Week 4: In-class

U-Strap: The Importance of Being Elastic

U-Strap makes strapping and bundling materials. Its industrial rubber-band division is a monopolist. A few years ago, the division commissioned a market study, which estimated quarterly demand as

Original demand estimate\(Q^d(p)=15{,}000-10p\)

where \(Q^d\) is the number of boxes sold in a quarter and \(p\) is the price per box in dollars.

Question 1

Find the elasticity of demand at a price of $1,200. What is U-Strap's marginal revenue at that point? Why is it less than $1,200?

Reveal the solution

At \(p=1{,}200\), quantity is \(15{,}000-12{,}000=3{,}000\), and \(dQ/dp=-10\).

Elasticity\(\varepsilon\)\(=\)\(-10\times\dfrac{1{,}200}{3{,}000}\)\(=\)\(-4\)
Marginal revenue\(MR\)\(=\)\(1{,}200\left(1-\dfrac14\right)\)\(=\)\(900\)

To sell one more box, U-Strap must lower the price, and with one price for all customers it lowers it on every box. Marginal revenue is the price of the extra box minus that discount on the other 3,000.

Question 2

Now find the elasticity at a quantity of 10,000. What is marginal revenue there?

Reveal the solution

At \(Q=10{,}000\), the price is \(p=(15{,}000-10{,}000)/10=500\).

Elasticity\(\varepsilon\)\(=\)\(-10\times\dfrac{500}{10{,}000}\)\(=\)\(-0.5\)
Marginal revenue\(MR\)\(=\)\(500\left(1-\dfrac{1}{0.5}\right)\)\(=\)\(-500\)

Demand is inelastic here, so selling more lowers revenue. A profit-maximizing monopolist never operates at this point.

Question 3

A new study revises the demand estimate to \(Q^d(p)=27{,}000-20p\). The point \(p=1{,}200\), \(Q=3{,}000\) also lies on this curve. What is the elasticity there? Why does it differ from your answer to Question 1?

Reveal the solution
Elasticity\(\varepsilon\)\(=\)\(-20\times\dfrac{1{,}200}{3{,}000}\)\(=\)\(-8\)

Both curves pass through the same price and quantity, so \(p/Q\) is the same. The new curve is flatter: each dollar of price change moves quantity by 20 boxes instead of 10. At the same point, a flatter demand curve is more elastic.

Question 4

Marginal cost is known to be constant at $1,000. At the current price of $1,200, should U-Strap increase or decrease production? What is the elasticity of demand at the profit-maximizing output?

Reveal the solution

The answer depends on which estimate is right. Under the original estimate, \(MR=900<1{,}000\), so U-Strap should produce less. Under the revised estimate,

Marginal revenue\(MR\)\(=\)\(1{,}200\left(1-\dfrac18\right)\)\(=\)\(1{,}050\)

which is above the marginal cost of 1,000, so U-Strap should produce more. A better demand estimate reverses the recommendation.

With the revised demand, inverse demand is \(p(Q)=1{,}350-Q/20\) and \(MR(Q)=1{,}350-Q/10\).

Optimum\(1{,}350-\dfrac{Q}{10}\)\(=\)\(1{,}000\)\(Q^m\)\(=\)\(3{,}500\)\(p^m\)\(=\)\(1{,}350-\dfrac{3{,}500}{20}\)\(=\)\(1{,}175\)
Elasticity at the optimum\(\varepsilon\)\(=\)\(-20\times\dfrac{1{,}175}{3{,}500}\)\(=\)\(-\dfrac{47}{7}\approx-6.71\)

Check with the markup rule: \((1{,}175-1{,}000)/1{,}175=7/47\), which equals \(-1/\varepsilon\).

Concept atlas