Week 3: Practice

Sweet Subsidies (continued)

Recall from Week 2. Twenty sugar cane plantations can each produce up to 5 pounds of sugar a day, at $0.05 a pound. One hundred sugar beet farms each have the daily cost function

One beet farm\(C(q)=q^2-0.9q+1\)

where \(q\) is pounds of sugar per day. The government pays beet farmers a subsidy of $1 for every pound they produce.

The industry supply derived in Week 2 is

Sugar industry\(Q^s(p)=\begin{cases}0&p<0.05\\ [0,100]&p=0.05\\ 100&0.05<p<0.10\\ \{100,101,\ldots,200\}&p=0.10\\ 50p+195&p>0.10.\end{cases}\)

Question 2

Daily demand for sugar in the United States is

Daily demand\(Q^d(p)=109-100p\)

where \(p\) is the price of a pound of sugar in dollars. What is the market price of sugar? What profits do cane plantations and beet farms earn? How much does the subsidy program cost the government each day?

Reveal the solution

From Week 2, market supply is

Sugar industry\(Q^s(p)=\begin{cases}0&p<0.05,\\ \text{anything from }0\text{ to }100&p=0.05,\\ 100&0.05<p<0.10,\\ \text{anything from }100\text{ to }200&p=0.10,\\ 50p+195&p>0.10.\end{cases}\)

First find which piece demand crosses. At $0.05, buyers want \(109-5=104\) pounds, more than the 100 the plantations can supply, so the price must be above $0.05. At $0.10, buyers want \(109-10=99\) pounds, less than 100, so the price must be below $0.10. Between those prices, supply is fixed at 100 pounds, so the price is wherever buyers want exactly 100:

Competitive equilibrium\(109-100p\)\(=\)\(100\)\(p^e\)\(=\)\(0.09\)

The plantations sell 100 pounds at $0.09, against a cost of $0.05 a pound. Their total profit is \(100\times(0.09-0.05)=\$4\) a day, or $0.20 for each plantation. The price is below the beet farms' shutdown threshold of $0.10, so they produce nothing. Their costs are avoidable, so they earn zero profit, and the subsidy program costs the government nothing.

Question 3

Now suppose demand for sugar rises to

Higher daily demand\(Q^d(p)=240-100p\)

What is the new market price? How do the profits of cane plantations and beet farms change? How much does the subsidy program cost the government each day now?

Reveal the solution

At $0.10, buyers now want \(240-10=230\) pounds, more than the 200 that the market can supply at that price. So the price is above $0.10, where supply is \(50p+195\):

Competitive equilibrium\(240-100p\)\(=\)\(50p+195\)\(45\)\(=\)\(150p\)\(p^e\)\(=\)\(0.30\)\(Q^e\)\(=\)\(240-100\times0.30=210\)

Cane plantations sell 100 pounds at $0.30, at a cost of $0.05 a pound. Their total profit is \(100\times(0.30-0.05)=\$25\) a day.

Beet farms supply the remaining 110 pounds. Each grows \((0.30+1.9)/2=1.1\) pounds. Using the cost after the subsidy, as in Week 2:

One beet farm\(C(1.1)\)\(=\)\(1.1^2-1.9\times1.1+1\)\(=\)\(1.21-2.09+1=0.12\)

Each farm's revenue is \(0.30\times1.1=\$0.33\), so its profit is \(0.33-0.12=\$0.21\) a day. Across all 100 farms, that's $21 a day.

The subsidy is $1 on each of 110 pounds, so it costs the government $110 a day. The program costs $110 a day, and beet farmers' total profit is $21.

Concept atlas