Week 3: In-class

Auto Eco Market Equilibrium

From the short run to the long run

There are initially ten identical Auto Eco firms. Each firm has the monthly economic cost function

One firm\(C(q)=80+10q+5q^2\)

where \(q\) is measured in hundreds of vehicles and price and cost per vehicle are in thousands of dollars. The firm's shutdown threshold is $50,000 and, above it, its supply is \(q^s(p)=(p-10)/10\).

Monthly market demand is

Market demand\(Q^d(p)=170-p\)

Question 1

Find the short-run competitive equilibrium. How much does each firm produce? Calculate one firm's economic profit.

Reveal the solution

With ten identical firms, market supply above the threshold is

Market supply\(Q^s(p)\)\(=\)\(10\left(\dfrac{p-10}{10}\right)\)\(=\)\(p-10\)

Set demand equal to supply:

Short-run equilibrium\(170-p\)\(=\)\(p-10\)\(180\)\(=\)\(2p\)\(p^e\)\(=\)\(90\)\(Q^e\)\(=\)\(80\)

Each firm produces \(80/10=8\), or 800 vehicles. Its economic profit is

One firm's profit\(\pi\)\(=\)\(90\times8-[80+10\times8+5\times8^2]\)\(=\)\(720-480\)\(=\)\(240\)

In the units of the model, this is $24 million per month.

Question 2

Suppose the current price is $70,000 rather than the equilibrium price. Calculate excess demand or excess supply. Explain why the price changes and what happens to quantity demanded and quantity supplied during the adjustment.

Reveal the solution

At \(p=70\), buyers demand \(170-70=100\), while firms supply \(70-10=60\). Excess demand is \(100-60=40\), or 4,000 vehicles.

Some buyers cannot carry out their plans. Competition for the available vehicles and sellers' recognition that they can charge more create upward pressure on price. As price rises, quantity demanded falls along the demand curve and quantity supplied rises along the supply curve. The adjustment stops at \(p=90\), where both quantities are 80.

Question 3

Demand permanently increases to \(Q^d_1(p)=210-p\). Find the new short-run equilibrium and one firm's profit. Then allow free entry by firms with the same technology. Find the long-run price, market quantity and number of firms.

Reveal the solution

In the short run, the number of firms stays at ten:

New short-run equilibrium\(210-p\)\(=\)\(p-10\)\(p^e_{SR}\)\(=\)\(110\)\(Q^e_{SR}\)\(=\)\(100\)

Each firm produces ten. Its profit is

Short-run profit\(\pi_{SR}\)\(=\)\(110\times10-[80+10\times10+5\times10^2]\)\(=\)\(1{,}100-680\)\(=\)\(420\)

Positive profit attracts entry. With identical firms and free entry, the long-run price is minimum average cost, 50, and each firm produces four. At that price, market demand is \(210-50=160\). The number of firms is \(160/4=40\).

The permanent demand increase raises price and incumbent profit in the short run. In the long run it increases market quantity and the number of firms, while price returns to 50 and economic profit returns to zero.

Question 4

Suppose the stronger demand in Question 3 is temporary and will return to its original level next month. Would you expect the same entry response? Explain.

Reveal the solution

No. Entry compares the future profit stream with the economic cost of committing resources to the industry. A one-month profit opportunity may be too short to recover entry costs or justify moving resources from their next-best use.

Existing firms still expand output in the current month because they can do so with their existing plants. The difference is the horizon: temporary demand can produce a short-run price and profit increase without changing the long-run number of firms.

Concept atlas