Practice 03 · Week 01

The Piggy Bank

Should Last Chance Bank make more loans or fewer?

A bank in trouble

In 1974, the shareholders of Last Chance Bank were running out of patience. The bank was earning a return on its assets of less than a tenth of the industry average, and shareholders had begun to question its strategy. Management responded by hiring you as a consultant. Last Chance Bank is a real institution; only its name has been changed.

How the bank worked

Last Chance Bank's business model was simple. It borrowed money from people who wanted to save and lent it to people who wanted to spend, and it lent out every dollar it raised.

Its founder had set two rules for approving a loan. First, the borrower had to have both the means and the intent to repay. Second, the interest rate on the loan had to be at least 1.5 percentage points above the bank's average cost of the funds it lent. Thanks to the first rule, no borrower had ever defaulted.

Where the money came from

The bank drew its loanable funds from three sources: checking accounts, savings accounts and the federal funds market. Money market accounts were not yet available.

Checking accounts paid customers no interest, but they weren't free for the bank. Servicing them cost the bank about 2.25% of deposits a year. The bank held about $2 billion in checking accounts.

Savings accounts paid interest, so they cost the bank more, about 4% a year. The bank held about $1 billion in savings accounts.

Deposits in both types of account had stayed fairly stable over time. Federal regulations capped the interest rates the bank could offer, so it couldn't attract more deposits by paying savers more.

As loan applications grew, the bank turned to the federal funds market, where banks with surplus funds lend to banks that are short, sometimes for as little as a day. Over the past year, Last Chance had borrowed about $2 billion this way. Federal funds were usually more expensive than deposits, and their rate could swing sharply. Over the past two years, it had climbed from 6% to 11%, and it currently stood at about 10%.

The new strategy

To win market share, management had recently cut the bank's loan rate. Instead of charging 1.5 percentage points above the current average cost of funds, the bank would now charge 1 percentage point above it, and it would hold this rate fixed for the coming year. The bank charged the same rate on all its loans, so the new rate applied to every loan on its books.

As management expected, loan applications poured in. Management forecast an additional $1 billion in loans over the coming year. In its view, the bank would attract many more borrowers without substantially raising its funding costs, and its overall performance would improve.

The Board of Directors has asked you to evaluate this strategy.

Exhibit 1 · Sources of loanable funds

SourceAmountAnnual cost to the bank
Checking accounts$2 billionAbout 2.25% (servicing)
Savings accounts$1 billionAbout 4% (interest)
Federal funds$2 billionAbout 10% currently; 6% to 11% over two years

Lending rules

RuleLoan rate
Founder's ruleAt least the current average cost of funds + 1.5 percentage points
New policyCurrent average cost of funds + 1 percentage point, fixed for the coming year, on all loans

Questions

1. Is cutting the loan rate to attract an additional $1 billion in loans profitable for Last Chance Bank?

2. Should the bank be making more loans or fewer? Explain your reasoning.

Reveal the solution

Question 1

Step 1: the bank's pricing rule

The bank prices loans off its average cost of funds. Weighting each source by its size gives:

Average cost of funds\\(\\displaystyle \\frac{2(2.25\\%)+1(4\\%)+2(10\\%)}{5}\\)\\(=\\)\\(\\displaystyle \\frac{28.5\\%}{5}\\)\\(=\\)\\(5.7\\%\\)

Under the founder's rule, the loan rate is \\(5.7\\%+1.5\\%=7.2\\%\\). Under the new policy, it's \\(5.7\\%+1\\%=6.7\\%\\), fixed for the coming year.

Step 2: the cost of the next loan

Deposits are stuck: regulation stops the bank from paying more to attract them. So every additional dollar the bank lends must be borrowed in the federal funds market at 10%. That's the bank's marginal cost of funds, and it's far above both 7.2% and 6.7%. Every extra loan loses money. The average cost of 5.7% hides this because it blends the expensive federal funds with cheap deposits.

Step 3: profits

Here, profit means interest earned on loans minus the cost of the funds. Before the change, the bank lent $5 billion at 7.2%:

SourceAmountMargin (7.2% minus cost)Profit
Checking$2B4.95%$99M
Savings$1B3.2%$32M
Federal funds$2B−2.8%−$56M
Total$5B$75M

Equivalently, \\(1.5\\%\\times\\$5\\text{B}=\\$75\\text{M}\\), since the rate is 1.5 percentage points above the average cost on every dollar.

After the change, the bank lends $6 billion at 6.7%, with the extra $1 billion borrowed at 10%.

Profit after the change\\(\\text{Revenue: }6.7\\%\\times\\$6\\text{B}\\)\\(=\\)\\(\\$402\\text{M}\\)\\(\\text{Funding cost: }\\$45\\text{M}+\\$40\\text{M}+\\$300\\text{M}\\)\\(=\\)\\(\\$385\\text{M}\\)\\(\\text{Profit: }\\$402\\text{M}-\\$385\\text{M}\\)\\(=\\)\\(\\$17\\text{M}\\)

Profit falls from $75 million to $17 million.

Question 2

The bank should make fewer loans, not more. Look again at the table: even at the founder's 7.2%, the $2 billion funded by federal funds loses $56 million. If the bank stopped borrowing federal funds and lent only its $3 billion in deposits at 7.2%, its profit would be $99 million + $32 million = $131 million, well above $75 million. Beyond $3 billion, a loan pays only if its rate covers the 10% marginal cost of funds.

The lesson

The bank's mistake is pricing off average cost. Average cost tells you what your funds cost on the whole, but a lending decision is about the next dollar, and the next dollar costs 10%. This is the average-versus-marginal distinction from the previous reading, with real money at stake.

Concept atlas