Week 2: Practice

The Rock Collector

Every morning, Ethan chooses between working as a contract consultant for his former employer at $300 per day and collecting rocks to sell to landscape artists. His former employer has enough contract work to employ him every day of the year.

If Ethan collects rocks, he pays a daily fixed fee of $12.50 for exclusive access to his preferred area and the necessary equipment. Transporting each additional rock becomes more expensive. His average variable cost per rock is

Average variable cost\(AVC(q)=2.5+0.005q\)

where \(q\) is the number of rocks he collects that day.

Question 1

Ethan wakes up and finds that the wholesale price is $7 per rock. He is a price taker and cannot influence this price. How many rocks should he collect, if any? Calculate his economic profit for the day.

Reveal the solution

First find the profit-maximizing output. Then check whether the revenue from that output covers all avoidable costs, including the income Ethan gives up by not consulting.

The fixed cost of collecting rocks is the $300 opportunity cost of not consulting plus the $12.50 access fee, so \(FC=312.50\).

We can also find the variable cost by multiplying average variable cost by output:

Variable cost\(VC(q)\)\(=\)\(AVC(q)\times q\)\(=\)\((2.5+0.005q)\times q\)\(=\)\(2.5q+0.005q^2\)

Adding \(FC\) and \(VC(q)\), we find the total cost:

Total cost\(C(q)=312.50+2.5q+0.005q^2\)

The marginal-cost function is derived from this total-cost function:

Marginal cost\(MC(q)=2.5+0.01q\)

The entry threshold is the minimum average cost. Set \(MC(q)=AC(q)\):

Threshold output\(2.5+0.01q\)\(=\)\(\dfrac{312.50}{q}+2.5+0.005q\)\(0.005q^2\)\(=\)\(312.50\)\(q\)\(=\)\(250\)

At this output, average cost is

Minimum average cost\(AC(250)\)\(=\)\(\dfrac{312.50}{250}+2.5+0.005\times250\)\(=\)\(1.25+2.5+1.25\)\(=\)\(5\)\(\min AC\)\(=\)\(AC(250)=5\)

Above this threshold, set price equal to marginal cost: \(p=2.5+0.01q\), so \(q=100p-250\). Ethan's supply is

Supply of rocks\(q^s(p)=\begin{cases}0&p<5,\\ \{0,250\}&p=5,\\ 100p-250&p>5.\end{cases}\)

Since \(7>5=\min AC\), Ethan collects rocks. At \(p=7\), his profit-maximizing output is \(q^s(7)=450\). His economic profit is

Economic profit\(\pi\)\(=\)\(7\times450-[312.50+2.5\times450+0.005\times450^2]\)\(=\)\(\$700\)

Question 2

On the following day, the wholesale price falls to $4.99 per rock. How many rocks should Ethan collect, if any? Calculate his economic profit for the day.

Reveal the solution

The price of $4.99 is below the $5 entry threshold. Ethan collects no rocks and doesn't pay the access fee or any variable cost. His opportunity cost is $300 since he can work as a consultant and earn $300.

Therefore, his economic profit from collecting rocks is \(-\$300\).

Question 3

Suppose the wholesale price returns to $7 per rock and is expected to remain there indefinitely. The access fee has changed. Instead of paying $12.50 each day, Ethan must pay a nonrefundable annual fee of $3,125 on the first day of the year. This is roughly the daily fee multiplied by 250 workdays. How many rocks should Ethan collect on the first day? Calculate his economic profit for that day.

Reveal the solution

Ethan makes the annual participation decision before paying the fee. Over 250 workdays, the $3,125 annual charge is equivalent to $12.50 per day. The analysis in Question 1 is unchanged.

He collects 450 rocks on the first day and on every other workday while the price remains $7. Allocating the annual fee across 250 workdays gives economic profit of $700 per day, or $175,000 for the year.

Question 4

On the final morning of the year, after Ethan has already paid the annual access fee, the wholesale price unexpectedly falls to $4.99 per rock. How many rocks should he collect that day? Calculate his economic profit for the day.

Reveal the solution

The annual fee has already been paid, so it is unavoidable and doesn't enter today's decision. The relevant daily cost is

Relevant daily cost\(C(q)\)\(=\)\(300+2.5q+0.005q^2\)\(AC(q)\)\(=\)\(\dfrac{300}{q}+2.5+0.005q\)

Setting \(MC=AC\) gives \(0.005q^2=300\), so the new threshold output is \(q=\sqrt{60{,}000}\approx244.95\), and minimum average cost is about $4.949. Since $4.99 exceeds this threshold, Ethan collects rocks.

Set price equal to marginal cost: \(4.99=2.5+0.01q\). He collects 249 rocks. His economic profit for the day is

Economic profit\(\pi\)\(=\)\(4.99\times249-[300+2.5\times249+0.005\times249^2]\)\(\approx\)\(\$10.01\)

Question 5

Why does the answer to Question 2 differ from the answer to Question 4?

Reveal the solution

In Question 2, the daily access fee is avoidable. Ethan pays it only if he chooses to collect rocks. In Question 4, the annual access fee has already been paid and is unavoidable. It is a sunk cost for the final day's decision, so it doesn't affect whether Ethan collects rocks that day.

Question 6

Suppose the price drop in Question 4 occurs on the second day of the year rather than the final day. How does this change Ethan's response?

Reveal the solution

It doesn't change his response for that day. Once Ethan has paid the annual charge, it is unavoidable on the second day just as it is on the final day. He collects 249 rocks when the price is $4.99. If the lower price is expected to persist, it may affect whether he pays the annual fee again next year, but it doesn't change the current year's unavoidable fee.

Concept atlas