Week 7: Practice

A Tale of Two Cities

Two companies collect rubbish in the Melbourne cities of Boroondara and Stonnington. Both use the same simple technology, with no fixed costs and a collection cost of $50 a tonne. Each city has just passed a law charging companies based outside the city an extra administrative fee of $15 a tonne. So each company must declare its home in one of the two cities.

Weekly inverse demand for rubbish collection in each city is

\(p^b\)\(=\)\(200-\tfrac{1}{4}Q^b\)Boroondara\(p^s\)\(=\)\(200-\tfrac{1}{3}Q^s\)Stonnington

where \(Q^b\) and \(Q^s\) are the tonnes collected in each city by both companies together. In each city, the companies choose how much to collect at the same time, and the price clears the market.

Question 1

Both companies are based in Boroondara. Find each company's best-response function in each city, the equilibrium tonnes and price in each city, and each company's weekly profit.

Reveal the solution

Both companies pay 50 a tonne in Boroondara and 65 in Stonnington.

Boroondara. Company 1's marginal revenue is \(200-\frac{1}{2}q_1-\frac{1}{4}q_2\). Setting it equal to 50 gives \(q_1=300-\frac{q_2}{2}\). By symmetry each collects \(q=300-\frac{q}{2}\), so \(q=200\). The total is 400, the price is \(200-100=100\), and each earns \((100-50)\times200=10{,}000\).

Stonnington. Marginal revenue is \(200-\frac{2}{3}q_1-\frac{1}{3}q_2\). Setting it equal to 65 gives \(q_1=\frac{405-q_2}{2}\). By symmetry \(q=135\). The total is 270, the price is 110, and each earns \((110-65)\times135=6{,}075\).

Each company earns \(10{,}000+6{,}075=16{,}075\) a week.

Question 2

Both companies are based in Stonnington. Answer the same questions.

Reveal the solution

Now the cost is 65 in Boroondara and 50 in Stonnington.

Boroondara: \(q_i=270-\frac{q_j}{2}\), so 180 each. The total is 360, the price is 110, and each earns \(45\times180=8{,}100\).

Stonnington: \(q_i=\frac{450-q_j}{2}\), so 150 each. The total is 300, the price is 100, and each earns \(50\times150=7{,}500\).

Each company earns \(8{,}100+7{,}500=15{,}600\) a week.

Question 3

Company 1 is based in Boroondara and Company 2 in Stonnington. Answer the same questions.

Reveal the solution

Boroondara. Company 1's cost is 50 and Company 2's is 65:

\(q_1\)\(=\)\(300-\dfrac{q_2}{2}\)\(q_2\)\(=\)\(270-\dfrac{q_1}{2}\)

Substituting, \(q_1=300-135+\frac{q_1}{4}\), so \(q_1=220\) and \(q_2=160\). The total is 380 and the price is 105. Company 1 earns \(55\times220=12{,}100\) and Company 2 earns \(40\times160=6{,}400\).

Stonnington. Company 1's cost is 65 and Company 2's is 50:

\(q_1\)\(=\)\(\dfrac{405-q_2}{2}\)\(q_2\)\(=\)\(\dfrac{450-q_1}{2}\)

Substituting gives \(q_1=120\) and \(q_2=165\). The total is 285 and the price is 105. Company 1 earns \(40\times120=4{,}800\) and Company 2 earns \(55\times165=9{,}075\).

Company 1 earns \(12{,}100+4{,}800=16{,}900\) and Company 2 earns \(6{,}400+9{,}075=15{,}475\). The lower-cost firm in each city produces more, and each firm does best in the city where it's based.

Question 4

Now the companies choose where to be based, one after the other. Company 1 chooses first, and Company 2 sees its choice. After that they compete as above. Where does each company locate?

Reveal the solution
Weekly profits for each pair of locations.

Solve backward. If Company 1 is in Boroondara, Company 2 earns 16,075 in Boroondara and 15,475 in Stonnington, so it picks Boroondara. If Company 1 is in Stonnington, Company 2 earns 16,900 in Boroondara and 15,600 in Stonnington, so it again picks Boroondara. Company 1 then compares 16,075 in Boroondara with 15,475 in Stonnington.

In the credible Nash equilibrium, both companies locate in Boroondara. In fact Boroondara is a dominant strategy for each, so the order of moves doesn't matter. The larger market is worth more as a home base: the 15-dollar disadvantage costs more there, because more tonnes are collected there.

Concept atlas