Week 7: Assignment

The Advertisement Game

In an oligopoly, a firm advertises to raise demand for its own product, often at its rivals' expense. When every firm does it, the ads can largely cancel out.

Two identical firms, Wholesome Grains and Crunchy Morning's, sell breakfast cereal and must decide how many ads to run. If Wholesome Grains runs \(k_w\) ads and Crunchy Morning's runs \(k_c\), their revenues, in thousands of dollars, are

\(R_w\)\(=\)\(240k_w-10k_w(k_w+k_c)\)\(R_c\)\(=\)\(240k_c-10k_c(k_w+k_c)\)

Each firm's revenue rises with its own ads, at a decreasing rate, and falls with the rival's ads.

A firm can make its ads in one of two ways.

  • Outsource them to an agency, at $120,000 per ad. A firm that outsources \(k\) ads pays \(120k\) thousand dollars.
  • Build an in-house department for a fixed cost of $300,000, after which each ad costs $60,000. A firm that makes \(k\) ads in-house pays \(300+60k\) thousand dollars.

The firms first play the outsourcing game: each decides, privately and at the same time, whether to outsource or build a department. Both then see these decisions and play the ads game: each chooses, privately and at the same time, how many ads to run. Each firm's payoff is its revenue minus its advertising cost.

Question 1

Suppose both firms have chosen to outsource. Find the Nash equilibrium of the ads game. How many ads does each firm run, and what are the firms' payoffs?

Question 2

Now find the credible Nash equilibrium of the whole game, in which the firms first play the outsourcing game and then, having seen each other's choices, play the ads game. Draw the payoff matrix of the outsourcing game. Do the firms outsource? How many ads does each run, and what are the payoffs?

Solution

Locked

Available Tuesday, 1 December 2026 at 10:15 am (Melbourne time), after the quiz.

Concept atlas