not. A payment like that still shows up in the firm’s accounts, but it doesn’t belong in the cost function for this month’s output decision, because nothing the firm does this month can change it. Leaving it out lowers average cost, lowers the shutdown threshold and changes the economic profit you calculate for that decision.
This explains something that can look like a contradiction. A competitive firm may keep producing even though its accounts show a loss. The accounts include every payment, including the ones the firm can’t avoid. The production decision looks only at the costs the firm can still avoid. If revenue covers those, producing is better than shutting down, because shutting down wouldn’t make the locked-in payments go away. The firm loses less by producing than by closing.
So before using any profit formula, name the decision and its time frame, then build the cost function that matches.
Summary