Week 5: Practice

A Remote Island Far Away

Les épinards is the only supplier of spinach in a small country with two markets: the mainland and a remote island. Daily demand is

Mainland and island demand\(q_M=200-p_M\quad\text{and}\quad q_I=100-2p_I\)

where \(p_M\) and \(p_I\) are the prices Les épinards charges in each market. Supplying either market costs the same, and marginal cost depends on total output \(Q=q_M+q_I\):

Marginal cost\(MC(Q)=Q\)

Question 1

Find the profit-maximizing quantities Les épinards supplies to the mainland and to the island.

Reveal the solution

Les épinards can charge a different price in each market, so this is third-degree price discrimination. Inverse demands are \(p_M=200-q_M\) and \(p_I=50-q_I/2\), so

Marginal revenues\(MR_M(q_M)\)\(=\)\(200-2q_M\)\(MR_I(q_I)\)\(=\)\(50-q_I\)

Try to serve both markets. Each marginal revenue must equal marginal cost, \(q_M+q_I\):

Mainland\(200-2q_M\)\(=\)\(q_M+q_I\)\(200\)\(=\)\(3q_M+q_I\)
Island\(50-q_I\)\(=\)\(q_M+q_I\)\(50\)\(=\)\(q_M+2q_I\)

From the island equation, \(q_M=50-2q_I\). Substitute into the mainland equation:

Solve\(200\)\(=\)\(3(50-2q_I)+q_I\)\(=\)\(150-5q_I\)\(q_I\)\(=\)\(-10\)

A negative quantity means the island shouldn't be served at all. So Les épinards sells only on the mainland, where \(MR_M=MC\):

Mainland only\(200-2q_M\)\(=\)\(q_M\)\(q_M\)\(=\)\(\dfrac{200}{3}\approx66.67\)

Check the island at this output. Marginal cost is \(200/3\approx66.67\), and the first unit sold on the island would add at most \(MR_I(0)=50\). The island's highest marginal revenue is below marginal cost, so selling there would lower profit. Les épinards supplies about 66.67 units to the mainland and none to the island.

Question 2

What is the price on the mainland and on the island?

Reveal the solution
Mainland price\(p_M\)\(=\)\(200-\dfrac{200}{3}\)\(=\)\(\dfrac{400}{3}\approx133.33\)

The island isn't served. Islanders want no spinach at a price of $50 or more, so any island price of at least $50 is consistent with the answer. In practice, Les épinards simply doesn't ship to the island. Compare the mainland price of $133.33: islanders would buy nothing at that price either.

Concept atlas