Week 3: Practice

Banana Republic (continued)

Recall from Week 2. There are 100 identical banana farmers. Each farmer has weekly cost

One farmer\(C(q)=q^2+5q+36\)

and weekly market demand is

Market demand\(Q^d(p)=1{,}250-10p\)

where quantity is measured in pounds and price is dollars per pound. One old-technology farmer supplies zero below $17 and \((p-5)/2\) above $17.

Part I

Short run (continued)

Question 3

What are the short-run equilibrium price and quantity in the banana market?

Reveal the solution

From Week 2, market supply is

Banana market\(Q^s(p)=\begin{cases}0&p<17,\\ \text{any multiple of }6\text{ up to }600&p=17,\\ 50p-250&p>17,\end{cases}\)

and market demand is \(Q^d(p)=1{,}250-10p\). At $17, buyers want 1,080 pounds, more than 600, so the price is above $17:

Short-run equilibrium\(50p-250\)\(=\)\(1{,}250-10p\)\(60p\)\(=\)\(1{,}500\)\(p^e\)\(=\)\(25\)\(Q^e\)\(=\)\(1{,}250-10\times25=1{,}000\)

Question 4

What is one farmer’s short-run economic profit?

Reveal the solution

Each of the 100 farmers produces \(1{,}000/100=10\) pounds. Equivalently, from \(p=MC\), \(25=2q+5\), so \(q=10\). Profit is

One farmer\(\pi\)\(=\)\(25\times10-(10^2+5\times10+36)\)\(=\)\(250-186\)\(=\)\(\$64\text{ a week}\)

Part II

Long run with identical farms

New entrepreneurs can easily enter the banana market, and they would have the same costs as the existing 100 farmers. All costs of production are avoidable every week.

Question 5

What are the long-run equilibrium price and quantity?

Reveal the solution

Entrants have the same costs, and all costs are avoidable weekly. So farmers keep entering until the price falls to the lowest average cost, $17. At that price, buyers want \(1{,}250-10\times17=1{,}080\) pounds. The long-run equilibrium is a price of $17 and a quantity of 1,080.

Question 6

How many farmers will be in the market in the long run?

Reveal the solution

At $17, each farmer produces 6 pounds, at the lowest point of average cost. So the market has \(1{,}080/6=180\) farmers, which means eighty more than in the short run.

Part III

Long run with different technologies

An entrepreneur, Manny Plantaino, develops an innovation that gives him a cost advantage in growing bananas. His weekly cost function is

Manny Plantaino\(C_M(q)=\dfrac{1}{40}q^2+5q+250\)

No one else can use his innovation.

Question 7

What is the long-run market supply of bananas now?

Reveal the solution

Manny's average and marginal costs are

Manny's costs\(AC_M(q)=\dfrac{q}{40}+5+\dfrac{250}{q},\qquad MC_M(q)=\dfrac{q}{20}+5\)

Average cost is lowest where it equals marginal cost:

Minimum average cost\(\dfrac{q}{20}+5\)\(=\)\(\dfrac{q}{40}+5+\dfrac{250}{q}\)\(\dfrac{q}{40}\)\(=\)\(\dfrac{250}{q}\)\(q^2\)\(=\)\(10{,}000\)\(q\)\(=\)\(100\)

At that output, \(AC_M(100)=2.5+5+2.5=10\). Setting \(p=MC_M\) gives Manny's supply: \(q_M^s(p)=20p-100\) for \(p\geq10\), and zero below $10.

Old-technology farmers enter freely at $17. So long-run market supply is nothing below $10. Manny supplies \(20p-100\) between $10 and $17. At $17, Manny supplies 240 pounds and old-technology farmers can supply any additional quantity in 6-pound blocks.

Question 8

What are the long-run equilibrium price and quantity?

Reveal the solution

For prices between $10 and $17, buyers want between 1,080 and 1,150 pounds, but Manny alone supplies at most 240. Demand outstrips what Manny can offer, so the price rises to $17, where old-technology farmers enter.

The long-run equilibrium is a price of $17 and a quantity of 1,080. Manny supplies 240 pounds, and old-technology farmers supply the other 840.

Question 9

What profit does Manny Plantaino earn, and what profit do the farmers using the old technology earn? How many old-technology farmers remain in the market in the long run? Briefly discuss what you find.

Reveal the solution

Manny's profit is

Manny's profit\(\pi_M\)\(=\)\(17\times240-\left(\dfrac{240^2}{40}+5\times240+250\right)\)\(=\)\(4{,}080-2{,}890\)\(=\)\(\$1{,}190\text{ a week}\)

Old-technology farmers earn zero, since $17 is their lowest average cost. They supply 840 pounds at 6 each, so 140 old-technology farmers remain. Forty of the 180 leave.

Manny keeps his profit in the long run because no one can copy his innovation, just like the island farms in Reading 5. The price is still set by the old technology, which is needed to meet demand. So buyers pay the same $17 as before, and the whole benefit of the innovation goes to Manny.

Concept atlas