Week 5: In-class

A Fashion Statement

Pasta Couture, the Australian subsidiary of an Italian company, is known for its men's cashmere sweaters, which enjoy strong brand recognition and customer loyalty. It sells them through two store chains. One serves young buyers, aged 16 to 45. The other serves mature buyers, aged 45 and over.

The sweaters have the same design in both chains. They differ only in color and dyeing pattern, and a pattern that appeals to one group doesn't appeal to the other at all. Dyeing, production and distribution cost the same for both chains.

Last year Pasta Couture sold about $6 million worth of sweaters to young buyers at $120 each, and about 60,000 sweaters to mature buyers at $340 each. A marketing study found that, at these prices and quantities, a 1% price rise would cut young buyers' purchases by 1.2%, and that marginal revenue from mature buyers is about $280.

Question 1

Based on this information, does Pasta Couture's current pricing maximize its profit? Could it earn more by selling more sweaters to young buyers?

Reveal the solution

Young buyers bought \(6{,}000{,}000/120=50{,}000\) sweaters, and their elasticity there is \(-1.2\). So

Young marginal revenue\(MR_y\)\(=\)\(120\left(1+\dfrac{1}{-1.2}\right)\)\(=\)\(20\)

Marginal revenue from mature buyers is $280. At the best allocation, the two marginal revenues must be equal, so the current pricing isn't profit-maximizing.

We don't need marginal cost to see how to improve. Keep total output at 110,000 sweaters, so cost doesn't change, and dye a few more for mature buyers and a few fewer for young buyers. Each sweater moved loses about $20 of young revenue and gains about $280 of mature revenue. So Pasta Couture should sell fewer sweaters to young buyers, by raising the young price, and more to mature buyers, by lowering the mature price.

Question 2

The accounts show annual cost \(C(Q)=10{,}000{,}000+50Q\), where \(Q=q_y+q_m\) is the total number of sweaters. New market research estimates the inverse demands as

Inverse demands\(p_y(q_y)=220-\dfrac{q_y}{500}\quad\text{and}\quad p_m(q_m)=400-\dfrac{q_m}{1{,}000}\)

Find the profit-maximizing price for each group and the number of sweaters each group buys.

Reveal the solution

With linear demand, marginal revenue has the same intercept and twice the slope: \(MR_y=220-q_y/250\) and \(MR_m=400-q_m/500\). Marginal cost is constant at 50. Equal marginal revenues, both equal to marginal cost, give

Mature\(400-\dfrac{q_m}{500}\)\(=\)\(50\)\(q_m\)\(=\)\(175{,}000\)\(p_m\)\(=\)\(400-\dfrac{175{,}000}{1{,}000}\)\(=\)\(225\)
Young\(220-\dfrac{q_y}{250}\)\(=\)\(50\)\(q_y\)\(=\)\(42{,}500\)\(p_y\)\(=\)\(220-\dfrac{42{,}500}{500}\)\(=\)\(135\)

Pasta Couture should charge young buyers $135 and mature buyers $225, selling 42,500 and 175,000 sweaters. Profit is

Annual profit\(\pi\)\(=\)\(135\times42{,}500+225\times175{,}000-(10{,}000{,}000+50\times217{,}500)\)\(=\)\(45{,}112{,}500-20{,}875{,}000\)\(=\)\(24{,}237{,}500\)

The old prices lie on these demands: \(p_y(50{,}000)=120\) and \(p_m(60{,}000)=340\). Young sales fall from 50,000 to 42,500, as Question 1 predicted. The young group is more elastic, so it pays less: check that \((135-50)/135\) and \((225-50)/225\) match one over each group's elasticity at the optimum.

Concept atlas