Week 4: Practice

A Sweet Treat

In 1948 soft-serve ice cream was new, and only a handful of firms sold it. The industry rested on a patented technology: a freezer that dispenses the ice cream. Each machine cost $120,000, which annualizes to $12,000 a year or $1,000 a month. Once bought, a machine has no resale value, because almost nobody else wants one.

In Healesville, Victoria, a shop rents for $2,000 a month, and the lease can be ended at any time without penalty. Each cone costs 40 cents in materials and labor. Because the machine dispenses slowly, one outlet can serve at most 20,000 cones a month.

Question 1

The only ice cream store in Healesville operates under the Dairy King franchise. On top of the costs above, it pays Dairy King Inc. a franchise fee of 10 cents for every cone it serves. Monthly demand for soft serve in Healesville is

Demand\(Q^d(p)=30{,}000-10{,}000p\)

What price should the store charge, and how many cones will it sell? What is the franchisee's profit?

Reveal the solution

First identify the economic cost. The machine has already been bought and can't be resold, so its cost is sunk and doesn't affect any decision now. The rent can be avoided by ending the lease. The ingredients, labor and franchise fee are paid per cone. So

Monthly economic cost\(C(Q)\)\(=\)\(2{,}000+0.4Q+0.1Q\)\(=\)\(2{,}000+0.5Q\)

and \(MC=0.5\). The store is the town's only seller, so it chooses output with \(MR=MC\). Inverse demand is \(p(Q)=3-Q/10{,}000\), so \(MR(Q)=3-Q/5{,}000\).

Monopoly output and price\(3-\dfrac{Q}{5{,}000}\)\(=\)\(0.5\)\(Q^m\)\(=\)\(12{,}500\)\(p^m\)\(=\)\(3-\dfrac{12{,}500}{10{,}000}\)\(=\)\(1.75\)

The capacity of 20,000 cones doesn't bind.

Monthly economic profit\(\pi^m\)\(=\)\(1.75\times12{,}500-(2{,}000+0.5\times12{,}500)\)\(=\)\(21{,}875-8{,}250\)\(=\)\(13{,}625\)

The store charges $1.75 a cone, sells 12,500 cones a month and earns $13,625 above its avoidable costs. Subtracting the sunk machine cost of $1,000 a month gives an accounting profit of $12,625, but that number doesn't change the pricing decision.

Concept atlas