Read 4 of 5

Entry, exit and long-run equilibrium

What changes when the number of firms is no longer fixed?

A short-run equilibrium is a steady point for a fixed group of firms. It isn’t necessarily the end of the story. The long run is a conceptual time horizon in which all inputs can change: labor and materials, but also plants, equipment and whether a firm operates in this market at all. It isn’t a set number of months. It’s however long it takes for nothing to be fixed. Over that horizon, firms outside the market will want to enter if the firms inside are making an economic profit, and firms inside will want to leave if they’re making a loss.

4.1

The decision-maker changes

In the short run, the decision is made by a firm already in the market, choosing how much to produce this month. Its plant, its technology and the fact that it’s in this market are all fixed. In the long run, two new kinds of decision open up. A firm outside the market decides whether to commit resources to entering it. And a firm already in the market decides whether to stay, or move its resources to some other use.

How long that takes depends on what has to change. A food truck can start serving a new market within a week. A new mine can take years. Both are long-run decisions, because in each case the firm can change every input, including whether it’s in the market at all. You saw the same idea in Week 2 with the hotel and the lease.

Because the decision is different, the costs that matter are different too. A firm deciding whether to enter has to count everything it would commit: its plant, its equipment, and its owners’ money and time. A firm that leaves gets those resources back to use elsewhere. So long-run profit compares what the firm earns in this market with the full opportunity cost of those resources: what they could earn in their next-best use.

4.2

Positive profit attracts entry

With ten Auto Eco firms, the short-run equilibrium gives each firm a profit of 240, or $24 million a month. A potential entrant with the same technology can see that opportunity too.

When one more firm enters, market supply becomes the sum of eleven firms’ supplies instead of ten. At every price above the shutdown threshold, the market now supplies more, so the market supply curve shifts right.

Look at what happens at the old price of 90. Buyers still want 80, or 8,000 vehicles. But eleven firms would each want to supply 8, for a total of 88, or 8,800 vehicles. Entry has created excess supply at the old price, so the price falls. As it falls, every firm produces less and earns less.

Entry continues as long as the market price would leave another identical firm with a positive economic profit. It stops only when joining the market is no better than the entrant’s next-best alternative.

Start with ten firms and add entrants. Watch the market price and each firm's profit as market supply expands.

4.3

The zero-economic-profit condition

Where does entry stop? Recall from Week 2 that Auto Eco's average cost is lowest at an output of 4, or 400 vehicles a month. At that output, average cost and marginal cost are equal:

\[AC(4)=\frac{80}{4}+10+5\times4=50,\qquad MC(4)=10+10\times4=50.\]

As long as the price is above 50, firms earn a profit, so more firms enter and the price keeps falling. If the price fell below 50, firms would make losses, and some would leave, pushing the price back up. So entry and exit settle the price at 50, or $50,000 per vehicle. At that price, a firm producing four earns

\(\pi(4)\)\(=\)\([p-AC(4)]\times4\)\(=\)\([50-50]\times4\)\(=\)\(0\)

That's , which isn't the same as earning nothing. Economic cost already includes what the owners' money and time could earn in their next-best use. Zero economic profit means revenue covers all of that exactly. The owners earn just as much as they would elsewhere, so they have no reason to leave, and newcomers have no reason to enter.

With identical technologies and free entry, each firm that's producing in a long-run equilibrium satisfies three equalities at once:

Long-run condition for an active firm\(p=MC(q)=AC(q)=\min AC\)

Here's why, step by step. First, each firm chooses its output so that price equals marginal cost, as in Reading 2. Second, entry and exit push profit to zero, so price equals average cost. Put those two together, and marginal cost must equal average cost. That happens only at the output where average cost is at its lowest, which is the last equality. So in the long run, every firm that's producing operates at the lowest average cost its technology allows.

4.4

How many firms serve the market?

Zero profit settles two things: the long-run price, 50, and each firm's output, 4. Demand settles a third: how much the market buys at that price. The number of firms is whatever makes total supply match that amount.

At \(p=50\), market demand is

\(Q^d(50)\)\(=\)\(170-50\)\(=\)\(120\)

or 12,000 vehicles a month. Each firm produces 4, so the number of firms needed is

\(n^e\)\(=\)\(\dfrac{Q^e}{q^e}\)\(=\)\(\dfrac{120}{4}\)\(=\)\(30\)

So the long-run outcome is a price of $50,000, 12,000 vehicles a month, 30 firms and 400 vehicles per firm. Compare that with the ten-firm short run. Entry has lowered the price from $90,000 to $50,000 and raised total quantity from 8,000 to 12,000 vehicles. Each of the original ten firms now makes 400 vehicles instead of 800, and its profit has fallen from $24 million a month to zero.

This also tells us what long-run supply looks like. In the long run, the industry can supply any quantity buyers want at $50,000, simply by having more or fewer firms, each making 400 vehicles. If buyers want more, more firms enter. If they want less, some firms leave. Either way, the price returns to $50,000. So the long-run supply curve is a horizontal line at that price.

That's a slight simplification. Firms come in whole numbers, so supply can only change in steps of 4. If demand at 50 were 122 instead of 120, 30 firms would supply 120 and 31 would supply 124, and neither would match exactly. In a large market with many firms, these steps are tiny compared with the whole market, so the horizontal line is a very good approximation.

4.5

A permanent demand increase

Start from the long-run equilibrium in 4.4: 30 firms, a price of $50,000 and 12,000 vehicles a month. Now suppose demand rises permanently to the stronger demand from Reading 3:

\[Q^d_1(p)=210-p\]
Start with 30 firms. Shift demand first, then add firms and watch price return to minimum average cost.

Short run. At first, the number of firms is still 30. Each firm's supply is \((p-10)/10\), so 30 firms together supply \(3(p-10)=3p-30\). Setting demand equal to supply:

\(210-p\)\(=\)\(3p-30\)\(240\)\(=\)\(4p\)\(p\)\(=\)\(60\)

The price rises to $60,000, and the market buys \(210-60=150\), or 15,000 vehicles. Each firm now makes \((60-10)/10=5\), or 500 vehicles. Its average cost at that output is \(80/5+10+5\times5=51\), so its profit is

\[\pi(5)=[60-51]\times5=45,\]

or $4.5 million a month. Firms that were earning zero are now making a profit.

Long run. That profit attracts entry. New firms keep joining until the price is back at $50,000, where profit is zero again. At that price, buyers now want

\(Q^d_1(50)\)\(=\)\(210-50\)\(=\)\(160\)

or 16,000 vehicles. Each firm still makes 4, so the number of firms is

\(n^e_1\)\(=\)\(\dfrac{160}{4}\)\(=\)\(40\)

Ten new firms have entered. Under the assumptions of this model, stronger demand doesn't lead to a permanently higher price. It leads to a bigger industry: the price and each firm's output return to where they were, while total quantity and the number of firms rise.

Short run

The price rises, existing firms produce more, and their profit rises.

Long run

Entry expands supply, the price returns to minimum average cost, and the industry has more firms.

4.6

The assumptions behind a horizontal long-run supply curve

The result that the long-run price returns exactly to $50,000 needs more than free entry. New firms must have the same technology as existing firms and pay the same prices for their inputs. The industry must be able to grow without making its inputs scarcer and more expensive. And nothing else can change while entry is happening.

If those conditions fail, the result changes. Suppose that as the industry grows, it pushes up wages, land prices or the cost of materials. Then every firm's costs rise as more firms join. Each expansion of the industry needs a higher price to cover those higher costs, so long-run supply slopes upward instead of being flat. A rise in demand then leaves a higher price, even in the long run.

Now suppose firms have different technologies. The next firm to enter may have higher costs than the firms already in the market. Entry stops when that last entrant just breaks even, but the lower-cost firms still earn a profit at that price. You've already seen this pattern twice: in Week 2's medication market, where small producers earned a profit at $40 while large producers just broke even, and in Portakal, where island farms keep earning a profit because low-cost island land is scarce.

Finally, if entry is blocked, profit can last indefinitely with no new supply at all.

So the zero-profit result is a prediction that holds under specific conditions: identical technology, free entry and an industry that can grow without raising its own input costs. Reading 5 relaxes these conditions one at a time.

Summary

With identical technologies and free entry, positive profit attracts entry and losses induce exit. Long-run equilibrium occurs where price equals minimum average cost, each active firm earns zero economic profit and the number of firms adjusts to satisfy market demand.

Concept atlas