Week 5: Practice

Tennis Racquets

A screen that doesn't pay

Ace Pro is the only maker of tennis racquets on Isola del Tennis. It has two plants, one for standard racquets and one for high-quality racquets, each with unlimited capacity and no fixed cost. A standard racquet costs $40 to make and a high-quality racquet $60.

The island has 50,000 tennis players, and each buys at most one racquet a year. There are 40,000 veterans and 10,000 professionals.

StandardHigh quality
Veteran WTP$60$100
Professional WTP$120$150
Cost$40$60

Each player buys the racquet that gives the largest surplus, as long as it isn't negative. If both racquets give the same surplus, the player buys the high-quality one. Ace Pro can't tell veterans and professionals apart, and it sets prices in multiples of $10.

Question 1

If Ace Pro sells only standard racquets, what price maximizes its profit, and what is the profit?

Reveal the solution

At $60 every player buys: \((60-40)\times50{,}000=1{,}000{,}000\). At $120 only professionals buy: \((120-40)\times10{,}000=800{,}000\). The best standard-only price is $60, for $1.0 million. The high-quality price has to be high enough that nobody buys it, for example $150 or more.

Question 2

If Ace Pro sells only high-quality racquets, what price maximizes its profit, and what is the profit?

Reveal the solution

At $100 every player buys: \((100-60)\times50{,}000=2{,}000{,}000\). At $150 only professionals buy: \((150-60)\times10{,}000=900{,}000\). The best high-quality-only price is $100, for $2.0 million, with the standard price set high enough that nobody buys it, for example $120 or more.

Question 3

Suppose Ace Pro sells both racquets, so that the two groups buy different ones. What prices maximize its profit, and what is the profit?

Reveal the solution

There are two ways to split the groups.

Professionals on high quality, veterans on standard. Veterans must strictly prefer standard, because ties go to high quality: \(60-p_s>100-p_h\), so \(p_h>p_s+40\). Professionals must prefer high quality: \(150-p_h\geq120-p_s\), so \(p_h\le p_s+30\). Both can't hold. This split is impossible. Veterans value the upgrade at $40 and professionals at only $30, so any upgrade price that suits professionals also tempts veterans.

Veterans on high quality, professionals on standard. Charge veterans their full $100 for high quality. Professionals then get \(150-100=50\) from high quality, so they buy standard only if \(120-p_s>50\), that is \(p_s\lt70\). The highest allowed price is $60. Veterans get zero from either racquet and, breaking the tie, buy high quality.

Profit from the split\(\pi\)\(=\)\((100-60)\times40{,}000+(60-40)\times10{,}000\)\(=\)\(1{,}600{,}000+200{,}000\)\(=\)\(1{,}800{,}000\)

The best way to sell both racquets earns $1.8 million.

Question 4

Which plan should Ace Pro choose?

Reveal the solution

Selling only high-quality racquets at $100 earns $2.0 million, more than the $1.8 million from selling both. Ace Pro should drop the standard racquet.

The menu doesn't pay here. Both groups value the upgrade at more than its $20 cost, so the most profitable product for each group is the high-quality racquet. The only split that works puts professionals on the standard racquet, which wastes $10 of upgrade value on each of them and still leaves them $60 of surplus. Selling one product leaves professionals $50 instead and sells every player the better racquet.

A screen pays when the high-value type cares much more about the premium feature than the low-value type, as business travelers do about flexibility. Here it's the other way around.

Concept atlas