Read 3 of 5
When demand or supply shifts
How does a market find a new equilibrium after fundamentals change?
An equilibrium depends on the demand and supply curves that produced it. But the things behind those curves change all the time. Incomes rise and fall, production costs change, and buyers discover alternatives. When something like this changes, one of the curves shifts, and the old price no longer clears the market.
Two things then happen, one after the other. First, a curve shifts, which creates a new equilibrium. Second, at the old price there’s now either a shortage or unsold output, and that pushes the price toward the new equilibrium. Comparing the old equilibrium with the new one is called comparative statics. It’s “statics” because we compare the two points where the market is at rest, not the path between them.
The method is simple, but reading the results takes care. We’ll predict the new market price and quantity first, then go back to one firm and work out its new output and profit.
3.1
A four-step method
Start from a market in equilibrium and work through these steps in order:
- Name the event. Decide whether it affects buyers, through demand, or firms, through their costs or how many of them there are, which affects supply.
- Shift the right curve. Identify which curve shifts and in which direction. Leave the other curve where it is, unless the event affects it too.
- Check the old price. At the old price, work out whether there’s now excess demand or excess supply. That tells you which way the price will move.
- Compare the equilibria. Find the new equilibrium price and quantity and compare them with the old ones. Then use the new price to work out one firm’s output and profit.
The order matters. Saying “demand rises, so price rises” skips the part that explains why. Here’s the missing step. When demand shifts right, buyers want more than firms supply at the old price, so there’s excess demand. Buyers compete for the vehicles available, and the price rises. As it rises, quantity demanded falls along the new demand curve, and quantity supplied rises along the existing supply curve, until the two meet.
This kind of exercise compares the two points where the market is at rest. It doesn’t claim the market gets from one to the other instantly or smoothly.
3.2
A rise in demand
Let’s apply the four steps.
Step 1: name the event. Suppose buyers’ tastes shift toward electric vehicles. This affects buyers, so it’s a demand change. Nothing about the firms’ costs has changed.
Step 2: shift the right curve. Market demand shifts right, from \(Q^d(p)=170-p\) to
The subscript 1 marks the new curve, after the change. Supply stays where it is: the ten firms’ short-run market supply is still \(Q^s(p)=p-10\).
Step 3: check the old price. At the old price of 90, buyers now want \(210-90=120\), or 12,000 vehicles. The ten firms still supply 80, or 8,000. That’s excess demand of 40, so the price is pushed up.
Step 4: compare the equilibria. Set the new demand equal to the existing supply:
The new price of 110 is above the shutdown threshold of 50, so the supply formula applies. The market now clears at $110,000 per vehicle, with 10,000 vehicles sold each month.
Now go back to one firm. Each of the ten firms makes one tenth of the market quantity, so output rises from 8 to 10, or 1,000 vehicles. You can check this with marginal cost: \(110=10+10q\) gives \(q=10\). At that output,
Profit rises from 240 to 420, or from $24 million to $42 million a month.
So in the short run, stronger demand raises the market price and the market quantity. It also raises each firm’s output and profit.
3.3
An increase in production cost
Go back to the original demand, \(Q^d(p)=170-p\), and apply the four steps to a different event.
Step 1: name the event. Suppose a battery component becomes more expensive, adding $20,000 to the cost of every vehicle. This affects firms’ costs, so it’s a supply change. Nothing about buyers has changed.
Step 2: shift the right curve. In the cost function, the cost per unit rises from 10 to 30:
Marginal cost is now \(MC_1(q)=30+10q\), which is 20 higher at every output. The shutdown threshold changes too. Because the battery adds the same amount to every vehicle, average cost rises by 20 at every output. Its lowest point is still at an output of 4, but it’s now \(80/4+30+5\times4=70\) instead of 50. So no firm produces below $70,000. Above that price, one firm’s supply is \((p-30)/10\), and the ten firms together supply
Market supply has shifted left. At every price above 70, firms now offer 20 fewer units, or 2,000 fewer vehicles, than before.
Step 3: check the old price. At the old price of 90, firms now supply \(90-30=60\), or 6,000 vehicles, while buyers still want 80, or 8,000. That’s excess demand of 20, so the price is pushed up.
Step 4: compare the equilibria. Set demand equal to the new supply:
The new price of 100 is above the new threshold of 70, so the answer stands. The market now clears at $100,000 per vehicle, with 7,000 vehicles sold each month. The price is higher and the quantity is lower.
Now go back to one firm. Each firm makes 7, or 700 vehicles. At that output,
Profit falls from 240 to 165, or from $24 million to $16.5 million a month. The price went up, but the firms are worse off. Here’s why. The price rose by $10,000 per vehicle. But average cost at the firm’s output rose by more: from 60 to \(535/7\approx76.4\), or about $16,400 per vehicle. The margin on each vehicle shrank, and the firm also sells fewer vehicles.
So a higher market price isn’t, by itself, evidence that demand is stronger or that producers are doing better. A drop in supply also raises the price, and it can leave producers with less profit.
3.4
The four basic cases
| Change | Curve | Equilibrium price | Equilibrium quantity |
|---|---|---|---|
| Demand increases | Demand shifts right | Rises | Rises |
| Demand decreases | Demand shifts left | Falls | Falls |
| Supply increases | Supply shifts right | Falls | Rises |
| Supply decreases | Supply shifts left | Rises | Falls |
There’s a simple pattern here. When demand shifts, price and quantity move in the same direction. When supply shifts, they move in opposite directions.
The reason is which curve the market slides along. When demand shifts, supply stays put, so the new equilibrium is somewhere else on the same supply curve. Supply slopes upward, so a higher price comes with a higher quantity. That’s what happened in 3.2: price and quantity both rose. When supply shifts, demand stays put, so the new equilibrium is somewhere else on the same demand curve. Demand slopes downward, so a higher price comes with a lower quantity. That’s what happened in 3.3: price rose and quantity fell.
The pattern also works in reverse, as a way to diagnose what happened. If an industry reports a higher price and a higher quantity, a rise in demand fits what you see. A higher price with a lower quantity points instead to a drop in supply. A lower price with a lower quantity fits a fall in demand, and a lower price with a higher quantity fits a rise in supply.
Notice the word “fits.” Two numbers alone can’t prove what caused them. Both curves may have shifted at once. The price and the quantity may have been measured over different periods. Or a legal limit on the price may have stopped it from adjusting at all. The table tells you what the model predicts. It doesn’t replace evidence about what actually happened.
3.5
When both curves shift
Sometimes two things change at once. Suppose demand rises at the same time as supply falls. Both shifts push the price up, so we can be sure the price rises. But the two shifts pull quantity in opposite directions: more demand pushes quantity up, while less supply pushes it down. Which effect wins depends on which shift is bigger.
Both shifts agree about price.
The shifts pull quantity in opposite directions.
Auto Eco shows both possibilities. Suppose buyers’ tastes shift toward electric vehicles at the same time as battery costs rise, so supply becomes \(Q^s_1(p)=p-30\) as in 3.3. If demand rises all the way to \(210-p\) as in 3.2, the new equilibrium is a price of 120 and a quantity of 90, so quantity rises from 80. If demand rises only to \(180-p\), the new equilibrium is a price of 105 and a quantity of 75, so quantity falls. The price rises in both cases. Quantity depends on which shift is bigger.
The other combinations work the same way. If demand falls while supply rises, the price definitely falls, but quantity could go either way. If demand and supply both shift right, quantity definitely rises, but the price could go either way. If both shift left, quantity definitely falls, and again the price could go either way.
Economists call an outcome like this ambiguous. That doesn’t mean it can’t be worked out. If you know how far each curve shifts, you can calculate the answer, as we just did. It means that knowing the directions of the shifts isn’t enough on its own.
3.6
Short-run and long-run responses are different questions
Every calculation in this reading has kept the number of firms fixed at ten. That makes them short-run comparisons. In the short run, a lasting rise in demand raises the price, each firm’s output and each firm’s profit, as we found in 3.2.
But profit has another effect: firms outside the market notice it. Each one compares what it could earn by entering with what it earns elsewhere. If entry is free and the stronger demand is expected to last, new firms join. More firms means market supply shifts right, which pushes the price back down, and with it the profit of the firms already there.
In fact, Auto Eco’s firms were already earning a profit of 240 at the original price, and the demand rise lifts it to 420. So outsiders had a reason to enter from the start. Stronger demand makes that reason stronger.
So the question “What happens when demand rises?” needs a time frame. In the short run, the firms already in the market produce more along their supply curves and earn more. In the long run, the number of firms can change too. Reading 4 follows that adjustment until the market settles again.
Summary