End-of-week challenge · Week 01

TV News Magazine

Hobart, Ballarat and Gold Coast

TV Week produces weekly television guides for local newspapers.

Background

TV Week produces weekly television guides for local papers. The company was established in Melbourne in 1957 to take advantage of the opportunities created by newly developed technologies in computerised printing. At the same time, the widespread deployment of cable TV systems in the 1970s generated demand among local newspapers for a centralised listings producer.

The proliferation of cable channels greatly complicated the listings task facing local newspapers. Small cities, which in the 1960s might typically have had only one or two TV channels, had as many as twenty by the early 1980s. Since most of these new offerings were either national pay services, such as Binge, national superstations, such as ABC and SBS, or specialty national basic channels, national centralised listing production services began to enjoy a distinct advantage over local newspaper services.

Three parts of the weekly guide

The storybook

The storybook was a 16-page TV-magazine section containing stories and pictures on upcoming TV features, stars and items of current TV interest. Examples included movie plot summaries and ratings and a story on violence in children's TV programming. Magazine page components had to be included in multiples of four pages because they were produced by folding larger sheets in two, with two sides for each fold. This part of the guide was similar to the front section of the TV Guide and was common to all editions. It was printed on expensive coated paper and contained colour photographs.

The program book

The program book consisted of program listings specific to each edition, where an edition was the guide for a particular local newspaper. It contained text and pictures associated with advertising but was printed in black and white on newsprint. Like the storybook, it had to be produced in multiples of four pages.

The cover piece

Each guide also included a four-page cover piece comprising the front and back covers, both outside and inside. The cover piece was printed in colour on a special sheet and bound around the storybook and program book to produce a completed guide.

Production process

Printing and delivery

TV Week produces its guides as computer-stored images. The images for each weekly guide are transmitted electronically by satellite to a highly automated local printer, in most cases a sophisticated local newspaper printing plant, such as a Gannett plant. The local plant reads the transmissions into its composing computer, which produces plates for the printing presses. These press plates embody the computer-stored images sent by TV Week.

Black-and-white pages require one plate per page. Colour pages require four separate plates: red, yellow, blue and black. The plates are attached to the presses and used to print the guides. After each weekly edition is printed, the plates are destroyed and the materials recycled. The local plant also binds the pages into complete guides and delivers them in bulk to the local client newspaper.

TV Week typically negotiates prices for plate production, printing and paper, binding and delivery separately with each local printer. Consequently, different guides may have different underlying costs. A guide delivered to a more distant client, for example, may have higher-than-average delivery costs. Exhibit 1 reports expected costs for the next three years based on contracts in existence last year. The production, printing, binding and delivery figures describe a typical contract.

Preparing the storybook

Preparation of the 16-page storybook begins with the editorial department. TV Week's editors collect stories and pictures from staff and from freelancers working on assignment. This material is entered into a composing computer, which formats it in the established TV Week design framework and automatically produces the computer images for transmission to local printers.

Preparing the program book

Producing the program book for each edition is more complicated. TV Week purchases access to a national database of program listings and descriptions that its owner updates weekly. TV Week also compiles local program databases for each edition and updates them weekly.

To produce an edition, TV Week staff enter the channel numbers associated with each locally available station or service into the composing computer. The computer then uses the national and local program databases to produce images of the program-book pages in the standard TV Week format. These images are transmitted to local printers.

Preparing the cover

The cover piece uses photographs and other materials prepared by the editorial department. For each edition, this material is combined in the composing computer with the stored logo and typeface of the local client newspaper. The resulting image is transmitted to the appropriate printer together with the storybook and program book.

Cost information

Exhibit 1 provides cost information for the different parts of the TV Week production process. The figures are average expected costs over the coming three years, excluding additional costs from new contracts.

Editorial and administration costs include $205,000 in annual depreciation for buildings and furnishings and all overhead costs for payroll, management and related activities. Composing-computer costs include all computer and storage costs, including those associated with database and customer-service operations. They also include the cost of excess computer and storage capacity that had been ordered but never used. Of these costs, $705,000 per year represents depreciation.

Database costs include access to the national database and data entry and maintenance for the local databases. Customer-service operations cover billing, responses to queries and sales support for each local account. Each year contains 52 weekly issues.

Exhibit 1 · Expected cost information

Average over the next three years, based on existing contracts.

DepartmentItemAmount
EditorialOverhead$878,000/year
EditorialFreelance$624,000/year ($12,000/weekly issue)
AdministrationOperations$1,033,000/year
Composing computerOperations$1,975,000/year
National program databaseOperations$220,000/year (annual access to data)
Local program databaseOperations$1,360,800/year (approx. $1,800/channel/year)
Local printingColour and cover plate production$405/page ($101.25 per colour page plate)
Local printingB/W plate production$108/page
Local printingCoated paper$0.012/four-page sheet
Local printingNewsprint paper$0.004/four-page sheet
Local printingCover paper$0.016/cover sheet
Local printingBinding$0.019/copy
Local printingDelivery$0.013/copy
Customer serviceOperations$6,000/edition/year

1 · Increased circulation in Hobart, Tasmania

The Hobart Times' contract with TV Week is up for renewal. The newspaper currently distributes an average of 126,000 copies of TV Week each Sunday. This is expected to rise to 146,000 copies a week over the next three years. The guide contains listings for three local and fifteen national channels across 48 pages.

The Hobart Times pays $0.35 per copy and has agreed to maintain this price for the base circulation of 126,000 copies. It wants a lower price for any copies beyond that number.

What does each additional copy cost TV Week? What is the lowest price per extra copy TV Week can offer without reducing its profit?

2 · Increased channel offerings in Ballarat, Victoria

The Ballarat Courier is also at the end of a three-year contract. During the existing contract, circulation of the Ballarat edition of TV Week averaged 84,000 copies per issue. Circulation has been remarkably stable in the past and is expected to remain so for the foreseeable future.

The Ballarat area has been served by two local and four national channels. A new cable system will increase this to two local and sixteen national channels. As a result, the program book for each issue will increase from 16 to 48 pages.

How much must TV Week increase its original price to maintain its former profit level?

3 · A new guide for Gold Coast, Queensland

The Gold Coast Express, with a Sunday circulation of 48,000, has asked TV Week to submit a per-copy price bid for a TV Week Gold Coast Guide. The guide must provide information on four local and fourteen national channels, requiring a 48-page program book.

What is the minimum price TV Week can bid for the Gold Coast contract without losing money on it?

Reveal the solution

1 · Hobart

The base circulation and the guide's content don't change. The extra 20,000 copies require only the costs that rise when more copies are printed.

Which costs change?

Cost itemAvoidable or unavoidable?
EditorialUnavoidable
AdministrationUnavoidable
Composing computerUnavoidable
National program databaseUnavoidable
Local program databaseUnavoidable
Local printing: colour and cover plate productionUnavoidable
Local printing: B/W plate productionUnavoidable
Local printing: coated paperAvoidable
Local printing: newsprint paperAvoidable
Local printing: cover paperAvoidable
Local printing: bindingAvoidable
Local printing: deliveryAvoidable
Customer serviceUnavoidable

The plates have already been produced for the edition, and no new editorial, database, composing or customer-service work is required. Only paper, binding and delivery vary with the number of copies.

Cost per additional copy

ItemCalculationResult
Print storybook\(16/4\times\$0.012\)$0.048
Print program book\(48/4\times\$0.004\)$0.048
Print cover\(\$0.016\)$0.016
Binding\(\$0.019\)$0.019
Delivery\(\$0.013\)$0.013
Total$0.144
Cost per additional copy\(\$0.144\)

TV Week can offer a price as low as $0.144 per extra copy without reducing its profit. Any higher price adds to profit.

2 · Ballarat

The number of copies doesn't change. The decision changes only the number of black-and-white program-book pages, from 16 to 48.

Which costs change?

Cost itemAvoidable or unavoidable?
EditorialUnavoidable
AdministrationUnavoidable
Composing computerUnavoidable
National program databaseUnavoidable
Local program databaseUnavoidable
Local printing: colour and cover plate productionUnavoidable
Local printing: B/W plate productionAvoidable
Local printing: coated paperUnavoidable
Local printing: newsprint paperAvoidable
Local printing: cover paperUnavoidable
Local printing: bindingUnavoidable
Local printing: deliveryUnavoidable
Customer serviceUnavoidable

TV Week already pays for access to the national database, and the two local channels don't change. Circulation also stays at 84,000 copies. Only the plates and newsprint for the 32 additional program-book pages are avoidable.

Additional cost per copy

ItemCalculationResult
B/W plates\((48-16)\times\$108/84{,}000\)$0.04114
Print program book\((48-16)/4\times\$0.004\)$0.032
Total$0.07314
Required increase in price\(\$0.04114+\$0.032=\$0.07314\) per copy

TV Week must increase the original price by about $0.073 per copy to maintain its former profit.

3 · Gold Coast

Gold Coast is a new contract, so TV Week must count every cost it can avoid by not taking the contract.

Which costs change?

Cost itemAvoidable or unavoidable?
EditorialUnavoidable
AdministrationUnavoidable
Composing computerUnavoidable
National program databaseUnavoidable
Local program databaseAvoidable
Local printing: colour and cover plate productionAvoidable
Local printing: B/W plate productionAvoidable
Local printing: coated paperAvoidable
Local printing: newsprint paperAvoidable
Local printing: cover paperAvoidable
Local printing: bindingAvoidable
Local printing: deliveryAvoidable
Customer serviceAvoidable

The existing editorial, administration, computer and national-database costs don't change. TV Week has unused computer capacity, and it already pays for the national database. The local database, plates, paper, binding, delivery and customer service are specific to the new edition.

Minimum cost per copy

ItemCalculationResult
Local program database\(4\times\$1{,}800/(52\times48{,}000)\)$0.0029
Colour and cover plates\(20\times\$405/48{,}000\)$0.1688
B/W plates\(48\times\$108/48{,}000\)$0.1080
Print storybook\(16/4\times\$0.012\)$0.0480
Print program book\(48/4\times\$0.004\)$0.0480
Print cover\(\$0.016\)$0.0160
Binding\(\$0.019\)$0.0190
Delivery\(\$0.013\)$0.0130
Customer service\(\$6{,}000/(52\times48{,}000)\)$0.0024
Total$0.4260
Minimum bid for the Gold Coast contract\(\$0.282+\$0.144=\$0.426\) per copy

TV Week can bid as low as about $0.426 per copy without losing money on the Gold Coast contract.

Concept atlas