Week 3: In-class

Orange Farming on Portakal

Demand for oranges on Portakal is \(Q^d(p)=3{,}100-100p\). Each island farm has cost \(C_I(q)=100+q+q^2\), with minimum average cost of 21 at \(q=10\). Land and regulation allow no more than fifty island farms.

Question 1

Show that the fifty-farm cap binds. Then find the competitive equilibrium with only island farms and calculate one farm's economic profit.

Reveal the solution

With free entry by identical island farms, the long-run price would be 21. Demand at that price is \(3{,}100-100\times21=1{,}000\). Since each farm produces ten, the market would need 100 farms. The cap of fifty therefore binds.

Above 21, one farm supplies \((p-1)/2\), so fifty farms supply \(25p-25\). Equilibrium is

Capped equilibrium\(3{,}100-100p\)\(=\)\(25p-25\)\(p^e\)\(=\)\(25\)\(Q^e\)\(=\)\(600\)

Each farm produces twelve. Its profit is

Island farm profit\(\pi_I\)\(=\)\(25\times12-[100+12+12^2]\)\(=\)\(44\)

Question 2

Mainland farms may now ship oranges to Portakal. They have cost \(C_M(q)=100+3q+q^2\) and free entry. Find the new long-run price, market quantity, island output, mainland output and number of mainland farms.

Reveal the solution

A mainland farm's minimum average cost is 23 at an output of ten. Free mainland entry therefore pins the long-run price at 23.

Demand at 23 is 800. Each island farm sets \(23=1+2q\), so it produces eleven. Fifty island farms supply 550. Mainland farms supply the remaining \(800-550=250\). Each produces ten, so twenty-five mainland farms enter.

Long-run allocation\(p^e\)\(=\)\(23\)\(Q^e\)\(=\)\(800\)\(Q_I^e\)\(=\)\(550\)\(Q_M^e\)\(=\)\(250\)\(n_M^e\)\(=\)\(25\)

Question 3

Calculate the profit of an island farm and a mainland farm in Question 2. Why can their profits differ in a competitive equilibrium?

Reveal the solution

A mainland farm produces ten at its minimum average cost of 23, so its economic profit is zero.

An island farm produces eleven and earns

Island farm profit\(\pi_I\)\(=\)\(23\times11-[100+11+11^2]\)\(=\)\(253-232\)\(=\)\(21\)

Both types take the same market price as given. Their profits differ because island farms have a cost advantage: they don't pay the $2 transportation cost. Free entry removes profit for the marginal mainland technology, but entrants cannot copy the scarce low-cost island location.

Concept atlas