Week 02 · Complete notes
Demand and supply in competitive markets
How do buyers and price-taking firms respond to price?
This print edition combines all five readings. Interactive definitions become ordinary text when printed.
01
Individual demand
How does one buyer respond when price changes?
A demand curve isn't a record of what someone bought yesterday. It's a plan. It tells us how much one buyer would choose to buy at every possible price, given their income, their preferences, and the prices of other goods.
The plan comes from a choice. A buyer has a budget, set by their income, and many goods and services they could spend it on. Any combination of these goods and services is called a bundle: three coffees and two biscotti is one bundle, five coffees and no biscotti is another. The budget rules out the bundles the buyer can't afford. Among the ones they can afford, they choose the bundle with the greatest total value to them. This is the economic value from Week 1, now applied to a whole bundle rather than a single good. Economists call this an optimization problem: finding the best option available, where the budget decides what's available.
Change the price of one good and the set of affordable bundles changes with it, so the buyer may well choose differently. Tracking how much of that good ends up in the best bundle, price by price, gives us the demand curve. Usually, a lower price means more. One reason is easy to see: when a good gets cheaper, each unit costs the buyer less of everything else they might have bought.
1.1
Demand comes from a choice
Maya loves coffee and biscotti. She has $30 a day to spend on the two, and each biscotto costs $4. For her, a bundle is just a pair of numbers: how many coffees and how many biscotti.
Let \(q\) be cups of coffee and \(b\) be the number of biscotti. If coffee costs \(p\) a cup, Maya spends \(pq\) on coffee and \(4b\) on biscotti, so she can afford a bundle when
The inequality is what makes this a constraint. She can spend less than $30, but never more.
Next we need to know what each bundle is worth to her. The table below gives Maya's total value from each quantity of each good. These are cumulative totals, not the value of one more unit. Four coffees are worth $26 to her in total, and two biscotti are worth $12.
| Quantity | 0 | 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Coffee value | 0 | 8 | 15 | 21 | 26 | 30 |
| Biscotti value | 0 | 7 | 12 | 15 | 17 | 18 |
Now put the two together. Every cell in the grid below is one bundle, and the number in it is what that bundle is worth to Maya: her coffee value plus her biscotti value. The bundle of four coffees and two biscotti, for instance, is worth $26 + $12 = $38.
Here's the key thing to notice as you work with the grid. The values in the cells never change. What Maya thinks a bundle is worth doesn't depend on what it costs. The coffee price changes only which cells she can afford: white cells are within her budget, gray cells aren't.
Each reveal plots the number of coffees in Maya's best bundle against the price she faced. At a given price, the quantity of coffee in her best bundle is her . Collect those choices across every possible coffee price, holding her budget, her preferences and the biscotti price fixed, and you have her .
1.2
The best affordable bundle
Maya doesn't decide how much coffee to buy on its own. Every dollar she spends on coffee is a dollar she can't spend on biscotti, so the two decisions are really one decision. What she chooses is a bundle, and she picks the affordable bundle she values most.
Working through one price
Take a coffee price of $5. Maya's best bundle is four coffees and two biscotti. It costs \(4(5)+2(4)=28\), or $28, which is within her $30 budget. It's worth $38 to her: $26 from the coffee and $12 from the biscotti.
How do we know nothing else beats it? Compare the nearby bundles she could also afford:
| Bundle | Cost | Total value |
|---|---|---|
| 4 coffees, 2 biscotti | $28 | $38 |
| 5 coffees, 1 biscotto | $29 | $37 |
| 3 coffees, 3 biscotti | $27 | $36 |
| 5 coffees, 0 biscotti | $25 | $30 |
| 3 coffees, 2 biscotti | $23 | $33 |
Look at the second row. Swapping a biscotto for a fifth coffee adds $4 of coffee value and gives up $5 of biscotti value, so Maya is $1 worse off. The third row runs the trade the other way: she gives up the fourth coffee, worth $5, to gain a third biscotto, worth only $3, and loses $2. Every move away from four coffees and two biscotti costs her more than it gains. That's what makes it best.
Two things worth noticing
She doesn't spend everything. Her best bundle costs $28, leaving $2 unspent. That might look like a mistake, but it isn't. Maya would happily buy more if she could. The problem is that coffee costs $5 and a biscotto costs $4, so $2 buys nothing at all. Coffee and biscotti come in whole units, and her leftover change isn't enough for either. Had coffee been sold by the millilitre, she'd have spent the lot.
She can't have what she'd most like. The highest value anywhere in the grid is $48, at five coffees and five biscotti. Maya would love that bundle. But at $5 a coffee it costs $45, and even at the lowest price on the page, $4, it still costs $40. It's out of reach at every price we consider.
This is the shape of every economic choice: preferences tell us which bundles Maya ranks highest, and her budget tells us which of them she's actually allowed to have. Economists call this constrained optimization. The best bundle is almost never the best bundle imaginable. It's the best one available.
Why value alone isn't enough
In Week 1 we measured a buyer's value for a good by their willingness to pay. That's still the right measure of value, but on its own it doesn't tell us what Maya buys. She's willing to pay something for a fifth coffee, $4 of value, and at a $5 price she doesn't buy it. Not because she doesn't want it, but because those $5 do more for her as a biscotto plus change toward the next one.
So demand depends on three things together: what Maya values, what things cost and how much she has to spend. Change any one of them and her choice can change. The rest of this reading works through what happens when each one does.
1.3
Why individual demand usually slopes down
We now have Maya's choice at one price. Doing the same at every price traces out her demand curve. Here's what it looks like.
| Coffee price | $8 | $7 | $6 | $5 | $4 |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Cups of coffee chosen | 2 | 3 | 3 | 4 | 5 |
As the price falls, the quantity rises. Plotting these five points gives a downward-sloping curve made of steps rather than a smooth line.
Why a lower price leads to more coffee
Start at some price and lower it, with Maya's budget, her preferences and the price of biscotti all unchanged. Two things happen to her affordable set.
First, every bundle she could afford before is still affordable, since nothing got more expensive. Second, bundles that were just out of reach, the ones with more coffee in them, now come within budget. Her options have expanded, and they've expanded in the coffee direction specifically.
At the same time, the exchange rate between the two goods has shifted. At $8 a cup, a coffee costs Maya two biscotti. At $4, it costs one. Coffee has become cheaper not just in dollars but in biscotti, which is the comparison that matters when she's choosing between them.
Why the steps are flat
Maya's quantity stays at three cups when the price moves from $6 to $7. That isn't because she's indifferent. At each of those prices she has exactly one best bundle. At $6 she chooses three coffees and three biscotti ($30, worth $36). At $7 she chooses three coffees and two biscotti ($29, worth $33). Different bundles, both with three coffees in them.
This is what discrete choice looks like. Maya can't buy 3.4 coffees, so a small price change often shows up as her buying fewer biscotti rather than less coffee. The quantity only moves when the price shifts enough to tip a whole unit.
The role of diminishing marginal value
Look at the marginal values in the grid headers. Successive coffees add $8, $7, $6, $5 and $4 of value. Successive biscotti add $7, $5, $3, $2 and $1.
These falling increments are part of why Maya spreads her budget over both goods instead of piling into one. If coffees kept adding $8 each, she'd buy nothing but coffee. Because each extra cup adds less than the last, there comes a point where another coffee is worth less to her than the biscotti she'd give up for it. That's where she stops.
It also explains why a lower price pulls in more coffee. At $8, only the first two cups are worth their price in forgone biscotti. At $4, the fourth and fifth cups clear that bar too.
Two forces behind the change
Economists find it useful to split a price change into two separate effects, because they can pull in different directions.
The . A lower coffee price makes coffee cheaper relative to biscotti, as we saw: two biscotti per cup at $8, one at $4. Even setting aside the fact that Maya is now better off, the swap looks more attractive than it did. This pull toward the cheaper good is the substitution effect, and it always points the same way: when a good gets cheaper relative to the alternatives, it draws purchases toward itself.
The . A lower coffee price also leaves Maya with money to spare. If she kept buying exactly what she bought before, she'd have change left over. Her $30 stretches further than it did, so she's effectively richer even though her income hasn't changed. How she spends that extra purchasing power is the income effect.
Both effects come from the same price change, and separating them is a thought experiment rather than something we can read off the grid. The grid shows only Maya's final choice, the two effects combined.
Why the two effects matter
The direction of the income effect depends on the good.
For most goods, being richer means buying more. Economists call these , and we come back to the term in Section 1.6. For a normal good, a price fall produces two effects that push the same way. Substitution says buy more because it's relatively cheaper; income says buy more because you can afford more. Quantity demanded rises, and the demand curve slopes down.
For some goods, being richer means buying less. These are , and the classic examples are cheap staples people move away from as their circumstances improve. Here the two effects fight each other. Substitution still says buy more of the cheaper good, but income says buy less, because the buyer is now better off and would rather have something else.
Almost always, substitution wins and the curve still slopes down. But not as a matter of logic. If a good takes up a large share of someone's budget and the income effect is strong enough to overwhelm substitution, a price fall could lead them to buy less. Economists call such a good a Giffen good. Clear real-world examples are rare and disputed, which is the point: downward-sloping demand is a very strong empirical regularity, not a theorem.
1.4
Marginal value isn't total value
Every cell in the grid reports a total: what that whole bundle is worth to Maya. The small numbers in the headers report something different. Above each coffee column is what that cup adds as you move one column right, and beside each biscotti row is what that biscotto adds as you move one row up. These are marginal values.
Writing \(V_C(q)\) for Maya's total value from \(q\) coffees, the marginal value of one more cup is
So the fourth coffee is worth \(V_C(4)-V_C(3)=\$26-\$21=\$5\).
| Cups | 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Total value | $8 | $15 | $21 | $26 | $30 |
| Marginal value of that cup | $8 | $7 | $6 | $5 | $4 |
Marginal values fall as Maya drinks more, but her total value doesn't. Five coffees are worth $30 to her, more than the $26 she gets from four. Every extra cup still makes her better off, just by less than the one before. The top row keeps rising while the bottom row falls.
Why marginal value alone doesn't settle the choice
No coffee is bought in isolation. If Maya has already spent her budget, a fifth coffee has to be paid for by dropping a biscotto. The question isn't whether the fifth coffee is worth something. It's whether it's worth more than what she gives up. At $5 a cup, that coffee adds $4, while the biscotto she'd drop is worth $5. Four gained against five given up, so she doesn't do it.
This is why the demand curve records chosen quantities, not the value of the last unit. A lower price changes no number in the grid. It changes which bundles Maya can reach, and she picks again.
State the period
Demand is always demand per period. Five coffees a day and five a week describe completely different buyers. Maya's $30 and her quantities are daily, so her demand curve is a daily one. Before comparing two buyers, or adding them together, check that both refer to the same period.
1.5
A movement along demand versus a shift of demand
When the coffee price changes and everything else stays fixed, Maya faces the same problem with a different affordable set. Her chosen quantity moves to another point on the same demand curve. Economists call this a .
In the grid, a fall from $8 to $5 takes her from two coffees to four. The right way to describe this is “Maya's quantity demanded increases.” Not “Maya's demand increases,” which is reserved for something else.
That something else is a shift of demand, and it happens when one of the things we've been holding fixed changes instead. Maya's demand curve was drawn under three conditions: her budget is $30, her preferences are the values in the table and biscotti cost $4. Change any one of them and we have to redo the whole exercise. Suppose her budget rises to $40. At $8 a cup she might now choose three coffees instead of two, at $5 she might choose five instead of four, and so on at every price. The result is a new curve sitting to the right of the old one. That's a shift of demand: not a new point on the curve, but a new curve.
So the two cases differ in what caused the change. A change in coffee's own price moves Maya along her curve. A change in anything else gives her a different curve. The distinction sounds fussy, but it prevents a real mistake. The demand curve is already a complete answer to “how much does she buy at each price?” So a price change can never explain why the curve moved; the curve hasn't moved. Sections 1.6 and 1.7 take up the two most important sources of shifts: her income and the prices of related goods.
The curve stays put; quantity demanded changes.
The whole curve moves; the quantity chosen at every price may change.
1.6
Income: normal and inferior goods
A pay rise lifts Maya's daily budget from $30 to $40. At every coffee price, she can now afford bundles that were out of reach, and she may choose more coffee at each one. Her whole demand curve shifts to the right, which is the shift we just described. When demand responds this way, coffee is a for Maya.
“Normal” here doesn't mean ordinary, necessary or respectable. It's a label for one specific relationship: more income, more demand. Restaurant meals, new cars and organic groceries are usually normal goods because people buy more of them, or better versions of them, as they earn more.
For an the relationship runs backwards: more income, less demand. This isn't because the buyer stops needing the good. It's because they switch to something they preferred all along but couldn't justify before. A student eats fewer instant noodles once they have a full-time salary. A commuter takes the bus less often after buying a car. In both cases the extra income buys a move to the alternative.
“Inferior” is just as misleading a word as “normal.” It says nothing about quality. A bus service can be clean, punctual and excellent and still be an inferior good for a particular commuter, because what makes it inferior is how that person's demand responds to income, nothing else.
Two further points. The label belongs to a buyer, not to a product: the same bus route can be normal for a student without a car and inferior for a commuter who could buy one. And it belongs to an income range: rice may be normal for someone on a very low income and inferior for the same person once they're earning much more.
To classify a good, then, hold its price, other prices and the buyer's preferences fixed, change only income and see which way demand moves.
When income rises, demand rises. When income falls, demand falls.
When income rises, demand falls. When income falls, demand rises.
Classify the income response
In every scenario, the good's price, other prices and the buyer's preferences stay fixed. Use the stated change in income and quantity demanded, not the name of the product.
Priya's monthly income rises from $3,000 to $4,000. A restaurant lunch still costs $18, and she increases her restaurant lunches from two to five per month. For Priya, restaurant lunches are:
Restaurant lunches are a normal good for Priya over this income range. At the same price, higher income raises her quantity demanded from two lunches to five.
Daniel's weekly income rises from $600 to $1,200. A packet of instant noodles still costs $2, and he reduces his purchases from eight to three packets per week. For Daniel, instant noodles are:
Instant noodles are an inferior good for Daniel over this income range. At the same price, higher income lowers his quantity demanded from eight packets to three.
Mei's annual income rises from $70,000 to $90,000. The price of a weekend hotel stay is unchanged, and she increases her stays from two to four per year. For Mei, weekend hotel stays are:
Weekend hotel stays are a normal good for Mei over this income range. Her income rises and, at the same price, so does her quantity demanded.
Luis's weekly income rises from $900 to $1,400. The bus fare remains $5, and he reduces his bus trips from ten to four per week. For Luis, bus trips are:
Bus trips are an inferior good for Luis over this income range. His income rises while, at the same fare, his quantity demanded falls.
Aisha's monthly income falls from $5,000 to $3,500. A store-brand frozen meal still costs $6, and she increases her purchases from two to seven meals per month. For Aisha, store-brand frozen meals are:
Store-brand frozen meals are an inferior good for Aisha over this income range. Here income falls and quantity demanded rises. That is the reverse of the response for a normal good.
Tom's monthly income falls from $4,500 to $3,000. A cinema ticket still costs $20, and he reduces his cinema visits from four to one per month. For Tom, cinema visits are:
Cinema visits are a normal good for Tom over this income range. His income falls and, at the same ticket price, his quantity demanded also falls.
None of these labels belongs permanently to the product. The evidence tells us how one buyer responds over one income range. Another buyer, or the same buyer at a different income, may respond differently.
1.7
Prices of related goods
In Week 1 we met substitutes and complements as things that influence how much a good is worth to a buyer. Here we use them for a different job: explaining how a price change in one market shifts the demand curve in another.
A note on which price is which. Maya's demand curve for coffee already accounts for the coffee price; that's what moves her along the curve. The prices we're discussing now are other goods' prices, which were held fixed when we drew the curve. When one of them changes, the curve moves.
. Two goods are substitutes when one can take the place of the other. If tea gets more expensive, some tea drinkers switch to coffee, so demand for coffee rises at every coffee price and the curve shifts right. A higher price for one raises demand for the other.
They don't have to be alike. Flying and taking the train between Melbourne and Sydney are very different experiences, but a traveler choosing between them treats them as substitutes. So do two project-management platforms for a business deciding which to subscribe to. The test isn't similarity; it's whether a buyer would swap one for the other when relative prices change.
. Two goods are complements when they're used together, so buying one creates a reason to buy the other. If coffee machines get much more expensive and fewer households buy them, demand for coffee pods falls, even though pods themselves cost the same. A higher price for one lowers demand for the other, shifting that curve left.
. Most pairs of goods have no real connection. A rise in the price of rice isn't going to change Maya's shampoo purchases, and her demand curve for shampoo stays where it is.
None of these labels is printed on a product. They describe how one buyer's choices connect two goods, and the same pair can be related for one person and unrelated for another.
| Relationship | If the price of good Y rises | Demand for good X |
|---|---|---|
| Substitutes | Y becomes less attractive relative to X | Shifts right |
| Complements | Using X together with Y becomes more costly | Shifts left |
| Independent | The choice of X is largely unchanged | No systematic shift |
1.8
Reading a demand change carefully
A manager who sees sales go up needs to know why before deciding what to do next. The movement-versus-shift distinction isn't bookkeeping; it points to two different business situations.
Suppose a café sold 20% more coffee this month. If that happened because it cut its price, the café moved along its demand curve. It bought the extra volume with margin, and the question now is whether the trade was worth it: did the extra cups cover the revenue given up on every cup it was already selling?
If sales rose 20% with no price change, something shifted the curve. Maybe the café across the road raised its prices, or a new office block opened nearby. Here the question is different: is this permanent, and should the café raise its own price now that demand is stronger?
The first change the firm chose. The second happened to it. Confusing them leads to bad conclusions, like crediting a price cut for growth that actually came from a competitor's mistake, and then cutting again when the competitor corrects course.
So demand analysis starts with a disciplined sentence: name the good, the buyer, the period and what changed. Then ask one question. Was it the good's own price, or something else? Once that's settled, the graph follows.
Summary. Individual demand comes from constrained choice. At each price, the buyer picks the highest-value bundle their budget allows, and the amount of the good in that bundle is their quantity demanded. A change in the good's own price moves the buyer along the demand curve. A change in income, preferences, or the prices of related goods shifts the whole curve.
02
The supply of a price-taking firm
How much should one firm produce at each market price?
The last reading followed one buyer. This one follows one seller, and the structure is the same. We ask what the firm would choose at every possible price, and the answer is its supply curve.
The firm we have in mind is a . That means two things. It can sell as much as it wants at the going market price, and it's small enough that whatever it produces leaves that price unchanged. A wheat farmer is the standard picture: the world price of wheat is what it is, and one farm's harvest doesn't move it.
Both halves matter for the decision. Because the firm can't influence the price, setting a price isn't a choice it has. Because it can sell everything it makes at that price, the only question left is how much to make. Its supply curve records the quantity that earns the most profit at each price it might face.
Week 1 gave us everything we need to answer this. Economic cost tells us which resources count. The cost function tells us what each level of output costs. Average cost tells us whether production is worth undertaking at all, and marginal cost tells us whether one more unit is worth making. This reading puts those two to work, one for each half of the decision.
2.1
Supply is a collection of production decisions
Consider Auto Eco, one of many small electric-vehicle manufacturers. Let \(q\) measure its monthly output in hundreds of vehicles. So \(q=1\) means 100 vehicles, and \(q=1.23\) means 123 vehicles. We measure \(p\) in thousands of dollars per vehicle and monthly cost and profit in hundreds of thousands of dollars. A market price of $60,000 is therefore written as \(p=60\).
Suppose Auto Eco's monthly cost of producing \(q\) hundred vehicles is
This is an economic cost function of the kind we built in Week 1. The 80 is a fixed cost of $8 million, incurred only if the firm operates this month. The \(5q^2\) term captures the increasing strain on the plant as monthly production rises.
One point about the decision we're studying. Producing nothing means Auto Eco stays out of the market this month, so it incurs no cost at all, not even the 80. Its profit is then zero. Staying out is always available, and it's the benchmark every positive output has to beat.
Finding the best output at one price
Take a market price of $60,000, so \(p=60\). Write \(\pi(q)\) for Auto Eco's monthly economic profit: revenue minus cost. At \(q=5\), or 500 vehicles, revenue is \(60\times5=300\), measured in hundreds of thousands of dollars, and cost is \(80+5\times10+5\times5^2=255\), so
That's $4.5 million of profit for the month. Is 500 vehicles the best it can do? Check the neighbors. Outputs of 400 and 600 vehicles each give $4 million, and moving farther in either direction gives less. The peak is \(q=5\), so Auto Eco supplies 500 vehicles at a price of $60,000.
Doing it at every price
That's one price. Repeat the exercise at others and a pattern emerges.
| Market price | Profit-maximizing output | Maximum monthly profit | Reason |
|---|---|---|---|
| $30,000 | 0 vehicles | $0 | Every positive output makes a loss. The best positive output is 200 vehicles, which loses $6 million. |
| $60,000 | 500 vehicles | $4.5 million | Five hundred vehicles gives more profit than any other feasible output. |
| $100,000 | 900 vehicles | $32.5 million | Nine hundred vehicles gives more profit than any other feasible output. |
Each row answers the same question at a different price. Auto Eco's is that answer at every possible price: the full relationship between the market price and the quantity the firm chooses to produce.
Notice what the first row tells us. Supply isn't a promise to produce; at $30,000 the right decision is to produce nothing at all. Supply records what the firm is willing and able to sell at each price, which is the seller's counterpart to the demand curve from the last reading.
Supply is always tied to a period
Everything here is measured per month: the hundreds of vehicles Auto Eco builds, the cost of building them, and the profit it earns. That's a choice we make at the start, and we stick to it throughout. Quantities and costs measured over a year would give different numbers and a different supply curve.
So a supply statement needs three things: who is supplying, what they're supplying, and over what period. The tonnes of refined sugar Southern Mills supplies each month at different sugar prices is one such relationship. The kilograms of tomatoes Riverbend Farm supplies each year at different farm-gate prices is another. So are the hours of work one person supplies each day at different hourly wages. Change the supplier, the unit, or the period, and you've changed the question.
2.2
The firm takes price as given
Auto Eco is a : it can sell as many vehicles as it wants at the market price, but it's too small for its own output to move that price. So if the price is \(p\) thousand dollars per vehicle and it sells \(q\) hundred vehicles, its revenue is \(pq\), measured in hundreds of thousands of dollars. No discounting to shift extra units, no premium for scarcity. Every vehicle fetches the same \(p\).
Economic profit is revenue minus economic cost:
Recall the convention from Week 1: whenever we write \(C(q)\), we mean the economic cost function relevant to the decision and period we're studying. Profit built on that cost function is economic profit, so it already accounts for everything the firm gives up, including opportunities that never appear on an invoice.
Auto Eco chooses \(q\) to make \(\pi(q)\) as large as possible. In Section 2.1 we did this by brute force, computing profit at every output and picking the winner. That works, but it won't scale, and it doesn't tell us why the answer comes out where it does. Instead we split the problem into two questions and take them in order.
Question 1: should the firm produce at all? Some prices are simply too low. If every positive output loses money, as happened at $30,000, the firm is better off staying out. Answering this gives us a threshold price: the lowest price at which some positive output earns a profit of zero or better. Below it, the firm produces nothing, and there's no second question to ask.
Question 2: if it produces, how much? Once the price clears the threshold, the firm compares positive outputs and picks the most profitable one.
The order matters. Question 2 finds the best positive output, but the best positive output can still be a loss-making one. Only Question 1 can rule that out. The next two sections take each question in turn, and Section 2.5 puts them together on Auto Eco's numbers.
2.3
Step 1: Should the firm produce at all?
Before working out how much to produce, the firm asks a simpler question: is there any positive output at all that doesn't lose money? There's a neat way to see the answer. Take the profit formula and factor out \(q\):
The middle step just divides and multiplies cost by \(q\), which changes nothing, but it turns \(C(q)\) into average cost. Now profit reads as output times a margin. The bracket is profit per vehicle in thousands of dollars. Since \(q\) counts hundreds of vehicles, the product is total profit in hundreds of thousands of dollars. Price is what each vehicle brings in; average cost is what each vehicle costs on average. The gap between them is the margin.
So at any output, profit is nonnegative exactly when \(p\geq AC(q)\). If price covers average cost, the firm makes money on each unit and therefore in total. If it doesn't, the margin is negative and every unit adds to the loss.
The firm doesn't need this to hold at every output, only at one. If there's a single quantity where price covers average cost, producing that quantity beats staying out. So the question becomes: how low can average cost go?
That lowest point is the . If price is at least as high as the cheapest average cost the firm can achieve, production is viable:
Three cases follow. Below the threshold, price is under average cost at every positive output, so every production plan loses money and the firm produces nothing. Exactly at the threshold, the firm can just break even by producing the output that minimizes average cost; its economic profit is zero. Above it, at least one positive output turns a profit, and Step 2 finds the best one.
It's worth pausing on what zero economic profit means. It isn't failure. Economic cost already includes everything the owners gave up to run the firm, so zero economic profit means the business is doing exactly as well as its next-best alternative. A firm earning zero economic profit is earning a perfectly normal return.
Let's determine the shutdown threshold
Start by setting the market price to \(p=80\), or $80,000 per vehicle. Drag the hand on the horizontal price line up or down until the control reads 80. Then change the number of EVs produced by dragging the hand on the vertical quantity line left or right.
As you change \(q\), watch the green rectangle. Its area represents Auto Eco's monthly economic profit at the selected price and output. At \(p=80\), find the range of quantities for which the rectangle is green. The two boundary points occur where the price line crosses the average-cost curve. Enter them below the graph.
The shutdown threshold is the lowest price at which some positive output can avoid a loss. To find it, gradually lower the price. After each change, move \(q\) and see whether any quantity produces a green profit rectangle. Stop when the green rectangle disappears for every quantity and the price line just touches the average-cost curve. Below that price, every positive output loses money, so Auto Eco is better off producing nothing.
Now reveal the marginal-cost curve. What do you notice where average cost reaches its minimum?
2.4
Step 2: How much should the firm produce?
We know Auto Eco produces only if the price is at least $50,000. So fix a price above that, say $80,000, and set \(p=80\) on the graph. The price line sits well above the lowest point of the average-cost curve, so production is clearly worth it. The question is how many vehicles.
Rather than test every quantity, pick one and ask whether the firm could do better by moving.
Start high: 1,000 vehicles
Drag output to \(q=10\), or 1,000 vehicles. The marginal-cost curve is at 110, far above the price line at 80.
Read that literally. At this output, marginal cost is about $110,000 per vehicle, while each vehicle sells for $80,000. Moving from \(q=10\) to \(q=9\) means producing 100 fewer vehicles. The firm gives up $8 million in revenue but saves $10.5 million in cost, so profit rises by $2.5 million.
The same logic applies at \(q=9\) and \(q=8\), where marginal cost is still above 80. Wherever the marginal-cost curve sits above the price line, the firm is producing vehicles that cost more than they earn. Cutting back raises profit.
Start too low: 500 vehicles
Now drag output to \(q=5\), or 500 vehicles. Marginal cost is 60, below the price line.
Here the logic runs the other way. Expanding from 500 to 600 vehicles adds $6.5 million to cost and $8 million to revenue, so profit rises by $1.5 million. The firm is leaving money on the table. Wherever the price line sits above the marginal-cost curve, there are profitable vehicles still unbuilt. Expanding raises profit.
Where it stops
Above \(q=7\), cutting back helps. Below \(q=7\), expanding helps. The two forces meet where the price line crosses the marginal-cost curve:
For Auto Eco at \(p=80\), that's \(80=10+10q\), so \(q^*=7\), or 700 vehicles. The arithmetic confirms it:
| Output \(q\) (hundreds of vehicles) | 5 | 6 | 7 | 8 | 10 |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Monthly profit ($ million) | 14.5 | 16 | 16.5 | 16 | 12 |
What the equality does and doesn't say
It's a stopping rule, nothing more. It tells the firm where to stop expanding, not what it earns. Profit comes from average cost. At \(q=7\), \(AC(7)\) is about $56,400 per vehicle, so the margin is about $23,600 per vehicle. Across 700 vehicles, that gives the $16.5 million in the table. Price equals marginal cost at the chosen output, but the firm earns a positive margin on the vehicles it produces.
The comparison is more general than the crossing
The graph shows a textbook case: the price line crosses the rising marginal-cost curve inside the firm's feasible range, \(0\leq q\leq \bar q\), where \(\bar q\) is the firm’s capacity constraint. Below the crossing, \(p>MC(q)\), so another unit adds more to revenue than to cost and expanding raises profit. At the crossing, \(p=MC(q)\). Above it, \(p\lt MC(q)\), so contracting raises profit. The change from \(p>MC\) to \(p\lt MC\) is what makes the crossing a profit maximum.
But price need not intersect marginal cost before the firm reaches capacity. If \(p>MC(q)\) at every feasible output, profit keeps rising all the way to \(\bar q\), so the firm produces at capacity. The best output is then a boundary even though price never equals marginal cost. If \(p\lt MC(q)\) at every positive feasible output, every expansion lowers profit, so no positive output is optimal and the firm produces nothing.
This gives a rule that works in all three cases. When \(p>MC(q)\), expand if possible. When \(p\lt MC(q)\), contract. When \(p=MC(q)\), stop only if marginal cost crosses price from below to above. Apply the comparison over the full feasible range, including the endpoints \(0\) and \(\bar q\).
Step 1 still comes first. Even the best positive output must cover average cost; otherwise the firm chooses zero. And if marginal cost is falling at a crossing, equality doesn't identify a peak. It marks the worst output in its neighborhood, so the firm must compare the feasible boundary outputs.
2.5
Worked example: Auto Eco
We can now derive the choices from Section 2.1 properly, instead of by checking outputs one at a time. Auto Eco's monthly total cost, in hundreds of thousands of dollars, is
where \(q\) is measured in hundreds of vehicles. Dividing by \(q\) gives average cost, and marginal cost follows from the rule for quadratic cost functions in Week 1. Both are in thousands of dollars per vehicle:
Step 1: the threshold price
Step 1 said the firm produces only if price covers average cost at some output, so we need the lowest point of the average-cost curve. Week 1 gave us a shortcut for finding it: average cost is at its minimum where it equals marginal cost. Setting the two expressions equal:
At \(q=4\), or 400 vehicles, average cost is \(80/4+10+20=50\), that is, $50,000 per vehicle. No output is cheaper to produce per vehicle than this. So $50,000 is Auto Eco’s threshold price: below it, nothing it can do covers its costs.
Step 2: the quantity, at any price above the threshold
Step 2 said to set price equal to marginal cost. Doing it once with \(p\) left as a letter solves the problem for every price at once:
Checking two prices
At \(p=70\), Auto Eco produces \((70-10)/10=6\), or 600 vehicles. Average cost there is \(80/6+10+30=\frac{160}{3}\), about $53,333 per vehicle, so the margin is roughly $16,667 on each one:
In hundreds of thousands of dollars, that’s $10 million for the month. Note that price equals marginal cost on the last vehicle built, and the firm still clears $10 million, because every earlier vehicle cost less than the last.
At \(p=40\), the same formula gives \(q=3\), or 300 vehicles. But $40,000 is below the $50,000 threshold, and sure enough, average cost at \(q=3\) is about $51,667 per vehicle, above the price. Producing those 300 vehicles would lose about $3.5 million. Auto Eco supplies nothing.
This is why Step 1 comes first. The equation \(p=MC(q)\) finds the best positive output, and the best positive output can still be a loss. Only Step 1 catches that.
2.6
The firm's supply curve
Putting the two steps together gives Auto Eco’s supply, with \(p\) in thousands of dollars per vehicle and \(q\) in hundreds of vehicles:
Look at what the third line is. It’s \(p=MC(q)\) rearranged. So above the threshold, the supply curve and the marginal-cost curve are the same curve, read in opposite directions: marginal cost answers “what does the next vehicle cost at this output?”, and supply answers “at this price, how many vehicles?” That’s why supply slopes upward here. A higher price brings more vehicles within reach of being worth building, because each can be sold for more.
At exactly \(p=50\), Auto Eco’s optimal-output set is \(\{0,4\}\): either no vehicles or 400 vehicles. Both give zero economic profit, so there’s no fact of the matter about which it does. What happens just above and just below the threshold is what matters.
2.7
A movement along supply versus a shift of supply
When the market price changes and everything else stays fixed, Auto Eco faces the same problem with a different price line. Its chosen quantity moves to another point on the same supply curve. Economists call this a .
On the graph, a rise from $70,000 to $80,000 takes the firm from 600 vehicles to 700. The right way to describe this is “Auto Eco’s quantity supplied increases.” Not “Auto Eco’s supply increases,” which is reserved for something else.
That something else is a shift of supply, and it happens when one of the things we’ve been holding fixed changes instead. Auto Eco’s supply curve was drawn under one condition: its cost function is \(C(q)=80+10q+5q^2\). Change that and we have to redo the whole exercise. Suppose battery prices fall, so every vehicle costs less to build. Marginal cost is lower at every output, so at $70,000 the firm might now choose 700 vehicles instead of 600, at $80,000 it might choose 800 instead of 700, and so on at every price. The result is a new curve sitting to the right of the old one. That’s a shift of supply: not a new point on the curve, but a new curve.
So the two cases differ in what caused the change. A change in the market price moves Auto Eco along its curve. A change in its costs gives it a different curve. The distinction prevents the same mistake we met with demand. The supply curve is already a complete answer to “how much does the firm produce at each price?” So a price change can never explain why the curve moved; the curve hasn’t moved. Anything that rewrites the cost function can: technology, input prices, taxes and regulation are the usual sources, and they matter most in the next reading, when we add firms together into market supply.
The curve stays put; quantity supplied changes.
The whole curve moves; the quantity chosen at every price may change.
2.8
Capacity and discrete output
The rule \(p=MC(q)\) is easiest to apply when output can vary by any amount and the firm has room to expand. Real production is often less accommodating. A plant has a hard limit, and output may only move in blocks. Neither changes the logic, but both change how the supply curve looks.
A capacity limit
Suppose Auto Eco can build at most 800 vehicles a month, so \(q\leq 8\). Up to that point nothing changes: the firm follows \(p=MC(q)\) as before. From \(q=(p-10)/10\), it reaches capacity at a price of $90,000.
Above $90,000, the rule would call for more than 800 vehicles, and the firm simply can’t build them. Its quantity supplied stays at 800 however high the price goes. On the graph, the supply curve rises along marginal cost up to $90,000 and then turns vertical at \(q=8\).
The firm isn’t indifferent to the higher price. At $100,000 it earns far more on its 800 vehicles than at $90,000. What it can’t do is respond by producing more, at least until it can expand the plant, which is a decision over a longer period than this month.
Output in blocks
Now suppose Auto Eco can only adjust production in blocks of 100 vehicles, and take a market price of $60,000. Each block brings in $6 million of revenue, so the question for each block is whether it costs less than that to build.
| Block | Added cost | Added revenue | Effect on profit |
|---|---|---|---|
| 400 → 500 vehicles | $5.5 million | $6 million | +$500,000 |
| 500 → 600 vehicles | $6.5 million | $6 million | −$500,000 |
The firm takes the first block and declines the second, settling at \(q=5\). Notice that price doesn’t equal marginal cost at either end: $6 million sits between the two block costs, never on one. With discrete output, the equality often has nowhere to happen.
The underlying rule survives, though, in the form it had all along: build every block whose added revenue covers its added cost, and stop at the first one that doesn’t. The equality \(p=MC(q)\) was only ever a convenient way of saying that when output is divisible.
When capacity sets the threshold
Capacity can also change Step 1. Consider a firm whose economic cost function has a constant marginal cost and a positive fixed cost, as in the pharmaceutical exercise. Average cost then falls at every output, because the fixed cost spreads over more and more units and nothing pushes back. There’s no interior minimum to find.
So the cheapest output per unit is the largest one the firm can produce, and capacity is what defines it. The threshold price is average cost at full capacity. Below it, the firm produces nothing; at or above it, it goes straight to capacity, since every unit up to the limit adds to profit.
The supply curve is then a step rather than a smooth rise: flat at zero below the threshold, then vertical at capacity. This is a useful case to keep in mind. Industries with heavy up-front costs and cheap production, like software and pharmaceuticals, tend to look like this, and they behave very differently from Auto Eco.
2.9
What profit tells the manager
The supply decision keeps apart three numbers that are easy to blur in practice. Price is what each unit brings in. Marginal cost answers one question only: is the next unit worth making? Average cost answers a different one: are we making money on what we produce?
Keeping them separate matters because they can disagree. A firm can sit exactly at \(p=MC\) and still be losing money, if price is below average cost at that output. We saw it with Auto Eco at $40,000: the marginal rule pointed to 300 vehicles, and 300 vehicles would have lost $3.5 million. Marginal cost found the best positive output, which happened to be the least bad loss. It took average cost to reveal that the whole plan was worse than doing nothing.
This is the practical content of the two steps. Marginal cost is the right tool for “how much,” and the wrong tool for “whether.” A manager who reaches for it first can optimize their way into a loss.
One more thing to watch. Both steps rest on the cost function, and which costs belong in it depends on the decision being made. A plant manager setting this month’s output and an investor deciding whether to build the plant at all are asking different questions, so they work from different cost functions and can reach different conclusions about the same factory. Supply depends on the technology and on the decision the firm is actually facing.
Summary. A price-taking firm treats the market price as given. It operates when price is at least as high as minimum average cost and, once operating, chooses output where price equals marginal cost on the rising part of the marginal-cost curve. Average cost determines profit; marginal cost determines the quantity supplied.
03
From individual demand to market demand
How do many buyers become one market demand curve?
A market doesn’t choose anything. People do. Market demand is just a summary of what all the buyers choose together.
Here’s how to build it. Pick a price. Ask how much each buyer would buy at that price, and add up their quantities. Then do the same at every other price. The result tells you how much the whole market wants to buy at each price.
Economists call this horizontal addition. On a demand graph, price goes on the vertical axis and quantity goes on the horizontal axis. Since we add quantities, we’re adding along the horizontal direction.
3.1
Adding buyers at a given price
Suppose Ann and Bob are the only buyers of a service. At a price of $40, Ann buys 20 units and Bob buys 30, so the market buys 50 units in total. At $60, Ann buys 10 and Bob buys 20, so the market buys 30. The table shows their choices at four prices.
| Price | Ann | Bob | Market |
|---|---|---|---|
| $20 | 30 | 40 | 70 |
| $40 | 20 | 30 | 50 |
| $60 | 10 | 20 | 30 |
| $80 | 0 | 10 | 10 |
Read the table one row at a time. Each row fixes a price and adds Ann’s quantity to Bob’s to get the market quantity. That’s one horizontal sum. Notice what we don’t add: prices. Ann and Bob pay the same market price, so the price stays as it is and only the quantities get added.
In symbols, market demand is
Here’s how to read it. The superscript \(d\) stands for demand. Writing \(p\) after a quantity means it depends on the price \(p\): change the price and the quantity can change. Capital \(Q\) is the quantity for the whole market. Lowercase \(q\) is the quantity for one buyer, and the subscript tells you which buyer. So the equation says that at any price \(p\), the market’s quantity demanded equals Ann’s quantity plus Bob’s quantity at that same price.
Most markets have far more than two buyers. If there are \(N\) buyers, numbered 1 to \(N\), we write
The expression says: go through every buyer \(i\), from buyer 1 to buyer \(N\), find how much that buyer wants at price \(p\), and add those quantities together. The notation is new, but the idea is the same as with Ann and Bob.
3.2
Why the market curve can have kinks
Not every buyer buys at every price. Look at the table again. At $80, Ann buys nothing, while Bob still buys 10 units. Once the price falls below $80, Ann starts buying too.
That changes how the market responds to price. Below $80, every $20 price cut adds 20 units to the market: 10 from Ann and 10 from Bob. Just above $80, Ann isn’t buying, so a price cut changes only Bob’s purchases. Once Ann joins, the market responds more strongly to price.
On a graph, this shows up as a change in slope. Price is on the vertical axis, so a curve where quantity responds more to price looks flatter. Market demand therefore becomes flatter below $80. The point where the slope changes is called a kink.
Kinks aren’t mistakes. They record a change in who is buying, or in how strongly buyers respond to price. In a market with thousands of buyers whose reservation values differ only slightly, each buyer who joins adds a tiny kink, and together they’re too small to see. The curve looks smooth. In a market with a few large customer groups, the kinks can be big enough to matter.
For a manager, what’s behind market demand can matter as much as the total. Suppose a price cut increases sales. That could happen because existing customers buy more, because new customers start buying, or both. The total increase might be identical in each case, but the business consequences differ. New customers have to be reached, served, and kept. Existing customers who simply buy more don’t need any of that.
3.3
A linear example
The same idea works when demand is written as an equation. Suppose Ann’s demand is
Bob’s demand is
Notice that each equation comes with a range of prices. Above $80, Ann buys nothing. Above $120, Bob buys nothing.
To find market demand, first ask who is buying at each price.
Between $80 and $120, only Bob buys, so market demand is just Bob’s demand:
Below $80, both buy, so we add their quantities:
Check the two pieces at $80. The first gives \(60-40=20\) and the second gives \(140-120=20\), so they meet. But their slopes differ. Above $80, a $1 price cut adds half a unit, all of it from Bob. Below $80, a $1 price cut adds one and a half units: one from Ann and a half from Bob. That change in slope at $80 is the kink created when Ann starts buying.
Here’s the trap to avoid. It’s tempting to add the two equations once and use the result at every price. That only works at prices where both buyers are actually buying. Try it at $100. Ann’s equation gives \(80-100=-20\), as if she bought minus 20 units. That has no meaning, because nobody buys a negative amount. The correct answer at $100 is that Ann buys zero and the market buys Bob’s 10 units. Quantity demanded can never fall below zero, so always check who is buying before you add.
3.4
Why a representative buyer can mislead
Sometimes it’s convenient to divide market demand by the number of buyers and talk about an average buyer, also called a representative buyer. If all the buyers are identical, this shortcut does no harm. If they differ, it can hide what’s really going on.
Go back to the table. At $80, the market buys 10 units, so the average buyer buys 5. But nobody buys 5. Ann buys nothing and Bob buys 10. The average buyer doesn’t describe either of them.
The same problem shows up when the price changes. As the price falls below $80, part of the market’s response comes from Ann starting to buy. The average buyer can’t start buying, because it was already buying 5 units at $80. So the average makes it look as if everyone was already in the market and each person just buys a little more as the price falls. The market total is right, but the story about who buys is wrong.
This matters more when groups of buyers differ in consistent ways. A change in public transport fares may affect commuters, students and retirees differently. A rise in a software price may drive away small-business customers while large companies keep buying exactly as before. Market demand tells you the total response. Decisions about product design or customer service often need to know who is behind it.
None of this makes market demand wrong. If the question is how much the whole market buys at a given price, market demand is exactly the right tool. The warning is about how you read it. Adding buyers together hides who they are, but their differences are still there and still shape the curve. You just can’t see them in it.
3.5
Movement along market demand
A movement along the demand curve shows how quantity demanded responds to a change in the good’s own price, with everything else held fixed: buyers’ incomes, their preferences, the prices of related goods and the number of buyers.
Each buyer responds by moving along their own demand curve, and adding up their new quantities gives a new point on market demand. Go back to Ann and Bob. If the price falls from $80 to $60, Bob goes from 10 units to 20, Ann goes from 0 to 10, and market quantity rises from 10 to 30. On a graph, the market moves down and to the right along its demand curve. If the price rose back to $80, it would move up and to the left, back to 10.
That movement combines two kinds of response. Bob was already buying and buys more. Ann wasn’t buying and starts. Ann’s decision to start buying below $80 was always part of the market curve, so it’s still a movement along demand. The market curve doesn’t show how much of a change came from each kind of response. To split it up, you need data on individual customers, such as sales records showing who bought and how much. That’s one reason a firm may want to look behind its market demand estimate before it sets a pricing policy.
Careful wording helps keep these ideas apart. When the price changes and the market moves along the curve, we say quantity demanded rises or falls. We say demand increases or decreases only when the whole curve shifts. When the price fell from $80 to $60, quantity demanded rose from 10 to 30. Demand itself didn’t change.
3.6
What shifts market demand
A shift in the demand curve means buyers want a different quantity at every price. A shift to the right is an increase in demand: more at every price. A shift to the left is a decrease in demand: less at every price. Shifts come from something other than the good’s own price. In Week 1, you saw how income, preferences and the prices of related goods shift one person’s demand. Market demand shifts by the sum of those individual shifts. But buyers don’t always react the same way. A good might be normal for some households and inferior for others, so the same change can push their demands in opposite directions. The overall direction then depends on who the buyers are.
Start with income. Recall from Week 1 that people buy more of a normal good when their income rises, and less of an inferior good. Suppose the government raises income tax, so households have less income left after tax. For many households, new cars are a normal good, so demand for new cars shifts left. Say that before the tax, buyers wanted 700 new cars a year at $20,000. After it, they want only 300 at that same price. For some of those households, used cars may be an inferior good: with less income, they switch from new cars to used ones. Demand for used cars then shifts right. One change in income moves two related markets in opposite directions. This is why analysts and policymakers watch incomes closely. A recession shifts demand in many markets at once, and the direction in each market depends on whether the good is normal or inferior for the people buying it.
Next, the prices of related goods. Suppose the price of Pepsi rises while the price of Coke stays the same. Buyers who see the two drinks as substitutes switch some of their purchases to Coke, so market demand for Coke shifts right. Coke’s price hasn’t changed. What has changed is that, at any price Coke might charge, the market now wants more Coke than before. Complements work the other way. Cars and fuel are used together, so when fuel gets more expensive, running a car costs more. At any car price, buyers want fewer cars, and demand for cars shifts left. Cheaper fuel shifts it right. Because so many products are used with fuel, a change in the price of oil can shift demand in many markets at once.
Preferences matter too. If buyers’ tastes move toward a good, they want more of it at every price, and demand shifts right. Notice that the Pepsi example is not a change in preferences. Buyers like Coke and Pepsi exactly as much as before. What changed was the price of a substitute.
Expectations can also shift demand. Buyers who expect a good’s price to rise later have a reason to buy now, before it does, so current demand may shift right.
Finally, market demand can shift for a reason that has nothing to do with any one buyer’s choices: the number of buyers. If more people enter the market, there are more individual demands to add up, so market demand shifts right even if nobody’s own demand changes. If buyers leave, it shifts left.
| Change | Why | Effect on demand |
|---|---|---|
| Income rises | Buyers can afford more | Right for a normal good; left for an inferior good |
| Price of a substitute rises | Buyers switch toward this good | Right |
| Price of a complement rises | Using this good gets more expensive | Left |
| Preferences move toward the good | Buyers value it more | Right |
| Buyers expect a higher future price | Buying now beats buying later | Current demand may shift right |
| Number of buyers rises | More demands to add up | Right |
Treat the table as a summary, not a list to memorize. For any change, ask how it affects what buyers are willing to pay for the good, what they can afford, or how many buyers there are. If you can answer that, you can work out the direction of the shift.
3.7
Demand as a managerial object
Market demand is useful because it connects customer behavior to market outcomes without pretending that the market itself has preferences. Every point is still the sum of choices made by people or organizations.
It also disciplines causal claims. If quantity sold changed because the firm's own price changed, the firm moved along demand. If quantity changed at the same price because incomes, tastes, related prices or the customer base changed, demand shifted. If price and quantity both changed, we need more information before deciding which occurred.
In the next reading we apply the same aggregation to firms. Market supply is built by holding price fixed and adding the quantity each firm chooses. The arithmetic is the same. The source of the individual curves is different: demand comes from value and budgets; supply comes from cost and profit.
Summary. Market demand is the horizontal sum of individual demands. At each price, add the quantities chosen by all buyers. A change in the good's own price moves the market along its demand curve; changes in income, related prices, preferences, expectations or the buyer population can shift the curve.
04
From firm supply to market supply
How do the production decisions of many firms add up?
Market supply is built exactly the way market demand is. Pick a price. Ask how much each firm would supply at that price, and add up their quantities. Then do the same at every other price.
If all the firms have the same costs, this is easy: work out how much one firm supplies and multiply by the number of firms. If firms use different technologies, their costs differ, and so do the prices at which they’re willing to produce. Firms with low costs start producing at low prices. Firms with higher costs join only as the price rises. The order in which firms start producing and expand their output shapes the market supply curve.
4.1
Adding firms horizontally
Here’s the idea with numbers. Suppose that at a price of $15, one firm supplies five units, another supplies eight and a third supplies nothing. Market supply at $15 is \(5+8+0=13\) units.
In symbols, the notation works just as it did for demand. Let \(q_j^s(p)\) be the quantity firm \(j\) supplies at price \(p\). The superscript \(s\) stands for supply, and the subscript \(j\) tells you which firm. With \(N\) firms, is
As with demand, this is a horizontal sum. Quantity is on the horizontal axis, and quantities are what we add.
There are two things we don’t do. We don’t average the firms. An average firm doesn’t tell you how much is available to buy in the market, which is what market supply is for. And we don’t add prices. In a competitive market, every firm selling the same good gets the same market price.
Like market demand, market supply can have kinks. It can also have jumps. A kink is a point where the slope of the curve changes. A jump is a price at which total quantity leaps from one amount to another, skipping the amounts in between. Both come from events like these: a firm starts producing once the price reaches its shutdown threshold, a factory reaches capacity and can’t produce any more, or a more expensive technology becomes worth using. Each event changes how much total quantity responds to price. You’ll see a jump in the Auto Eco example below.
4.2
Identical firms: Auto Eco
Return to Auto Eco. Quantity \(q\) is measured in hundreds of vehicles per month, and prices and costs are in thousands of dollars, so \(q=6\) means 600 vehicles and a price of 70 means $70,000. Each firm has the cost function
As we found earlier, each firm’s shutdown threshold is $50,000. Above that price, its supply is
Now suppose the market has ten identical firms. Because they’re identical, every firm supplies the same amount at any price above $50,000. Market supply is therefore ten times one firm’s supply:
Here \(Q^s\), like \(q^s\), is measured in hundreds of vehicles. At \(p=70\), or $70,000, each firm supplies \(q^s(70)=(70-10)/10=6\), or 600 vehicles. The market therefore supplies 60 hundreds of vehicles, or 6,000 per month. At \(p=100\), each firm supplies 900 vehicles and the market supplies 9,000.
Below $50,000, no firm produces, so market supply is zero.
Exactly $50,000 is a special case. At that price, a firm that produces \(q=4\), or 400 vehicles, just breaks even. Its revenue is \(4\times 50=200\), and its cost is \(80+40+80=200\). Both amounts are in hundreds of thousands of dollars, so each equals $20 million. A firm that produces nothing also earns zero. Each firm is therefore indifferent between producing zero and producing 400 vehicles.
Depending on how many of the ten firms produce, the market supplies 0, 400, 800 and so on, up to 4,000 vehicles. In the units of the equation, these quantities are \(0,4,8,\ldots,40\). Putting the three cases together:
Now look at what happens around $50,000. Just below it, the market supplies nothing. Just above it, the market supplies just over 40 hundreds of vehicles, or just over 4,000 vehicles. Total quantity leaps from zero to 4,000 without passing through the quantities in between as the price changes. This is the jump described in Section 4.1, and it isn't a calculation error.
The jump comes from the fixed cost of $8 million in each firm’s economic cost function. A firm that produces nothing doesn't pay it, but a firm that produces anything does. To cover the fixed cost, the firm has to spread it over enough vehicles. At $50,000, the best it can do is break even by producing \(q=4\), or 400 vehicles. Producing \(q=1\) or \(q=2\), meaning 100 or 200 vehicles, would make a loss at that price. So a firm never produces a small positive amount around the threshold. It either stays out or produces at least 400 vehicles.
4.3
What the number of firms changes
Use the slider to change the number of identical Auto Eco firms. The blue curve is one firm’s supply, and it never moves. The green curve is market supply, and it stretches to the right as you add firms.
If the number of firms rises from ten to twenty, market supply doubles at every price above the shutdown threshold. At $70,000, for example, ten firms supply \(Q^s=60\), or 6,000 vehicles, and twenty firms supply \(Q^s=120\), or 12,000. Each firm’s own supply hasn't changed. Each still produces \(q^s=6\), or 600 vehicles, at that price. The market curve shifts right only because there are more individual curves to add up.
So market output can grow in two different ways. If the market price rises, each firm moves along its own supply curve and produces more. The market moves along its supply curve too. If the number of firms rises, each firm’s supply stays the same, but there are more firms, so the whole market supply curve shifts right.
Scale also affects how a single firm relates to the market. If Auto Eco supplies 600 of 6,000 vehicles, it accounts for ten percent of output. With one thousand similar firms it would account for one tenth of one percent. The smaller its share, the more plausible it is that changing its own quantity leaves the market price essentially unchanged.
4.4
Firms with different technologies
Imagine the market for a generic medication, sold by the pack. Because it’s generic, every firm’s pack is the same product, and every firm sells at the same market price.
Two kinds of firms make it. There are 100 small producers like Apex. Each can make at most 100 packs a month, at a marginal cost of $10 a pack, and each has a fixed cost of $1,000 a month. There are also 300 large producers like Boulder. Each can make up to 200 packs a month, also at $10 a pack, but its fixed cost is $6,000 a month. A firm that produces nothing in a month avoids its fixed cost.
The government is worried about a possible disease outbreak. An outbreak would raise demand for the medication and push its price up. Before that happens, the health department wants to know how much the industry would supply at different prices. That will help it predict where prices could go and decide whether it might need a subsidy. Market supply answers exactly that question.
Step 1: Apex’s lowest average cost. Apex’s cost function is \(C_A(q)=1{,}000+10q\), so its average cost is
As output rises, the $1,000 fixed cost is spread over more packs, so average cost falls. It keeps falling all the way to capacity. Apex’s lowest average cost is therefore at 100 packs:
That makes $20 Apex’s shutdown threshold.
Step 2: Apex’s supply. Below $20, Apex can’t cover its costs, so it produces nothing. Above $20, the price is also above its marginal cost of $10. Every extra pack adds to profit, and Apex produces at capacity. At exactly $20, Apex breaks even whether it makes 0 packs or 100, so it’s indifferent between the two.
Step 3: Boulder’s lowest average cost. Boulder’s cost function is \(C_B(q)=6{,}000+10q\), so its average cost is
The same reasoning applies. Average cost falls all the way to capacity, so Boulder’s lowest average cost is at 200 packs:
Boulder’s shutdown threshold is $40.
Step 4: Boulder’s supply. Below $40, Boulder produces nothing. Above $40, the price is above its marginal cost of $10, so Boulder produces at capacity. At exactly $40, it’s indifferent between 0 and 200 packs.
Step 5: Supply from each group. All 100 small producers are identical to Apex, so we multiply Apex’s supply by 100. At exactly $20, the total depends on how many small producers choose to operate. As with Auto Eco, it can be any multiple of 100 up to 10,000.
The 300 large producers are identical to Boulder, so we multiply Boulder’s supply by 300.
Step 6: Market supply. Market supply is the two groups added together, \(Q^s(p)=Q_A^s(p)+Q_B^s(p)\):
Here’s what this tells the health department. Below $20, nobody makes the medication. Between $20 and $40, the industry supplies 10,000 packs a month, all from the small producers. A higher price within that range doesn’t bring out a single extra pack. Only at $40 do the large producers start up, and supply can jump to 70,000 packs. So the industry won’t supply more than 10,000 packs a month unless the price reaches $40. The department needs to know this before an outbreak, not after.
4.5
Movement along market supply
A movement along the supply curve shows how quantity supplied responds to a change in the good’s own price, with everything else held fixed: firms’ costs, their technology and the number of firms.
Take Auto Eco. Suppose the price of a vehicle rises from $70,000 to $100,000 while nothing else changes. Each firm moves along its own supply curve and raises output from 600 to 900 vehicles a month. With ten firms, market quantity rises from 6,000 to 9,000 vehicles. On a graph, the market moves up and to the right along its supply curve. If the price fell back to $70,000, it would move down and to the left, back to 6,000.
A movement along the curve can involve more than firms adjusting their output. It also includes firms starting or stopping production as the price crosses their shutdown thresholds. In the medication market, when the price rises above $40, the large producers start up and quantity supplied jumps from 10,000 to 70,000 packs. Nothing about the firms has changed. Their thresholds were always part of the curve, so this is still a movement along supply.
Careful wording helps keep these ideas apart. When the price changes and the market moves along the curve, we say quantity supplied rises or falls. We say supply increases or decreases only when the whole curve shifts. In the Auto Eco example, quantity supplied rose from 6,000 to 9,000 vehicles. Supply itself didn’t change.
4.6
What shifts market supply
A shift in the supply curve means firms want to supply a different quantity at every price. A shift to the right is an increase in supply: more at every price. A shift to the left is a decrease in supply: less at every price. Shifts come from something other than the good’s own price. For market supply, that something is almost always a change in firms’ costs or a change in the number of firms.
Start with production costs and input prices. Firms buy inputs such as labor, raw materials, energy and equipment. When an input gets more expensive, every unit that uses it costs more to make. At any given price, some units that were worth producing no longer are, so supply shifts left. Cheaper inputs shift supply right. Input prices themselves move for many reasons, including world commodity prices, disruptions to supply chains and changes in exchange rates, which change what imported inputs cost in Australian dollars.
Technology works through the same channel. A better production method lets firms make the same output with fewer resources. That lowers the cost of each unit, so supply shifts right.
Government policies change costs too. A tax on each unit sold raises the cost of every unit, so supply shifts left. A subsidy for each unit does the opposite and shifts supply right. A tariff on imported inputs makes those inputs more expensive, which works like any other rise in input prices. Regulations that add compliance costs shift supply left.
Natural events such as droughts, floods and earthquakes can damage crops, factories and transport links. Inputs become scarcer and production becomes more expensive, so supply shifts left.
Finally, the number of firms. As we saw with Auto Eco, more firms means more individual supply curves to add up, so market supply shifts right. Fewer firms shift it left.
Fixed costs deserve a separate note. Some changes raise a firm’s fixed cost without touching its marginal cost, such as a new monthly fee that every operating firm must pay. A firm that keeps producing makes the same quantity at any given price because its marginal cost hasn’t moved. But a higher fixed cost raises its average cost, and with it its shutdown threshold. In the medication market, if the large producers’ fixed cost rose, they’d need a price above $40 before starting up. Market supply shifts because the set of firms willing to produce at a given price has changed.
| Change | Why | Effect on supply |
|---|---|---|
| Input prices rise | Each unit costs more to make | Shifts left |
| Technology improves | Each unit costs less to make | Shifts right |
| Per-unit tax introduced | Each unit costs more | Shifts left |
| Per-unit subsidy introduced | Each unit costs less | Shifts right |
| Drought or other natural disaster | Inputs are scarcer and dearer | Shifts left |
| Number of firms rises | More curves to add up | Shifts right |
Treat the table as a summary, not a list to memorize. For any change, ask two questions. Does it change what it costs a firm to produce one more unit? Does it change which firms find it worth producing at all? If you can answer those, you can work out the direction of the shift.
A solar-panel subsidy
Suppose the government wants to promote renewable energy and introduces a subsidy: it pays solar-panel manufacturers a fixed amount for each panel they produce.
From a manufacturer’s point of view, each panel now brings in the market price plus the subsidy. That’s the same as saying each extra panel costs the manufacturer less, by the amount of the subsidy. Some panels that weren’t worth making before now are, and some higher-cost manufacturers that weren’t producing may now find it worthwhile to start.
So at every market price, manufacturers want to make more. Before the program, at a price of $5,000 per panel, the industry supplied 30,000 panels a month. With the subsidy, at the same $5,000 price, it supplies 36,000. The same happens at every other price, so the whole supply curve shifts right.
Notice what the subsidy does not do, at least not directly: it doesn’t set the price customers pay. Whether the market price falls, and by how much, depends on how supply and demand meet, which comes in a later reading. For now, the point is that the subsidy changes how much firms supply at each price. That’s a shift of the supply curve, not a movement along it.
Summary. Market supply is the horizontal sum of individual firm supplies. With identical firms, multiply one firm's quantity by the number of firms. With different technologies, lower-cost firms tend to enter first and higher-cost firms join as price rises. Own price moves the market along supply; cost and participation changes shift the curve.
05
The competitive-market model
When is it reasonable to treat buyers and sellers as price-takers?
Demand tells us how buyers respond to a price. Supply tells us how firms respond to a price. To put the two together, we need a model of the market where they meet.
The model we use is perfect competition. In it, every buyer and seller is a price-taker: they treat the market price as given and decide only how much to buy or sell. No one gets to set the price.
Perfect competition is a benchmark, not a claim that real markets look like this. It leaves out the features that let a buyer or seller influence the price: products that differ from seller to seller, the time and effort it takes to compare prices, and obstacles that stop new firms from joining a market. With those removed, we can see what happens when no one controls the price.
5.1
Why use a model that isn't literally true?
No real market fits perfect competition exactly. Think of tomatoes at a farmers’ market. Tomatoes differ in quality from stall to stall, so the products aren’t identical. Buyers spend time walking between stalls to compare prices, so comparing isn’t free. Starting a farm takes land and equipment, so joining the market isn’t free either. And some growers are much bigger than others, so not every seller is small.
So why use the model? Because it lets us look at one thing at a time. The competitive model asks a narrow question: how do buyers and sellers behave when each one is too small to affect the price? The answer gives us a baseline. To study a real market, we compare it with that baseline. We ask which assumption fails and what that failure lets a buyer or seller do, such as charge more than its rivals.
Economists use models this way all the time. Think of a map. Nobody complains that a map leaves out every tree. What matters is whether it gets you where you’re going. In the same way, the competitive model is useful whenever treating the price as given is a good enough approximation for the decision you’re studying.
5.2
Define the market before judging competition
Whether a market looks competitive depends on how you define it. A café may be one of hundreds in Melbourne, but the only one inside an airport terminal. A hospital may compete with many others for routine care across a city, but have no nearby rival for a specialized emergency service. The same business can face lots of competition in one market and almost none in another.
A market definition has two parts: a product and a place. Products belong in the same market when buyers see them as close enough substitutes. Places belong in the same market when buyers or sellers can switch between them without it costing too much.
Getting the boundary right matters. Define the market too broadly, say as all food sold in Australia, and every firm looks tiny, so competition looks stronger than it really is. Define it too narrowly, say as coffee sold at a single airport gate, and almost every seller looks like a monopolist, the only seller in its market. To find a sensible boundary, ask a simple question: if this seller raised its price a little, would enough buyers switch to another product or another place? For the airport café, probably not. Travelers who are past security can’t walk to a café in town. That’s why the café’s market is the terminal, not the city.
The competitive model can’t draw this boundary for you. It only becomes useful once you know what buyers’ real alternatives are. A wheat farmer selling into a global market may well be a price-taker. The only mechanic in a remote town isn’t, even though both are small businesses. What matters isn’t how big a business is, but how big it is relative to its market.
5.3
Assumption 1: homogeneous goods
Goods are when buyers see the units sold by different sellers as identical. A kilogram of standard-grade wheat from one farm does exactly the same job as a kilogram from another, so the buyer doesn’t care who grew it.
This matters because of what it does to prices. Suppose two sellers offer the same good and buyers can see both prices. If one seller charges more, buyers simply go to the cheaper one. Nothing about the product can justify the higher price, because buyers see no difference worth paying for.
Notice that homogeneity is about how buyers compare products, not only about the products themselves. Electricity from two power stations is literally the same once it’s in the grid, so buyers have no reason to prefer one over the other. Wheat of a given grade is close to homogeneous. Restaurant meals aren’t, even when two restaurants use the same ingredients, because location, service and reputation all affect how much a diner values the meal. Products that buyers see as different are called differentiated.
When products are differentiated, a firm can raise its price and still keep some customers: the ones who prefer its version. That firm faces its own downward-sloping demand curve, and it has some market power, meaning some ability to set its price rather than just take it. We’ll study firms like this in later weeks.
5.4
Assumption 2: price-taking
is the heart of the model. Each buyer and seller treats the market price as given and decides only how much to buy or sell.
This is believable when each participant is small relative to the market. If one tomato grower keeps a crate off the market, total supply barely changes. If one shopper buys an extra kilogram, total quantity demanded barely changes. Neither action moves the market price by enough to matter. You saw the same idea with Auto Eco: with a thousand similar firms, one firm’s output is a tenth of one percent of the market, so changing it leaves the price essentially where it was.
Price-taking doesn’t mean participants are passive. Buyers decide how much to buy by comparing the price with how much they value one more unit. Firms decide how much to produce by comparing the price with their marginal cost. Both can respond strongly when the price changes. What they can’t do is choose the price itself.
In the model, price-taking isn’t assumed out of thin air. The other assumptions are what make it hold. Because there are many small participants, no single one matters to the price. Because goods are homogeneous and prices are easy to compare, a seller who charges more than the market price loses its customers. And over a longer period, free entry keeps profits in check: if sellers earn high profits, new firms join, add to supply and push the price down. We look at entry more closely in 5.6.
5.5
Assumption 3: zero search cost
Search is costless when buyers and sellers can find each other and compare prices without spending any real time or money. At an open farmers’ market, a buyer can walk past every stall and see every price. On an online exchange for a commodity, prices from all sellers may appear on the screen instantly.
This matters because it keeps prices in line. If goods are identical and buyers can see every price for free, a seller who charges more than the others gets no customers, so every seller ends up charging the same price. When search is costly, that pressure weakens. Two sellers can charge different prices for similar goods, because some buyers won’t find the cheaper option or won’t bother to travel to it. A seller in a convenient location can charge more, because some buyers would rather pay a little extra than go further. An online platform that decides which offers buyers see first can steer them toward some sellers and away from others. In each case, control over information gives someone market power.
Zero search cost is an extreme assumption, since real search always takes some time. But search can be cheap enough that treating the market as having a single price is still a good approximation. The question to ask is whether the cost of searching meaningfully changes the decision you’re studying.
5.6
Assumption 4: free entry and exit
Free entry means a new firm can join the market on the same terms as the firms already in it. Free exit means a firm can leave the market without being stuck with costs that keep it there, such as a long lease it can’t break.
Starting a business always takes resources, but ordinary costs aren’t barriers. If every newcomer can rent the same equipment, hire workers at the same wages and use the same technology as existing firms, those costs are just part of producing. A barrier is different. It gives existing firms an advantage newcomers can’t match, or it keeps newcomers out even when joining would be profitable.
Many things can act as barriers. A market may require a license that only a few firms hold. A patent gives one firm the legal right to be the only producer of an invention for a period. An existing firm may sign exclusive contracts that tie up suppliers or customers. Good locations may be scarce. Some products are worth more the more people use them, as with a social network, so a newcomer with few users struggles to attract more. And some industries require large investments that can’t be recovered if the firm later leaves, which makes entering risky. How much these matter depends on the market. Starting a food truck takes a modest commitment. Building an electricity network takes an enormous one.
Entry and exit matter most over time. If firms in a market earn more than their opportunity cost, that is, more than they could earn elsewhere, and newcomers can copy what they do, those profits attract new firms. If firms keep losing money, some leave, and the market loses their capacity. We’ll see how this changes market outcomes when we study the long run.
5.7
How the assumptions fit together
The four assumptions aren’t a checklist of unrelated boxes to tick. As we saw in 5.4, the other three are what make price-taking hold. Identical goods and free price comparison stop any seller from charging more. Many small sellers mean no single seller moves total supply. Free entry means high profits attract competitors instead of staying protected.
That also means price-taking can be a good approximation even when an assumption doesn’t hold perfectly. A wheat farmer faces transport costs, and wheat varies in quality, so neither homogeneity nor zero search cost holds exactly. But the farmer is still far too small to affect the price grain buyers offer, so treating that price as given works well. The reverse can happen too. A market can have many sellers and still not be competitive if a single platform controls how they reach customers.
So the useful question about a real market isn’t “Is this market perfectly competitive?” because almost none is. It’s “Who can affect the price, what gives them that ability, and for how long?” The competitive model tells you where to look for the answer.
5.8
Short run and long run
The is a period in which at least one commitment can’t be changed and the number of firms is fixed. A commitment is something a firm has already locked in, such as a factory, a machine or a lease. In the short run, firms can change how much they produce by changing things like labor hours or materials. But they can’t build a new plant overnight, and new firms can’t set up in time to join.
The is a period long enough for everything to change: every input and the number of firms. Firms can expand or shrink their capacity, leases can run out, new firms can enter and existing ones can leave.
These aren’t calendar periods. The long run might be a few weeks for a market stall, years for a mine and decades for an electricity network. What matters is which decisions can change within the time frame you’re studying.
Think of hotel rooms during a major event. This week, the number of rooms in the city is essentially fixed. A higher price might persuade a hotel to open a few rooms it was holding back for maintenance, but supply can’t grow much. If high room prices last for several years, hotels renovate and add rooms, and new hotels get built. The same city then responds to price very differently. Neither picture is the wrong one: each answers a different question. A manager planning next weekend needs the short-run view. An investor deciding whether to build a hotel needs the long-run view.
The time frame also changes which costs count. Recall from Week 1 that a firm’s decisions depend only on the costs it can avoid. This month, a firm’s lease is already signed, so it pays the rent whether it produces or not, and the rent doesn’t affect this month’s decision. Next year, the firm can choose not to renew, so the rent becomes a cost it can avoid. That’s why a firm’s shutdown threshold can differ between the short run and the long run. Short-run supply reflects the capacity and commitments firms already have. Long-run supply also includes building new capacity, new firms entering and existing firms leaving.
5.9
What the model does not yet determine
We now have a demand curve, which tells us how much buyers want at each price, and a supply curve, which tells us how much firms want to sell at each price. What we don’t have yet is the price itself.
At some prices, buyers want more than firms are willing to supply. At others, firms want to supply more than buyers want to buy. To finish the model, we need to explain how these mismatches push the price up or down, and where the market settles: at the price where the quantity buyers want matches the quantity firms want to sell.
That’s the subject of the next reading. These readings have built its ingredients. How much buyers value a good gives us individual demand. What it costs firms to produce gives us individual supply. Adding up horizontally takes us from individual curves to market curves. And the competitive assumptions let each buyer and seller treat the price as given, even though the market as a whole determines it.
Summary. Perfect competition is a benchmark built on homogeneous goods, price-taking, costless search and free entry and exit. The assumptions support the idea that each buyer and firm treats price as given. The short run fixes some commitments and the number of firms; the long run allows capacity, entry and exit to change.