Read 1 of 5

Individual demand

How does one buyer respond when price changes?

A demand curve isn't a record of what someone bought yesterday. It's a plan. It tells us how much one buyer would choose to buy at every possible price, given their income, their preferences, and the prices of other goods.

The plan comes from a choice. A buyer has a budget, set by their income, and many goods and services they could spend it on. Any combination of these goods and services is called a bundle: three coffees and two biscotti is one bundle, five coffees and no biscotti is another. The budget rules out the bundles the buyer can't afford. Among the ones they can afford, they choose the bundle with the greatest total value to them. This is the economic value from Week 1, now applied to a whole bundle rather than a single good. Economists call this an optimization problem: finding the best option available, where the budget decides what's available.

Change the price of one good and the set of affordable bundles changes with it, so the buyer may well choose differently. Tracking how much of that good ends up in the best bundle, price by price, gives us the demand curve. Usually, a lower price means more. One reason is easy to see: when a good gets cheaper, each unit costs the buyer less of everything else they might have bought.

1.1

Demand comes from a choice

Maya loves coffee and biscotti. She has $30 a day to spend on the two, and each biscotto costs $4. For her, a bundle is just a pair of numbers: how many coffees and how many biscotti.

Let \(q\) be cups of coffee and \(b\) be the number of biscotti. If coffee costs \(p\) a cup, Maya spends \(pq\) on coffee and \(4b\) on biscotti, so she can afford a bundle when

Maya's daily budget constraint\(pq+4b\leq 30\)

The inequality is what makes this a constraint. She can spend less than $30, but never more.

Next we need to know what each bundle is worth to her. The table below gives Maya's total value from each quantity of each good. These are cumulative totals, not the value of one more unit. Four coffees are worth $26 to her in total, and two biscotti are worth $12.

Quantity012345
Coffee value0815212630
Biscotti value0712151718

Now put the two together. Every cell in the grid below is one bundle, and the number in it is what that bundle is worth to Maya: her coffee value plus her biscotti value. The bundle of four coffees and two biscotti, for instance, is worth $26 + $12 = $38.

Here's the key thing to notice as you work with the grid. The values in the cells never change. What Maya thinks a bundle is worth doesn't depend on what it costs. The coffee price changes only which cells she can afford: white cells are within her budget, gray cells aren't.

Try an affordable bundle, then reveal Maya's best one. Each revealed choice adds a point to her demand curve.

Each reveal plots the number of coffees in Maya's best bundle against the price she faced. At a given price, the quantity of coffee in her best bundle is her . Collect those choices across every possible coffee price, holding her budget, her preferences and the biscotti price fixed, and you have her .

1.2

The best affordable bundle

Maya doesn't decide how much coffee to buy on its own. Every dollar she spends on coffee is a dollar she can't spend on biscotti, so the two decisions are really one decision. What she chooses is a bundle, and she picks the affordable bundle she values most.

Working through one price

Take a coffee price of $5. Maya's best bundle is four coffees and two biscotti. It costs \(4(5)+2(4)=28\), or $28, which is within her $30 budget. It's worth $38 to her: $26 from the coffee and $12 from the biscotti.

How do we know nothing else beats it? Compare the nearby bundles she could also afford:

BundleCostTotal value
4 coffees, 2 biscotti$28$38
5 coffees, 1 biscotto$29$37
3 coffees, 3 biscotti$27$36
5 coffees, 0 biscotti$25$30
3 coffees, 2 biscotti$23$33

Look at the second row. Swapping a biscotto for a fifth coffee adds $4 of coffee value and gives up $5 of biscotti value, so Maya is $1 worse off. The third row runs the trade the other way: she gives up the fourth coffee, worth $5, to gain a third biscotto, worth only $3, and loses $2. Every move away from four coffees and two biscotti costs her more than it gains. That's what makes it best.

Maya's choiceMaya chooses \(q\) coffees and \(b\) biscotti to make her total value as large as possible, subject to \(pq+4b\leq 30\).

Two things worth noticing

She doesn't spend everything. Her best bundle costs $28, leaving $2 unspent. That might look like a mistake, but it isn't. Maya would happily buy more if she could. The problem is that coffee costs $5 and a biscotto costs $4, so $2 buys nothing at all. Coffee and biscotti come in whole units, and her leftover change isn't enough for either. Had coffee been sold by the millilitre, she'd have spent the lot.

She can't have what she'd most like. The highest value anywhere in the grid is $48, at five coffees and five biscotti. Maya would love that bundle. But at $5 a coffee it costs $45, and even at the lowest price on the page, $4, it still costs $40. It's out of reach at every price we consider.

This is the shape of every economic choice: preferences tell us which bundles Maya ranks highest, and her budget tells us which of them she's actually allowed to have. Economists call this constrained optimization. The best bundle is almost never the best bundle imaginable. It's the best one available.

Why value alone isn't enough

In Week 1 we measured a buyer's value for a good by their willingness to pay. That's still the right measure of value, but on its own it doesn't tell us what Maya buys. She's willing to pay something for a fifth coffee, $4 of value, and at a $5 price she doesn't buy it. Not because she doesn't want it, but because those $5 do more for her as a biscotto plus change toward the next one.

So demand depends on three things together: what Maya values, what things cost and how much she has to spend. Change any one of them and her choice can change. The rest of this reading works through what happens when each one does.

1.3

Why individual demand usually slopes down

We now have Maya's choice at one price. Doing the same at every price traces out her demand curve. Here's what it looks like.

Coffee price$8$7$6$5$4
Cups of coffee chosen23345

As the price falls, the quantity rises. Plotting these five points gives a downward-sloping curve made of steps rather than a smooth line.

Why a lower price leads to more coffee

Start at some price and lower it, with Maya's budget, her preferences and the price of biscotti all unchanged. Two things happen to her affordable set.

First, every bundle she could afford before is still affordable, since nothing got more expensive. Second, bundles that were just out of reach, the ones with more coffee in them, now come within budget. Her options have expanded, and they've expanded in the coffee direction specifically.

At the same time, the exchange rate between the two goods has shifted. At $8 a cup, a coffee costs Maya two biscotti. At $4, it costs one. Coffee has become cheaper not just in dollars but in biscotti, which is the comparison that matters when she's choosing between them.

Why the steps are flat

Maya's quantity stays at three cups when the price moves from $6 to $7. That isn't because she's indifferent. At each of those prices she has exactly one best bundle. At $6 she chooses three coffees and three biscotti ($30, worth $36). At $7 she chooses three coffees and two biscotti ($29, worth $33). Different bundles, both with three coffees in them.

This is what discrete choice looks like. Maya can't buy 3.4 coffees, so a small price change often shows up as her buying fewer biscotti rather than less coffee. The quantity only moves when the price shifts enough to tip a whole unit.

The role of diminishing marginal value

Look at the marginal values in the grid headers. Successive coffees add $8, $7, $6, $5 and $4 of value. Successive biscotti add $7, $5, $3, $2 and $1.

These falling increments are part of why Maya spreads her budget over both goods instead of piling into one. If coffees kept adding $8 each, she'd buy nothing but coffee. Because each extra cup adds less than the last, there comes a point where another coffee is worth less to her than the biscotti she'd give up for it. That's where she stops.

It also explains why a lower price pulls in more coffee. At $8, only the first two cups are worth their price in forgone biscotti. At $4, the fourth and fifth cups clear that bar too.

Two forces behind the change

Economists find it useful to split a price change into two separate effects, because they can pull in different directions.

The . A lower coffee price makes coffee cheaper relative to biscotti, as we saw: two biscotti per cup at $8, one at $4. Even setting aside the fact that Maya is now better off, the swap looks more attractive than it did. This pull toward the cheaper good is the substitution effect, and it always points the same way: when a good gets cheaper relative to the alternatives, it draws purchases toward itself.

The . A lower coffee price also leaves Maya with money to spare. If she kept buying exactly what she bought before, she'd have change left over. Her $30 stretches further than it did, so she's effectively richer even though her income hasn't changed. How she spends that extra purchasing power is the income effect.

Both effects come from the same price change, and separating them is a thought experiment rather than something we can read off the grid. The grid shows only Maya's final choice, the two effects combined.

Why the two effects matter

The direction of the income effect depends on the good.

For most goods, being richer means buying more. Economists call these , and we come back to the term in Section 1.6. For a normal good, a price fall produces two effects that push the same way. Substitution says buy more because it's relatively cheaper; income says buy more because you can afford more. Quantity demanded rises, and the demand curve slopes down.

For some goods, being richer means buying less. These are , and the classic examples are cheap staples people move away from as their circumstances improve. Here the two effects fight each other. Substitution still says buy more of the cheaper good, but income says buy less, because the buyer is now better off and would rather have something else.

Almost always, substitution wins and the curve still slopes down. But not as a matter of logic. If a good takes up a large share of someone's budget and the income effect is strong enough to overwhelm substitution, a price fall could lead them to buy less. Economists call such a good a Giffen good. Clear real-world examples are rare and disputed, which is the point: downward-sloping demand is a very strong empirical regularity, not a theorem.

1.4

Marginal value isn't total value

Every cell in the grid reports a total: what that whole bundle is worth to Maya. The small numbers in the headers report something different. Above each coffee column is what that cup adds as you move one column right, and beside each biscotti row is what that biscotto adds as you move one row up. These are marginal values.

Writing \(V_C(q)\) for Maya's total value from \(q\) coffees, the marginal value of one more cup is

Marginal value of another coffee\(V_C(q+1)-V_C(q)\)

So the fourth coffee is worth \(V_C(4)-V_C(3)=\$26-\$21=\$5\).

Cups12345
Total value$8$15$21$26$30
Marginal value of that cup$8$7$6$5$4

Marginal values fall as Maya drinks more, but her total value doesn't. Five coffees are worth $30 to her, more than the $26 she gets from four. Every extra cup still makes her better off, just by less than the one before. The top row keeps rising while the bottom row falls.

Why marginal value alone doesn't settle the choice

No coffee is bought in isolation. If Maya has already spent her budget, a fifth coffee has to be paid for by dropping a biscotto. The question isn't whether the fifth coffee is worth something. It's whether it's worth more than what she gives up. At $5 a cup, that coffee adds $4, while the biscotto she'd drop is worth $5. Four gained against five given up, so she doesn't do it.

This is why the demand curve records chosen quantities, not the value of the last unit. A lower price changes no number in the grid. It changes which bundles Maya can reach, and she picks again.

State the period

Demand is always demand per period. Five coffees a day and five a week describe completely different buyers. Maya's $30 and her quantities are daily, so her demand curve is a daily one. Before comparing two buyers, or adding them together, check that both refer to the same period.

1.5

A movement along demand versus a shift of demand

When the coffee price changes and everything else stays fixed, Maya faces the same problem with a different affordable set. Her chosen quantity moves to another point on the same demand curve. Economists call this a .

In the grid, a fall from $8 to $5 takes her from two coffees to four. The right way to describe this is “Maya's quantity demanded increases.” Not “Maya's demand increases,” which is reserved for something else.

That something else is a shift of demand, and it happens when one of the things we've been holding fixed changes instead. Maya's demand curve was drawn under three conditions: her budget is $30, her preferences are the values in the table and biscotti cost $4. Change any one of them and we have to redo the whole exercise. Suppose her budget rises to $40. At $8 a cup she might now choose three coffees instead of two, at $5 she might choose five instead of four, and so on at every price. The result is a new curve sitting to the right of the old one. That's a shift of demand: not a new point on the curve, but a new curve.

So the two cases differ in what caused the change. A change in coffee's own price moves Maya along her curve. A change in anything else gives her a different curve. The distinction sounds fussy, but it prevents a real mistake. The demand curve is already a complete answer to “how much does she buy at each price?” So a price change can never explain why the curve moved; the curve hasn't moved. Sections 1.6 and 1.7 take up the two most important sources of shifts: her income and the prices of related goods.

Own price changesMovement along demand

The curve stays put; quantity demanded changes.

Other fundamentals of demand changeShift of demand

The whole curve moves; the quantity chosen at every price may change.

1.6

Income: normal and inferior goods

A pay rise lifts Maya's daily budget from $30 to $40. At every coffee price, she can now afford bundles that were out of reach, and she may choose more coffee at each one. Her whole demand curve shifts to the right, which is the shift we just described. When demand responds this way, coffee is a for Maya.

“Normal” here doesn't mean ordinary, necessary or respectable. It's a label for one specific relationship: more income, more demand. Restaurant meals, new cars and organic groceries are usually normal goods because people buy more of them, or better versions of them, as they earn more.

For an the relationship runs backwards: more income, less demand. This isn't because the buyer stops needing the good. It's because they switch to something they preferred all along but couldn't justify before. A student eats fewer instant noodles once they have a full-time salary. A commuter takes the bus less often after buying a car. In both cases the extra income buys a move to the alternative.

“Inferior” is just as misleading a word as “normal.” It says nothing about quality. A bus service can be clean, punctual and excellent and still be an inferior good for a particular commuter, because what makes it inferior is how that person's demand responds to income, nothing else.

Two further points. The label belongs to a buyer, not to a product: the same bus route can be normal for a student without a car and inferior for a commuter who could buy one. And it belongs to an income range: rice may be normal for someone on a very low income and inferior for the same person once they're earning much more.

To classify a good, then, hold its price, other prices and the buyer's preferences fixed, change only income and see which way demand moves.

Normal good

When income rises, demand rises. When income falls, demand falls.

Inferior good

When income rises, demand falls. When income falls, demand rises.

Classify the income response

In every scenario, the good's price, other prices and the buyer's preferences stay fixed. Use the stated change in income and quantity demanded, not the name of the product.

Question 1 of 6

Priya's monthly income rises from $3,000 to $4,000. A restaurant lunch still costs $18, and she increases her restaurant lunches from two to five per month. For Priya, restaurant lunches are:

Choose one answer.

None of these labels belongs permanently to the product. The evidence tells us how one buyer responds over one income range. Another buyer, or the same buyer at a different income, may respond differently.

1.7

Prices of related goods

In Week 1 we met substitutes and complements as things that influence how much a good is worth to a buyer. Here we use them for a different job: explaining how a price change in one market shifts the demand curve in another.

A note on which price is which. Maya's demand curve for coffee already accounts for the coffee price; that's what moves her along the curve. The prices we're discussing now are other goods' prices, which were held fixed when we drew the curve. When one of them changes, the curve moves.

. Two goods are substitutes when one can take the place of the other. If tea gets more expensive, some tea drinkers switch to coffee, so demand for coffee rises at every coffee price and the curve shifts right. A higher price for one raises demand for the other.

They don't have to be alike. Flying and taking the train between Melbourne and Sydney are very different experiences, but a traveler choosing between them treats them as substitutes. So do two project-management platforms for a business deciding which to subscribe to. The test isn't similarity; it's whether a buyer would swap one for the other when relative prices change.

. Two goods are complements when they're used together, so buying one creates a reason to buy the other. If coffee machines get much more expensive and fewer households buy them, demand for coffee pods falls, even though pods themselves cost the same. A higher price for one lowers demand for the other, shifting that curve left.

. Most pairs of goods have no real connection. A rise in the price of rice isn't going to change Maya's shampoo purchases, and her demand curve for shampoo stays where it is.

None of these labels is printed on a product. They describe how one buyer's choices connect two goods, and the same pair can be related for one person and unrelated for another.

RelationshipIf the price of good Y risesDemand for good X
SubstitutesY becomes less attractive relative to XShifts right
ComplementsUsing X together with Y becomes more costlyShifts left
IndependentThe choice of X is largely unchangedNo systematic shift

Match the relationship

For each observation, choose substitutes, complements or independent goods. Assume everything else is held fixed.

Answer key: 1 substitutes; 2 complements; 3 independent; 4 substitutes; 5 complements; 6 independent.

1.8

Reading a demand change carefully

A manager who sees sales go up needs to know why before deciding what to do next. The movement-versus-shift distinction isn't bookkeeping; it points to two different business situations.

Suppose a café sold 20% more coffee this month. If that happened because it cut its price, the café moved along its demand curve. It bought the extra volume with margin, and the question now is whether the trade was worth it: did the extra cups cover the revenue given up on every cup it was already selling?

If sales rose 20% with no price change, something shifted the curve. Maybe the café across the road raised its prices, or a new office block opened nearby. Here the question is different: is this permanent, and should the café raise its own price now that demand is stronger?

The first change the firm chose. The second happened to it. Confusing them leads to bad conclusions, like crediting a price cut for growth that actually came from a competitor's mistake, and then cutting again when the competitor corrects course.

So demand analysis starts with a disciplined sentence: name the good, the buyer, the period and what changed. Then ask one question. Was it the good's own price, or something else? Once that's settled, the graph follows.

Summary

Individual demand comes from constrained choice. At each price, the buyer picks the highest-value bundle their budget allows, and the amount of the good in that bundle is their quantity demanded. A change in the good's own price moves the buyer along the demand curve. A change in income, preferences, or the prices of related goods shifts the whole curve.

Concept atlas