Practice 02 · Week 01
The Chef
What did the restaurant really cost Daniel?
A year later
A year after opening his restaurant, Daniel sat down with a stack of receipts and a question he couldn't quite answer: what had the restaurant really cost him?
Daniel was a young chef in the bustling heart of Sydney. He was a wizard in the kitchen, but his experience with economic decision-making was limited, to say the least. A year earlier, full of enthusiasm, he had left a job that paid him $28,000 a year with no additional benefits and set out to open a restaurant of his own. His accountant had assured him that his income from the restaurant would be taxed at the same rate as his old salary.
Setting up
To equip the kitchen, Daniel cashed in a $5,000 term deposit that had been earning 5% interest a year and spent the money on essential equipment. A year of heavy use took its toll: by the end of the year, the equipment was worn out and had no resale value.
For the premises, he converted a small building owned by his wife. Until then, she had been renting it out for $1,000 a month.
The first year
Once the restaurant opened, the bills piled up quickly. Over the year, Daniel spent $50,000 on high-quality ingredients, $40,000 on a small but capable staff and $4,000 on utilities. Outside the restaurant, his life went on much as before, and his personal expenses didn't change.
Daniel knew how to add up his revenue. What he wasn't sure about was how to account for everything the restaurant had cost him.
Exhibit 1 · Key figures (AUD)
| Item | Amount |
|---|---|
| Before opening | |
| Salary in previous job | $28,000 per year |
| Term deposit | $5,000 at 5% per year |
| Rent from wife's building | $1,000 per month |
| First year of operation | |
| Equipment (paid from term deposit) | $5,000 |
| Resale value of equipment after one year | $0 |
| Ingredients | $50,000 |
| Staff | $40,000 |
| Utilities | $4,000 |
Question
What were the economic costs of running Daniel's restaurant for its first year?
Reveal the solution
Daniel's restaurant income is taxed at the same rate as his old salary, so we can compare everything before tax. His personal expenses didn't change, so the only costs that matter are those connected to the restaurant. The equipment had no resale value after one year.
The approach
Economic cost asks what Daniel gave up by running the restaurant for a year instead of carrying on as before. We go through each resource the restaurant used, ask whether it was avoidable and value it at its opportunity cost.
Daniel's time
By running the restaurant, Daniel gave up the $28,000 salary from his previous job. He never writes a check for it, but it's a real cost: it's the income he would have had without the restaurant.
The term deposit
Daniel cashed in his $5,000 term deposit to buy equipment. Had he left it alone, it would have earned 5% interest, or $250 over the year. That forgone interest is an opportunity cost.
The equipment
The $5,000 spent on equipment is a cost because, as the case points out, the equipment is worth nothing at the end of the year. If Daniel could sell it for, say, $2,000, the cost would be only $3,000. We count the $5,000 once, as equipment. The term deposit contributes only the $250 of interest it would have earned, not its $5,000 principal. Counting both would be double counting.
The building
Before the restaurant, Daniel's wife rented the building out for $1,000 a month. Using it for the restaurant means giving up $12,000 in rent over the year. Although no one pays rent, the building has an opportunity cost. We treat Daniel and his wife as one household, so her forgone rent is a cost of the restaurant.
Ingredients, staff and utilities
These are ordinary cash expenses, and all of them are avoidable: without the restaurant, Daniel wouldn't pay them.
Economic cost of running the restaurant for one year
| Item | Type | Amount |
|---|---|---|
| Forgone salary | Opportunity cost | $28,000 |
| Forgone interest on term deposit | Opportunity cost | $250 |
| Forgone rent on building | Opportunity cost | $12,000 |
| Equipment | Cash expense | $5,000 |
| Ingredients | Cash expense | $50,000 |
| Staff | Cash expense | $40,000 |
| Utilities | Cash expense | $4,000 |
| Total economic cost | $139,250 |
Accounting cost and economic cost
Daniel's accounts would show only the cash expenses: $99,000. Economic cost is $40,250 higher because it includes the salary, interest and rent he gave up. If his revenue for the year was between $99,000 and $139,250, his books would show a profit even though he'd have been better off keeping his old job.