Week 03 · Complete notes
Equilibrium in competitive markets
How does a competitive market reach and move in and out of equilibrium?
This print edition combines all five readings. Interactive definitions become ordinary text when printed.
01
Short-run market equilibrium
At what price do buyers want to buy exactly what firms want to sell?
Week 2 ended with two market plans. Market demand tells us how much buyers want to buy at each price. Market supply tells us how much firms want to sell at each price. In a competitive market, both sides face the same price. So the first question is whether there's a price at which the two sides of the market agree.
A price where they agree is called a competitive equilibrium. You may have seen it drawn as the point where the demand and supply curves cross. But the crossing point is only half the story. At any other price, buyers and sellers can't all do what they planned. Either some buyers can't get what they want, or some firms are left with output they can't sell. That gives people a reason to change what they offer to pay or what they ask, and those changes push the price toward the crossing.
At this stage, we focus on the short run, so the number of firms stays fixed. We start with Auto Eco because you already know its supply from Week 2. Keeping the firm the same lets us focus on what's new this week: how the market brings buyers and sellers together.
1.1
From two curves to one market price
Pick a possible market price, say $70,000 per vehicle. The demand curve tells you how many vehicles buyers want to buy at that price. The supply curve tells you how many vehicles all the firms together want to produce. Nothing guarantees that these two numbers are the same.
A is a price \(p^e\) and a quantity \(Q^e\) that meet three conditions at once. First, every buyer chooses the optimal quantity they can afford at that price. Second, every firm chooses the output that maximizes its economic profit at that price. Third, the quantity buyers want to buy equals the quantity firms want to sell:
The first two conditions are already built into the curves. Every point on the demand curve shows what buyers choose at that price, and every point on the supply curve shows what firms choose. So to find an equilibrium, the only thing left to check is the third condition. That's why it's called the market-clearing condition: at that price, everything firms bring to market gets bought, and every buyer who wants a vehicle at that price gets one.
Read the equation carefully. It compares two quantities at one price. Demand and supply are different functions, and they agree only at the equilibrium price.
The superscript \(e\) marks an equilibrium value. Once you know \(p^e\), plugging it into either curve gives the same \(Q^e\).
Equilibrium doesn't mean every buyer gets a vehicle, or that every firm is happy with the price. Some buyers value a vehicle at less than \(p^e\), so they don't buy one. Some firms have costs too high to produce at that price. The claim is narrower: at the same price, everyone makes the best choice available to them, and the total amount buyers choose to buy equals the total amount firms choose to sell.
1.2
Auto Eco's market
Each Auto Eco firm has the same monthly cost function as in Week 2:
Price is in thousands of dollars per vehicle, and \(q\) is in hundreds of vehicles. So a price of 90 means $90,000 per vehicle, and \(q=8\) means 800 vehicles. As you saw in Week 2, each firm's shutdown threshold is 50. Above that price, its supply is
Below 50, the firm produces nothing. There are ten identical firms, so market supply is ten times one firm's supply:
Suppose monthly market demand is
At equilibrium, quantity demanded equals quantity supplied. We don't know the equilibrium price yet, so we call it \(p^e\) and solve for it:
Before using this answer, check that it's in the right range. The supply formula only holds above 50, and 90 is above 50, so the answer stands.
Now plug 90 into either curve to get the quantity. Demand gives \(Q^d(90)=170-90=80\), and supply gives \(Q^s(90)=90-10=80\). The two curves agree, as they must at equilibrium. Each of the ten firms makes \(q^s(90)=8\), or 800 vehicles.
So the market clears at a price of $90,000 per vehicle, with 8,000 vehicles sold each month.
1.3
A price below equilibrium: excess demand
Now suppose the price is 70, or $70,000, instead of 90. Plug 70 into each curve. Since 70 is above 50, the supply formula applies. Buyers want \(Q^d(70)=170-70=100\), and firms want to supply \(Q^s(70)=70-10=60\). That’s 10,000 vehicles wanted and only 6,000 for sale.
When buyers want more than firms are willing to sell, the difference is called . Here it’s 4,000 vehicles. In everyday terms, it’s a : some buyers who are willing to pay $70,000 can’t get a vehicle.
A shortage pushes the price up, because buyers compete for the vehicles that are available. A dealer with a waiting list realizes it could sell each vehicle for more. Buyers who value a vehicle most offer to pay more rather than wait. As the price rises, two things happen. Buyers want fewer vehicles, so quantity demanded falls. Firms want to make more, so quantity supplied rises. The gap shrinks, and at 90 it disappears.
Notice what hasn’t happened. Neither curve has shifted. Nothing about buyers’ incomes or tastes has changed, and nothing about firms’ costs. The market is moving along the same two curves because the price is changing. This is the movement along demand and supply from Week 2.
1.4
A price above equilibrium: excess supply
Now suppose the price is 110, or $110,000. Plug 110 into each curve. Buyers want \(Q^d(110)=170-110=60\), and firms want to supply \(Q^s(110)=110-10=100\). That’s 10,000 vehicles for sale and only 6,000 wanted.
The gap is
When firms want to sell more than buyers want to buy, the difference is called . Here it’s 4,000 vehicles left unsold. Excess supply is sometimes called a market . Be careful with that word. In Week 1, buyer surplus and seller surplus measured the gains people get from trading. Here “surplus” just means output nobody buys.
Excess supply pushes the price down, because sellers compete for the buyers who are available. A dealer cuts its price rather than leave vehicles sitting on the lot. A rival dealer follows rather than lose the sale. As the price falls, the same two movements happen in reverse. Buyers want more vehicles, so quantity demanded rises. Firms want to make fewer, so quantity supplied falls. Once again, the market moves along the same two curves, and the gap disappears at 90.
The graph talks as if the price moves on its own. It doesn’t. Nobody in the market is “the price,” and no single person sets it. When the price rises or falls, that’s the combined result of many separate decisions: dealers raising or cutting what they ask, and buyers offering more or holding out. The model predicts which direction those decisions push the price. It doesn’t assume that anyone works out the equilibrium price and announces it to the market.
1.5
What equilibrium does and doesn't claim
Equilibrium makes two claims. At \(p^e=90\), the quantity buyers want equals the quantity firms want to sell. And because there’s no shortage and no unsold output, nothing pushes the price up or down. That’s what means.
It doesn’t claim the outcome is fair or good for society. At $90,000, some people who would like a vehicle can’t afford one. Factories may pollute, imposing costs on people who aren’t buying or selling vehicles at all. Market clearing says nothing about either issue. Those are separate questions.
It also doesn’t claim the price jumps to 90 instantly. Many things slow the adjustment down. Buyers take time to search, contracts fix prices for a while, changing posted prices costs time and money, production takes time to ramp up, and nobody knows exactly where the equilibrium is. The model tells you the direction: below equilibrium, the price is pushed up, and above it, the price is pushed down. How fast the price actually moves is something you’d have to measure in a real market.
Finally, our example is a simple one. Demand slopes down and supply slopes up, so they cross exactly once, and from either side the price gets pushed toward that crossing. Not every market behaves this neatly. In some markets, the curves can cross more than once. A law that caps the price below 90 would stop it from ever rising to equilibrium. And if buyers or sellers expect prices to change, the curves themselves can shift while the price is still adjusting. None of this makes the model wrong. Each case tells you which assumption has to change when the simple model doesn’t fit the market you’re looking at.
Summary. A competitive equilibrium is a price at which quantity demanded equals quantity supplied and every buyer and firm is choosing optimally. Below that price, excess demand creates upward pressure. Above it, excess supply creates downward pressure. The adjustment is a movement along fixed demand and supply curves.
02
Firms in short-run equilibrium
What does the market equilibrium imply for one firm?
Solving for equilibrium gives a market price and a market quantity. But a manager runs one firm, not the market, and needs two answers about that firm. How much should it produce at the market price? And how much profit will it make?
Each answer uses a different cost measure from Week 1. Marginal cost, the cost of producing one more unit, decides how much to produce. Average cost, total cost divided by the number of units, decides how much profit the firm makes on each unit. Keeping the two apart avoids one of the most common mistakes in this topic: thinking that if price equals marginal cost, profit must be zero. That’s not true, and this reading shows why.
We’ll stay with Auto Eco, so nothing changes except our point of view: we move from the whole market back to a single firm.
2.1
The market gives the firm a price
In the short run, the number of Auto Eco firms is fixed at ten. Together, market demand and those ten firms’ market supply set the equilibrium price at \(p^e=90\) and the quantity at \(Q^e=80\), as we found in Reading 1.
Each firm is a price-taker. It doesn’t choose the price of 90, and it doesn’t bargain over it. It takes 90 as given and decides only how much to produce. Since the ten firms are identical, each makes one tenth of the market quantity. We write one firm’s equilibrium output with a lowercase \(q^e\):
That’s 800 vehicles per firm each month.
We can get the same answer from the firm’s own decision. A firm keeps expanding as long as the next unit adds more to revenue than to cost. At a market price of 90, each extra unit brings in 90, so the firm expands until the marginal cost of the next unit reaches 90. Auto Eco’s marginal cost is \(MC(q)=10+10q\), so
The price of 90 is also above the shutdown threshold of 50, so producing beats shutting down, and 8 is the firm’s best choice.
The two methods agree, and that isn’t a coincidence. Market supply was built by adding up each firm’s best output at every price. Solving for the market price and then asking what one firm does simply runs that adding-up in reverse.
2.2
Calculate economic profit
A firm’s economic profit is its revenue minus its economic cost.
Here \(pq\) is revenue, the price times the quantity sold, and \(C(q)\) is the cost of producing that quantity.
At \(p=90\) and \(q=8\), revenue is \(90\times 8=720\). Cost is
So profit is
What does 240 mean in dollars? Price is in thousands of dollars per vehicle and quantity is in hundreds of vehicles, so price times quantity is measured in units of $100,000. Costs and profit are measured the same way. So each firm earns revenue of $72 million a month, pays costs of $48 million and makes a profit of $24 million. The units matter when you report the numbers, but the reasoning is the same whatever units you use.
2.3
The margin method gives the same answer
Recall the second way to calculate profit: take the gap between price and average cost, and multiply by output. Recall that average cost is total cost divided by output, \(AC(q)=C(q)/q\). Turning that around, total cost is average cost times output, \(C(q)=AC(q)\times q\). Substituting this into the profit formula gives
At an output of 8, average cost is \(480/8=60\), or $60,000 per vehicle. Each vehicle sells for 90, so the firm makes a margin of \(90-60=30\), or $30,000, on every vehicle. Multiply by output:
That’s $30,000 on each of 800 vehicles, or $24 million, the same answer as in 2.2.
This version is useful because it splits profit into two parts that come from different places. How much the firm produces, 8, comes from marginal cost. How much it makes on each unit, 30, comes from average cost. Profit is the two multiplied together. On a graph, you can picture profit as a rectangle: its width is the quantity produced, and its height is the gap between price and average cost.
2.4
Why price equal to marginal cost doesn't imply zero profit
At the firm’s chosen output, price equals marginal cost: \(p=MC(8)=90\). But average cost is only 60, so the firm makes a profit. How can both be true?
The two cost measures answer different questions. Marginal cost is the cost of producing one more unit. It tells the firm whether expanding is worthwhile: if the next unit adds more to revenue than to cost, produce it. Average cost is total cost spread evenly over all the units produced. It tells the firm how much it makes per unit overall.
Setting price equal to marginal cost only says that the last unit just breaks even. The earlier units were much cheaper to make. At low output, Auto Eco’s marginal cost is close to 10, far below the price of 90. Add up all eight units: they bring in 720, and the part of cost that depends on output, \(10\times8+5\times8^2=400\), is much less than that. The firm comes out 320 ahead on its production. It then pays its fixed cost of 80 out of that and keeps 240 as profit, the same answer as in 2.2.
So there are two separate checks, and it helps to keep them apart.
\(p=MC(q)\) identifies the profit-maximizing output, as long as the price is above the shutdown threshold.
\(p\gtreqless AVC(q)\) determines whether producing or shutting down is better in the short run.
Zero profit requires price to equal average cost, not just marginal cost. Price can equal both at once only at the output where average cost is at its lowest. For Auto Eco, that’s an output of 4, where marginal cost and average cost both equal 50, the shutdown threshold. In Reading 4, we’ll see why competition pushes firms to that point in the long run.
2.5
Identical firms and firms with different costs
All ten Auto Eco firms have the same cost function, so at the equilibrium price each one makes the same output and earns the same profit. That’s a feature of this example, not something competitive equilibrium requires.
When firms use different technologies, they still sell a homogeneous good at a single market price. But their costs differ, so their profits differ too. A low-cost firm has average cost well below the price and earns a large profit. A higher-cost firm may only just cover its costs. A firm with even higher costs may not produce at all.
You’ve already seen this in Week 2’s medication market. Suppose the price is $40 a pack. A small producer like Apex has an average cost of $20 at capacity, so it makes $20 on each of its 100 packs, a profit of $2,000 a month. A large producer like Boulder has an average cost of $40 at capacity, so it just breaks even. Both are price-takers selling the same pack at the same price. Apex earns more only because its costs are lower.
So differences in profit don’t come from differences in price, because there aren’t any: every firm gets the same price. Differences in profit come entirely from differences in cost.
This will matter in the exercise “Portakal.” There, low-cost farms on the island and higher-cost farms on the mainland both behave competitively. New mainland farms can keep entering until the market price settles at a level that just covers their costs. Island farms still earn positive profit at that price, because low-cost island land is scarce and newcomers can’t get more of it.
2.6
Which cost function belongs in the calculation?
Before calculating anything, ask which decision you’re analyzing and over what period. The right cost function depends on both.
Auto Eco’s cost function \(C(q)\) includes only the costs the firm can avoid by not producing that month. That’s why the shutdown rule works so simply: if the price is below the threshold, the firm produces nothing, because producing would mean a loss it could avoid.
Over a shorter period, some payments may already be locked in. Recall the lease example from Week 2: once a lease is signed for this month, the firm pays the rent whether it produces or not. A payment like that still shows up in the firm’s accounts, but it doesn’t belong in the cost function for this month’s output decision, because nothing the firm does this month can change it. Leaving it out lowers average cost, lowers the shutdown threshold and changes the economic profit you calculate for that decision.
This explains something that can look like a contradiction. A competitive firm may keep producing even though its accounts show a loss. The accounts include every payment, including the ones the firm can’t avoid. The production decision looks only at the costs the firm can still avoid. If revenue covers those, producing is better than shutting down, because shutting down wouldn’t make the locked-in payments go away. The firm loses less by producing than by closing.
So before using any profit formula, name the decision and its time frame, then build the cost function that matches.
Summary. The market equilibrium gives a price to each price-taking firm. Marginal cost determines the firm's output at that price, while average cost determines its profit margin. Price equal to marginal cost doesn't imply zero profit; zero economic profit requires price to equal average cost.
03
When demand or supply shifts
How does a market find a new equilibrium after fundamentals change?
An equilibrium depends on the demand and supply curves that produced it. But the things behind those curves change all the time. Incomes rise and fall, production costs change, and buyers discover alternatives. When something like this changes, one of the curves shifts, and the old price no longer clears the market.
Two things then happen, one after the other. First, a curve shifts, which creates a new equilibrium. Second, at the old price there’s now either a shortage or unsold output, and that pushes the price toward the new equilibrium. Comparing the old equilibrium with the new one is called comparative statics. It’s “statics” because we compare the two points where the market is at rest, not the path between them.
The method is simple, but reading the results takes care. We’ll predict the new market price and quantity first, then go back to one firm and work out its new output and profit.
3.1
A four-step method
Start from a market in equilibrium and work through these steps in order:
- Name the event. Decide whether it affects buyers, through demand, or firms, through their costs or how many of them there are, which affects supply.
- Shift the right curve. Identify which curve shifts and in which direction. Leave the other curve where it is, unless the event affects it too.
- Check the old price. At the old price, work out whether there’s now excess demand or excess supply. That tells you which way the price will move.
- Compare the equilibria. Find the new equilibrium price and quantity and compare them with the old ones. Then use the new price to work out one firm’s output and profit.
The order matters. Saying “demand rises, so price rises” skips the part that explains why. Here’s the missing step. When demand shifts right, buyers want more than firms supply at the old price, so there’s excess demand. Buyers compete for the vehicles available, and the price rises. As it rises, quantity demanded falls along the new demand curve, and quantity supplied rises along the existing supply curve, until the two meet.
This kind of exercise compares the two points where the market is at rest. It doesn’t claim the market gets from one to the other instantly or smoothly.
3.2
A rise in demand
Let’s apply the four steps.
Step 1: name the event. Suppose buyers’ tastes shift toward electric vehicles. This affects buyers, so it’s a demand change. Nothing about the firms’ costs has changed.
Step 2: shift the right curve. Market demand shifts right, from \(Q^d(p)=170-p\) to
The subscript 1 marks the new curve, after the change. Supply stays where it is: the ten firms’ short-run market supply is still \(Q^s(p)=p-10\).
Step 3: check the old price. At the old price of 90, buyers now want \(210-90=120\), or 12,000 vehicles. The ten firms still supply 80, or 8,000. That’s excess demand of 40, so the price is pushed up.
Step 4: compare the equilibria. Set the new demand equal to the existing supply:
The new price of 110 is above the shutdown threshold of 50, so the supply formula applies. The market now clears at $110,000 per vehicle, with 10,000 vehicles sold each month.
Now go back to one firm. Each of the ten firms makes one tenth of the market quantity, so output rises from 8 to 10, or 1,000 vehicles. You can check this with marginal cost: \(110=10+10q\) gives \(q=10\). At that output,
Profit rises from 240 to 420, or from $24 million to $42 million a month.
So in the short run, stronger demand raises the market price and the market quantity. It also raises each firm’s output and profit.
3.3
An increase in production cost
Go back to the original demand, \(Q^d(p)=170-p\), and apply the four steps to a different event.
Step 1: name the event. Suppose a battery component becomes more expensive, adding $20,000 to the cost of every vehicle. This affects firms’ costs, so it’s a supply change. Nothing about buyers has changed.
Step 2: shift the right curve. In the cost function, the cost per unit rises from 10 to 30:
Marginal cost is now \(MC_1(q)=30+10q\), which is 20 higher at every output. The shutdown threshold changes too. Because the battery adds the same amount to every vehicle, average cost rises by 20 at every output. Its lowest point is still at an output of 4, but it’s now \(80/4+30+5\times4=70\) instead of 50. So no firm produces below $70,000. Above that price, one firm’s supply is \((p-30)/10\), and the ten firms together supply
Market supply has shifted left. At every price above 70, firms now offer 20 fewer units, or 2,000 fewer vehicles, than before.
Step 3: check the old price. At the old price of 90, firms now supply \(90-30=60\), or 6,000 vehicles, while buyers still want 80, or 8,000. That’s excess demand of 20, so the price is pushed up.
Step 4: compare the equilibria. Set demand equal to the new supply:
The new price of 100 is above the new threshold of 70, so the answer stands. The market now clears at $100,000 per vehicle, with 7,000 vehicles sold each month. The price is higher and the quantity is lower.
Now go back to one firm. Each firm makes 7, or 700 vehicles. At that output,
Profit falls from 240 to 165, or from $24 million to $16.5 million a month. The price went up, but the firms are worse off. Here’s why. The price rose by $10,000 per vehicle. But average cost at the firm’s output rose by more: from 60 to \(535/7\approx76.4\), or about $16,400 per vehicle. The margin on each vehicle shrank, and the firm also sells fewer vehicles.
So a higher market price isn’t, by itself, evidence that demand is stronger or that producers are doing better. A drop in supply also raises the price, and it can leave producers with less profit.
3.4
The four basic cases
| Change | Curve | Equilibrium price | Equilibrium quantity |
|---|---|---|---|
| Demand increases | Demand shifts right | Rises | Rises |
| Demand decreases | Demand shifts left | Falls | Falls |
| Supply increases | Supply shifts right | Falls | Rises |
| Supply decreases | Supply shifts left | Rises | Falls |
There’s a simple pattern here. When demand shifts, price and quantity move in the same direction. When supply shifts, they move in opposite directions.
The reason is which curve the market slides along. When demand shifts, supply stays put, so the new equilibrium is somewhere else on the same supply curve. Supply slopes upward, so a higher price comes with a higher quantity. That’s what happened in 3.2: price and quantity both rose. When supply shifts, demand stays put, so the new equilibrium is somewhere else on the same demand curve. Demand slopes downward, so a higher price comes with a lower quantity. That’s what happened in 3.3: price rose and quantity fell.
The pattern also works in reverse, as a way to diagnose what happened. If an industry reports a higher price and a higher quantity, a rise in demand fits what you see. A higher price with a lower quantity points instead to a drop in supply. A lower price with a lower quantity fits a fall in demand, and a lower price with a higher quantity fits a rise in supply.
Notice the word “fits.” Two numbers alone can’t prove what caused them. Both curves may have shifted at once. The price and the quantity may have been measured over different periods. Or a legal limit on the price may have stopped it from adjusting at all. The table tells you what the model predicts. It doesn’t replace evidence about what actually happened.
3.5
When both curves shift
Sometimes two things change at once. Suppose demand rises at the same time as supply falls. Both shifts push the price up, so we can be sure the price rises. But the two shifts pull quantity in opposite directions: more demand pushes quantity up, while less supply pushes it down. Which effect wins depends on which shift is bigger.
Both shifts agree about price.
The shifts pull quantity in opposite directions.
Auto Eco shows both possibilities. Suppose buyers’ tastes shift toward electric vehicles at the same time as battery costs rise, so supply becomes \(Q^s_1(p)=p-30\) as in 3.3. If demand rises all the way to \(210-p\) as in 3.2, the new equilibrium is a price of 120 and a quantity of 90, so quantity rises from 80. If demand rises only to \(180-p\), the new equilibrium is a price of 105 and a quantity of 75, so quantity falls. The price rises in both cases. Quantity depends on which shift is bigger.
The other combinations work the same way. If demand falls while supply rises, the price definitely falls, but quantity could go either way. If demand and supply both shift right, quantity definitely rises, but the price could go either way. If both shift left, quantity definitely falls, and again the price could go either way.
Economists call an outcome like this ambiguous. That doesn’t mean it can’t be worked out. If you know how far each curve shifts, you can calculate the answer, as we just did. It means that knowing the directions of the shifts isn’t enough on its own.
3.6
Short-run and long-run responses are different questions
Every calculation in this reading has kept the number of firms fixed at ten. That makes them short-run comparisons. In the short run, a lasting rise in demand raises the price, each firm’s output and each firm’s profit, as we found in 3.2.
But profit has another effect: firms outside the market notice it. Each one compares what it could earn by entering with what it earns elsewhere. If entry is free and the stronger demand is expected to last, new firms join. More firms means market supply shifts right, which pushes the price back down, and with it the profit of the firms already there.
In fact, Auto Eco’s firms were already earning a profit of 240 at the original price, and the demand rise lifts it to 420. So outsiders had a reason to enter from the start. Stronger demand makes that reason stronger.
So the question “What happens when demand rises?” needs a time frame. In the short run, the firms already in the market produce more along their supply curves and earn more. In the long run, the number of firms can change too. Reading 4 follows that adjustment until the market settles again.
Summary. Comparative statics separates the shift that changes equilibrium from the price adjustment that restores market clearing. A demand shift moves equilibrium price and quantity in the same direction; a supply shift moves them in opposite directions. When both curves shift, one outcome may be ambiguous.
04
Entry, exit and long-run equilibrium
What changes when the number of firms is no longer fixed?
A short-run equilibrium is a steady point for a fixed group of firms. It isn’t necessarily the end of the story. The long run is a conceptual time horizon in which all inputs can change: labor and materials, but also plants, equipment and whether a firm operates in this market at all. It isn’t a set number of months. It’s however long it takes for nothing to be fixed. Over that horizon, firms outside the market will want to enter if the firms inside are making an economic profit, and firms inside will want to leave if they’re making a loss.
4.1
The decision-maker changes
In the short run, the decision is made by a firm already in the market, choosing how much to produce this month. Its plant, its technology and the fact that it’s in this market are all fixed. In the long run, two new kinds of decision open up. A firm outside the market decides whether to commit resources to entering it. And a firm already in the market decides whether to stay, or move its resources to some other use.
How long that takes depends on what has to change. A food truck can start serving a new market within a week. A new mine can take years. Both are long-run decisions, because in each case the firm can change every input, including whether it’s in the market at all. You saw the same idea in Week 2 with the hotel and the lease.
Because the decision is different, the costs that matter are different too. A firm deciding whether to enter has to count everything it would commit: its plant, its equipment, and its owners’ money and time. A firm that leaves gets those resources back to use elsewhere. So long-run profit compares what the firm earns in this market with the full opportunity cost of those resources: what they could earn in their next-best use.
4.2
Positive profit attracts entry
With ten Auto Eco firms, the short-run equilibrium gives each firm a profit of 240, or $24 million a month. A potential entrant with the same technology can see that opportunity too.
When one more firm enters, market supply becomes the sum of eleven firms’ supplies instead of ten. At every price above the shutdown threshold, the market now supplies more, so the market supply curve shifts right.
Look at what happens at the old price of 90. Buyers still want 80, or 8,000 vehicles. But eleven firms would each want to supply 8, for a total of 88, or 8,800 vehicles. Entry has created excess supply at the old price, so the price falls. As it falls, every firm produces less and earns less.
Entry continues as long as the market price would leave another identical firm with a positive economic profit. It stops only when joining the market is no better than the entrant’s next-best alternative.
4.3
The zero-economic-profit condition
Where does entry stop? Recall from Week 2 that Auto Eco's average cost is lowest at an output of 4, or 400 vehicles a month. At that output, average cost and marginal cost are equal:
As long as the price is above 50, firms earn a profit, so more firms enter and the price keeps falling. If the price fell below 50, firms would make losses, and some would leave, pushing the price back up. So entry and exit settle the price at 50, or $50,000 per vehicle. At that price, a firm producing four earns
That's , which isn't the same as earning nothing. Economic cost already includes what the owners' money and time could earn in their next-best use. Zero economic profit means revenue covers all of that exactly. The owners earn just as much as they would elsewhere, so they have no reason to leave, and newcomers have no reason to enter.
With identical technologies and free entry, each firm that's producing in a long-run equilibrium satisfies three equalities at once:
Here's why, step by step. First, each firm chooses its output so that price equals marginal cost, as in Reading 2. Second, entry and exit push profit to zero, so price equals average cost. Put those two together, and marginal cost must equal average cost. That happens only at the output where average cost is at its lowest, which is the last equality. So in the long run, every firm that's producing operates at the lowest average cost its technology allows.
4.4
How many firms serve the market?
Zero profit settles two things: the long-run price, 50, and each firm's output, 4. Demand settles a third: how much the market buys at that price. The number of firms is whatever makes total supply match that amount.
At \(p=50\), market demand is
or 12,000 vehicles a month. Each firm produces 4, so the number of firms needed is
So the long-run outcome is a price of $50,000, 12,000 vehicles a month, 30 firms and 400 vehicles per firm. Compare that with the ten-firm short run. Entry has lowered the price from $90,000 to $50,000 and raised total quantity from 8,000 to 12,000 vehicles. Each of the original ten firms now makes 400 vehicles instead of 800, and its profit has fallen from $24 million a month to zero.
This also tells us what long-run supply looks like. In the long run, the industry can supply any quantity buyers want at $50,000, simply by having more or fewer firms, each making 400 vehicles. If buyers want more, more firms enter. If they want less, some firms leave. Either way, the price returns to $50,000. So the long-run supply curve is a horizontal line at that price.
That's a slight simplification. Firms come in whole numbers, so supply can only change in steps of 4. If demand at 50 were 122 instead of 120, 30 firms would supply 120 and 31 would supply 124, and neither would match exactly. In a large market with many firms, these steps are tiny compared with the whole market, so the horizontal line is a very good approximation.
4.5
A permanent demand increase
Start from the long-run equilibrium in 4.4: 30 firms, a price of $50,000 and 12,000 vehicles a month. Now suppose demand rises permanently to the stronger demand from Reading 3:
Short run. At first, the number of firms is still 30. Each firm's supply is \((p-10)/10\), so 30 firms together supply \(3(p-10)=3p-30\). Setting demand equal to supply:
The price rises to $60,000, and the market buys \(210-60=150\), or 15,000 vehicles. Each firm now makes \((60-10)/10=5\), or 500 vehicles. Its average cost at that output is \(80/5+10+5\times5=51\), so its profit is
or $4.5 million a month. Firms that were earning zero are now making a profit.
Long run. That profit attracts entry. New firms keep joining until the price is back at $50,000, where profit is zero again. At that price, buyers now want
or 16,000 vehicles. Each firm still makes 4, so the number of firms is
Ten new firms have entered. Under the assumptions of this model, stronger demand doesn't lead to a permanently higher price. It leads to a bigger industry: the price and each firm's output return to where they were, while total quantity and the number of firms rise.
The price rises, existing firms produce more, and their profit rises.
Entry expands supply, the price returns to minimum average cost, and the industry has more firms.
4.6
The assumptions behind a horizontal long-run supply curve
The result that the long-run price returns exactly to $50,000 needs more than free entry. New firms must have the same technology as existing firms and pay the same prices for their inputs. The industry must be able to grow without making its inputs scarcer and more expensive. And nothing else can change while entry is happening.
If those conditions fail, the result changes. Suppose that as the industry grows, it pushes up wages, land prices or the cost of materials. Then every firm's costs rise as more firms join. Each expansion of the industry needs a higher price to cover those higher costs, so long-run supply slopes upward instead of being flat. A rise in demand then leaves a higher price, even in the long run.
Now suppose firms have different technologies. The next firm to enter may have higher costs than the firms already in the market. Entry stops when that last entrant just breaks even, but the lower-cost firms still earn a profit at that price. You've already seen this pattern twice: in Week 2's medication market, where small producers earned a profit at $40 while large producers just broke even, and in Portakal, where island farms keep earning a profit because low-cost island land is scarce.
Finally, if entry is blocked, profit can last indefinitely with no new supply at all.
So the zero-profit result is a prediction that holds under specific conditions: identical technology, free entry and an industry that can grow without raising its own input costs. Reading 5 relaxes these conditions one at a time.
Summary. With identical technologies and free entry, positive profit attracts entry and losses induce exit. Long-run equilibrium occurs where price equals minimum average cost, each active firm earns zero economic profit and the number of firms adjusts to satisfy market demand.
05
When competitive profit persists
What prevents entry from competing profit away?
In the Auto Eco market, positive profit attracted identical new firms, and they kept coming until the profit was gone. So if we see a market where economic profit lasts, some part of that argument must have broken down.
The part that breaks down doesn’t have to be price-taking. A firm can be far too small to affect the price and still have something newcomers can’t get: a scarce resource, a license or a cheaper technology that rivals can’t copy. Each firm still takes the price as given, just as in any competitive market. What’s restricted is who gets to produce.
The Portakal example in this reading shows the difference clearly. Every farm grows the same oranges, and every farm takes the price as given. What’s scarce is the right to farm on the island.
5.1
The Portakal market
On the remote island of Portakal, local demand for oranges is
where quantity is in tonnes and price is in dollars per tonne.
Each island farm has the same economic cost function. The subscript \(i\) stands for “island”:
Dividing total cost by output gives average cost, and the cost of growing one more tonne gives marginal cost:
As we saw in Reading 4, average cost is lowest where it equals marginal cost. Setting the two equal:
At 10 tonnes, average cost is \(10+1+10=21\). So $21 a tonne is the lowest average cost an island farm can reach. It’s also the farm’s shutdown threshold: below $21 a tonne, a farm grows nothing.
Land and local regulation allow at most fifty farms on the island, and each of them is a price-taker. The cap changes who is allowed to produce. It doesn’t change how a farm that is producing decides how much to grow: it still sets price equal to marginal cost.
5.2
What free entry would require
Start by asking what would happen without the cap. If any number of identical island farms could enter, the reasoning from Reading 4 applies. Farms would keep entering until the price fell to the lowest average cost, $21 a tonne, with each farm growing 10 tonnes. At that price, buyers want
tonnes. Supplying 1,000 tonnes at 10 tonnes per farm would take 100 farms. But Portakal allows only fifty. The free-entry outcome can’t happen, so the cap actually limits the market.
This comparison is worth doing first. It tells us whether the cap matters before we work out what happens with it. Suppose demand at $21 had been only 400 tonnes. Then forty farms would have been enough, and a cap of fifty would have made no difference at all.
5.3
Equilibrium with the fifty-farm cap
Now put the cap back. At any price above $21, each island farm grows the amount at which price equals marginal cost:
With all fifty farms growing, market supply is fifty times that:
Set supply equal to demand and solve for the price:
The price of $25 a tonne is above the $21 shutdown threshold, so every farm does grow. The market clears at 600 tonnes. Compared with free entry, the cap means a higher price ($25 instead of $21) and much less fruit (600 tonnes instead of 1,000).
Each farm grows \((25-1)/2=12\) tonnes. Its economic profit is
Every farm is choosing its best output, and the market clears. Yet each farm earns a profit of $44. That profit lasts because the one thing that would compete it away, a fifty-first low-cost farm, isn’t allowed in.
5.4
Opening the market to mainland farms
Now allow farmers on the mainland to ship oranges to Portakal. They use the same farming methods as the island farms, but shipping costs them $2 for every tonne. So their cost function, with the subscript \(m\) for “mainland,” is
The only difference from an island farm is the $2 added to every tonne. That raises both average cost and marginal cost by $2 at every output, just as the battery cost in Reading 3 added $20,000 to every vehicle. The lowest point of average cost stays at 10 tonnes, but it’s now $23 instead of $21:
There are many mainland farmers who could enter, and nothing stops them. So the reasoning from Reading 4 applies to them. They keep entering as long as the price is above $23, which is the lowest average cost they can reach. Entry therefore holds the market price at $23 a tonne. At that price, buyers want
tonnes.
Who supplies those 800 tonnes? The island farms come first. The price of $23 is above their $21 threshold, so all fifty keep growing. Each sets \(23=1+2q\), so each grows 11 tonnes, and together they supply 550. Mainland farms supply the rest. Each mainland farm grows 10 tonnes, at its lowest average cost, so the number of mainland farms is
5.5
The marginal technology earns zero; the low-cost farms don't
A mainland farm earns zero economic profit at $23, because $23 is its lowest average cost. An island farm does better:
Opening the market has cut each island farm’s profit from $44 to $21, but it hasn’t eliminated it. Mainland entry can push the price down only to $23. Below that, mainland farms would make losses and leave. So the island farms keep their $2 cost advantage on every tonne, and that advantage is where their profit comes from.
Economists call this kind of profit a : a return that comes from controlling something scarce, here low-cost access to farmland on the island, rather than from farming any better than anyone else.
That changes how we should measure the island farms’ profit. If the right to farm on the island can be leased, a farmer would pay up to $21 a period to lease it, because that’s what it earns. If the right can be sold, its price should reflect what all those future earnings are worth today. Either way, the right has a market value, and that value is an opportunity cost for whoever holds it, since they could lease it out or sell it instead of farming. Count that cost, and an island farm’s economic profit is zero too, whether the farmer bought the right last week or has owned it for generations. The $21 hasn’t disappeared. It’s the return to owning the right, and it goes to whoever owns it.
5.6
What persistent profit tells a manager
When firms in a price-taking industry keep earning a profit, that’s not a puzzle. It’s a clue. It tells you that one of the assumptions behind the zero-profit result has stopped holding, and it points you toward which one.
| Possible source | Question to ask |
|---|---|
| Scarce land or natural resource | Can another firm obtain an equally productive site? |
| Licence or regulation | Who is legally allowed to enter, and can the rule change? |
| Patent or proprietary technology | How long does the protection last, and can rivals invent around it? |
| Capacity, finance or distribution access | Is the constraint temporary or structural? |
| Lower opportunity cost | Can entrants copy the cost advantage, or is it tied to a scarce resource? |
How long the profit lasts depends on how long the barrier or cost advantage lasts. A regulation can be repealed. A patent expires. A scarce location can’t be copied, but as 5.5 showed, its value ends up in the price of the land or the right, so whoever owns it collects the profit.
This way of thinking also prepares us for monopoly. In Week 3, every firm takes the market price as given. In Week 4, we study a firm that produces enough of the market’s output to change the price it receives.
Summary. Positive economic profit can persist in a competitive market when entry is restricted or firms have different costs. Portakal's low-cost island farms earn scarcity rents because low-cost sites are capped; higher-cost mainland entry pins down price but doesn't erase the island cost advantage.