Explore · Week 07

Does the aluminum cartel hold?

How patient must the firms be to keep to a quota of 30 tonnes?

Both firms follow grim trigger: produce the quota of 30 until anyone produces 40, then produce 40 forever. Drag the discount factor, then change the profits.

The top chart compares the profit streams from keeping the quota and from cheating once. The bottom chart plots their discounted values; the cartel holds where the green curve is above the red one.

Observe, then explain

Predict

With profits of 2,000, 1,800, 1,600 and 1,500, at what discount factor does the cartel hold?

Vary

Raise the profit from cheating to 2,025, the best cheat. What happens to the threshold?

Explain

Use \(\delta\geq(T-R)/(T-P)\) to say why a harsher punishment helps the cartel.

Concept atlas