Read 4 of 5
From firm supply to market supply
How do the production decisions of many firms add up?
Market supply is built exactly the way market demand is. Pick a price. Ask how much each firm would supply at that price, and add up their quantities. Then do the same at every other price.
If all the firms have the same costs, this is easy: work out how much one firm supplies and multiply by the number of firms. If firms use different technologies, their costs differ, and so do the prices at which they’re willing to produce. Firms with low costs start producing at low prices. Firms with higher costs join only as the price rises. The order in which firms start producing and expand their output shapes the market supply curve.
4.1
Adding firms horizontally
Here’s the idea with numbers. Suppose that at a price of $15, one firm supplies five units, another supplies eight and a third supplies nothing. Market supply at $15 is \(5+8+0=13\) units.
In symbols, the notation works just as it did for demand. Let \(q_j^s(p)\) be the quantity firm \(j\) supplies at price \(p\). The superscript \(s\) stands for supply, and the subscript \(j\) tells you which firm. With \(N\) firms, is
As with demand, this is a horizontal sum. Quantity is on the horizontal axis, and quantities are what we add.
There are two things we don’t do. We don’t average the firms. An average firm doesn’t tell you how much is available to buy in the market, which is what market supply is for. And we don’t add prices. In a competitive market, every firm selling the same good gets the same market price.
Like market demand, market supply can have kinks. It can also have jumps. A kink is a point where the slope of the curve changes. A jump is a price at which total quantity leaps from one amount to another, skipping the amounts in between. Both come from events like these: a firm starts producing once the price reaches its shutdown threshold, a factory reaches capacity and can’t produce any more, or a more expensive technology becomes worth using. Each event changes how much total quantity responds to price. You’ll see a jump in the Auto Eco example below.
4.2
Identical firms: Auto Eco
Return to Auto Eco. Quantity \(q\) is measured in hundreds of vehicles per month, and prices and costs are in thousands of dollars, so \(q=6\) means 600 vehicles and a price of 70 means $70,000. Each firm has the cost function
As we found earlier, each firm’s shutdown threshold is $50,000. Above that price, its supply is
Now suppose the market has ten identical firms. Because they’re identical, every firm supplies the same amount at any price above $50,000. Market supply is therefore ten times one firm’s supply:
Here \(Q^s\), like \(q^s\), is measured in hundreds of vehicles. At \(p=70\), or $70,000, each firm supplies \(q^s(70)=(70-10)/10=6\), or 600 vehicles. The market therefore supplies 60 hundreds of vehicles, or 6,000 per month. At \(p=100\), each firm supplies 900 vehicles and the market supplies 9,000.
Below $50,000, no firm produces, so market supply is zero.
Exactly $50,000 is a special case. At that price, a firm that produces \(q=4\), or 400 vehicles, just breaks even. Its revenue is \(4\times 50=200\), and its cost is \(80+40+80=200\). Both amounts are in hundreds of thousands of dollars, so each equals $20 million. A firm that produces nothing also earns zero. Each firm is therefore indifferent between producing zero and producing 400 vehicles.
Depending on how many of the ten firms produce, the market supplies 0, 400, 800 and so on, up to 4,000 vehicles. In the units of the equation, these quantities are \(0,4,8,\ldots,40\). Putting the three cases together:
Now look at what happens around $50,000. Just below it, the market supplies nothing. Just above it, the market supplies just over 40 hundreds of vehicles, or just over 4,000 vehicles. Total quantity leaps from zero to 4,000 without passing through the quantities in between as the price changes. This is the jump described in Section 4.1, and it isn't a calculation error.
The jump comes from the fixed cost of $8 million in each firm’s economic cost function. A firm that produces nothing doesn't pay it, but a firm that produces anything does. To cover the fixed cost, the firm has to spread it over enough vehicles. At $50,000, the best it can do is break even by producing \(q=4\), or 400 vehicles. Producing \(q=1\) or \(q=2\), meaning 100 or 200 vehicles, would make a loss at that price. So a firm never produces a small positive amount around the threshold. It either stays out or produces at least 400 vehicles.
4.3
What the number of firms changes
Use the slider to change the number of identical Auto Eco firms. The blue curve is one firm’s supply, and it never moves. The green curve is market supply, and it stretches to the right as you add firms.
If the number of firms rises from ten to twenty, market supply doubles at every price above the shutdown threshold. At $70,000, for example, ten firms supply \(Q^s=60\), or 6,000 vehicles, and twenty firms supply \(Q^s=120\), or 12,000. Each firm’s own supply hasn't changed. Each still produces \(q^s=6\), or 600 vehicles, at that price. The market curve shifts right only because there are more individual curves to add up.
So market output can grow in two different ways. If the market price rises, each firm moves along its own supply curve and produces more. The market moves along its supply curve too. If the number of firms rises, each firm’s supply stays the same, but there are more firms, so the whole market supply curve shifts right.
Scale also affects how a single firm relates to the market. If Auto Eco supplies 600 of 6,000 vehicles, it accounts for ten percent of output. With one thousand similar firms it would account for one tenth of one percent. The smaller its share, the more plausible it is that changing its own quantity leaves the market price essentially unchanged.
4.4
Firms with different technologies
Imagine the market for a generic medication, sold by the pack. Because it’s generic, every firm’s pack is the same product, and every firm sells at the same market price.
Two kinds of firms make it. There are 100 small producers like Apex. Each can make at most 100 packs a month, at a marginal cost of $10 a pack, and each has a fixed cost of $1,000 a month. There are also 300 large producers like Boulder. Each can make up to 200 packs a month, also at $10 a pack, but its fixed cost is $6,000 a month. A firm that produces nothing in a month avoids its fixed cost.
The government is worried about a possible disease outbreak. An outbreak would raise demand for the medication and push its price up. Before that happens, the health department wants to know how much the industry would supply at different prices. That will help it predict where prices could go and decide whether it might need a subsidy. Market supply answers exactly that question.
Step 1: Apex’s lowest average cost. Apex’s cost function is \(C_A(q)=1{,}000+10q\), so its average cost is
As output rises, the $1,000 fixed cost is spread over more packs, so average cost falls. It keeps falling all the way to capacity. Apex’s lowest average cost is therefore at 100 packs:
That makes $20 Apex’s shutdown threshold.
Step 2: Apex’s supply. Below $20, Apex can’t cover its costs, so it produces nothing. Above $20, the price is also above its marginal cost of $10. Every extra pack adds to profit, and Apex produces at capacity. At exactly $20, Apex breaks even whether it makes 0 packs or 100, so it’s indifferent between the two.
Step 3: Boulder’s lowest average cost. Boulder’s cost function is \(C_B(q)=6{,}000+10q\), so its average cost is
The same reasoning applies. Average cost falls all the way to capacity, so Boulder’s lowest average cost is at 200 packs:
Boulder’s shutdown threshold is $40.
Step 4: Boulder’s supply. Below $40, Boulder produces nothing. Above $40, the price is above its marginal cost of $10, so Boulder produces at capacity. At exactly $40, it’s indifferent between 0 and 200 packs.
Step 5: Supply from each group. All 100 small producers are identical to Apex, so we multiply Apex’s supply by 100. At exactly $20, the total depends on how many small producers choose to operate. As with Auto Eco, it can be any multiple of 100 up to 10,000.
The 300 large producers are identical to Boulder, so we multiply Boulder’s supply by 300.
Step 6: Market supply. Market supply is the two groups added together, \(Q^s(p)=Q_A^s(p)+Q_B^s(p)\):
Here’s what this tells the health department. Below $20, nobody makes the medication. Between $20 and $40, the industry supplies 10,000 packs a month, all from the small producers. A higher price within that range doesn’t bring out a single extra pack. Only at $40 do the large producers start up, and supply can jump to 70,000 packs. So the industry won’t supply more than 10,000 packs a month unless the price reaches $40. The department needs to know this before an outbreak, not after.
4.5
Movement along market supply
A movement along the supply curve shows how quantity supplied responds to a change in the good’s own price, with everything else held fixed: firms’ costs, their technology and the number of firms.
Take Auto Eco. Suppose the price of a vehicle rises from $70,000 to $100,000 while nothing else changes. Each firm moves along its own supply curve and raises output from 600 to 900 vehicles a month. With ten firms, market quantity rises from 6,000 to 9,000 vehicles. On a graph, the market moves up and to the right along its supply curve. If the price fell back to $70,000, it would move down and to the left, back to 6,000.
A movement along the curve can involve more than firms adjusting their output. It also includes firms starting or stopping production as the price crosses their shutdown thresholds. In the medication market, when the price rises above $40, the large producers start up and quantity supplied jumps from 10,000 to 70,000 packs. Nothing about the firms has changed. Their thresholds were always part of the curve, so this is still a movement along supply.
Careful wording helps keep these ideas apart. When the price changes and the market moves along the curve, we say quantity supplied rises or falls. We say supply increases or decreases only when the whole curve shifts. In the Auto Eco example, quantity supplied rose from 6,000 to 9,000 vehicles. Supply itself didn’t change.
4.6
What shifts market supply
A shift in the supply curve means firms want to supply a different quantity at every price. A shift to the right is an increase in supply: more at every price. A shift to the left is a decrease in supply: less at every price. Shifts come from something other than the good’s own price. For market supply, that something is almost always a change in firms’ costs or a change in the number of firms.
Start with production costs and input prices. Firms buy inputs such as labor, raw materials, energy and equipment. When an input gets more expensive, every unit that uses it costs more to make. At any given price, some units that were worth producing no longer are, so supply shifts left. Cheaper inputs shift supply right. Input prices themselves move for many reasons, including world commodity prices, disruptions to supply chains and changes in exchange rates, which change what imported inputs cost in Australian dollars.
Technology works through the same channel. A better production method lets firms make the same output with fewer resources. That lowers the cost of each unit, so supply shifts right.
Government policies change costs too. A tax on each unit sold raises the cost of every unit, so supply shifts left. A subsidy for each unit does the opposite and shifts supply right. A tariff on imported inputs makes those inputs more expensive, which works like any other rise in input prices. Regulations that add compliance costs shift supply left.
Natural events such as droughts, floods and earthquakes can damage crops, factories and transport links. Inputs become scarcer and production becomes more expensive, so supply shifts left.
Finally, the number of firms. As we saw with Auto Eco, more firms means more individual supply curves to add up, so market supply shifts right. Fewer firms shift it left.
Fixed costs deserve a separate note. Some changes raise a firm’s fixed cost without touching its marginal cost, such as a new monthly fee that every operating firm must pay. A firm that keeps producing makes the same quantity at any given price because its marginal cost hasn’t moved. But a higher fixed cost raises its average cost, and with it its shutdown threshold. In the medication market, if the large producers’ fixed cost rose, they’d need a price above $40 before starting up. Market supply shifts because the set of firms willing to produce at a given price has changed.
| Change | Why | Effect on supply |
|---|---|---|
| Input prices rise | Each unit costs more to make | Shifts left |
| Technology improves | Each unit costs less to make | Shifts right |
| Per-unit tax introduced | Each unit costs more | Shifts left |
| Per-unit subsidy introduced | Each unit costs less | Shifts right |
| Drought or other natural disaster | Inputs are scarcer and dearer | Shifts left |
| Number of firms rises | More curves to add up | Shifts right |
Treat the table as a summary, not a list to memorize. For any change, ask two questions. Does it change what it costs a firm to produce one more unit? Does it change which firms find it worth producing at all? If you can answer those, you can work out the direction of the shift.
A solar-panel subsidy
Suppose the government wants to promote renewable energy and introduces a subsidy: it pays solar-panel manufacturers a fixed amount for each panel they produce.
From a manufacturer’s point of view, each panel now brings in the market price plus the subsidy. That’s the same as saying each extra panel costs the manufacturer less, by the amount of the subsidy. Some panels that weren’t worth making before now are, and some higher-cost manufacturers that weren’t producing may now find it worthwhile to start.
So at every market price, manufacturers want to make more. Before the program, at a price of $5,000 per panel, the industry supplied 30,000 panels a month. With the subsidy, at the same $5,000 price, it supplies 36,000. The same happens at every other price, so the whole supply curve shifts right.
Notice what the subsidy does not do, at least not directly: it doesn’t set the price customers pay. Whether the market price falls, and by how much, depends on how supply and demand meet, which comes in a later reading. For now, the point is that the subsidy changes how much firms supply at each price. That’s a shift of the supply curve, not a movement along it.
Summary