Week 3: Practice

Flexodide Industry (continued)

Recall from Week 2. Annual demand for flexodide is

Market demand\(Q^d(p)=390{,}000-100p\)

There are 200 existing mines. Each can produce at most 1,000 tonnes a year, has a fixed operating cost of $500,000, a variable cost of $150 per tonne and a production tax of $100 per tonne. Each mine therefore supplies its full capacity when the price is above $750 per tonne.

Question 3

What are the short-run equilibrium price and quantity in the flexodide market?

Reveal the solution

From Week 2, each of the 200 mines produces 1,000 tonnes at any price above $750, so market supply is 200,000 tonnes at any price above $750. At $750, buyers want \(390{,}000-100\times750=315{,}000\) tonnes, more than the mines can supply, so the price must be higher. Above $750, supply is fixed at 200,000:

Short-run equilibrium\(390{,}000-100p\)\(=\)\(200{,}000\)\(p^e\)\(=\)\(1{,}900\)\(Q^e\)\(=\)\(200{,}000\)

Each mine earns \((1{,}900-750)\times1{,}000=\$1{,}150{,}000\) a year. Profits that large invite exploration, which is where Entry phase 1 begins.

Entry phase 1

Guaranteed discoveries

Many companies are considering exploring for new flexodide deposits. A new mine would have the same costs and the same production capacity as the existing ones. The Geological Studies Department of Fitzroy estimates that each exploration requires an upfront investment equivalent to $50,000 a year, paid for as long as the mine operates. Every exploration is guaranteed to find a new deposit.

Question 4

What is the long-run market supply of flexodide?

Reveal the solution

A new mine pays everything an existing mine pays, plus $50,000 a year for exploration:

New mine\(C(q)\)\(=\)\(500{,}000+50{,}000+250q\)\(=\)\(550{,}000+250q\)

Its average cost at capacity is \(550+250=\$800\) a tonne. The long-run supply has three parts. Below $750, nobody produces. Between $750 and $800, only the 200 original mines produce, supplying 200,000 tonnes. At $800, new mines can enter freely, so the industry can supply any amount from 200,000 tonnes upward, in steps of 1,000 tonnes. Long-run supply is flat at $800 once the original mines are at capacity.

Question 5

How many new mines will open?

Reveal the solution

At $800, buyers want \(390{,}000-100\times800=310{,}000\) tonnes. The original mines supply 200,000, so new mines supply 110,000. At 1,000 tonnes each, that's 110 new mines.

Question 6

What will the long-run equilibrium price be?

Reveal the solution

The long-run price is $800. At any higher price, more mines would enter. New mines earn exactly zero economic profit at $800.

Question 7

What profit will each of the original 200 mines earn?

Reveal the solution

Each original mine earns \((800-750)\times1{,}000=\$50{,}000\) a year. The original owners keep a profit because they got their deposits without paying for exploration, and newcomers can't get that advantage.

Entry phase 2

Tax reform and uncertain discoveries

Years pass. Demand for flexodide and its production costs stay the same, so the industry remains in its long-run equilibrium from Entry phase 1. Then a new, pro-market government abolishes the tax on flexodide production.

At the same time, the Geological Studies Department reports that deposits are becoming scarce. Exploration still costs the equivalent of $50,000 a year, but now only half of all explorations find a deposit. Potential entrants still aim to maximize profit.

Question 8

What is the lowest price at which anyone will explore for flexodide?

Reveal the solution

Without the $100-a-tonne tax, every mine's cost falls by $100 a tonne. Average cost at capacity becomes $650 for an original mine and $700 for an Entry-phase-1 mine.

An explorer pays $50,000 a year whether or not it finds a deposit. With probability \(1/2\), it finds one and earns \((p-650)\times1{,}000\) from the mine. With probability \(1/2\), it finds nothing. Its expected profit is

Expected exploration profit\(E[\pi_e]=\dfrac12(p-650)\times1{,}000-50{,}000\)

This is zero at \(p=750\) and negative below it. So nobody explores at prices below $750.

Question 9

Will any new mines open? If so, how many?

Reveal the solution

Before anyone new explores, the 310 existing mines supply 310,000 tonnes at any price above $700. Buyers want exactly 310,000 at $800, so the tax cut alone leaves the price at $800 and raises existing mines' profits.

At $800, an explorer's expected profit is \(\tfrac12\times150\times1{,}000-50{,}000=\$25{,}000>0\), so exploration starts. It continues until the price falls to $750. At $750, buyers want 315,000 tonnes, which is 5,000 more than existing mines supply. So five new mines open. Since only half of all explorations succeed, it takes about ten explorations on average to find them.

Question 10

What profits do existing mine owners earn now? Note that there are two kinds of existing owners: those who held the original deposits, and those who found new deposits in Entry phase 1.

Reveal the solution

At $750, original mines earn \((750-650)\times1{,}000=\$100{,}000\) a year, up from $50,000. Entry-phase-1 mines earn \((750-700)\times1{,}000=\$50{,}000\) a year, up from zero.

The tax cut benefits existing owners because the price falls by less than their costs do.

Question 11

Is the price you found in Question 8 a long-run equilibrium? Explain your answer in detail.

Reveal the solution

Yes, $750 is a long-run equilibrium. Three things hold there. The market clears at 315,000 tonnes. Further exploration has an expected profit of exactly zero, so nobody else enters. Every existing mine earns a positive profit, so nobody leaves.

Two points are worth noting. First, a lucky explorer that finds a deposit ends up with a mine that earns $50,000 a year, while an unlucky one loses $50,000 a year. On average, exploring earns zero, which is what stops entry.

Second, the tax cut lowered costs by $100 a tonne, but the price fell by only $50. Exploration got riskier. An entrant now pays, on average, $100,000 a year in exploration for each mine it finds, or $100 a tonne, instead of $50. That rise of $50 a tonne offsets half the tax cut.

Concept atlas