Week 2: Practice

Sweet Subsidies

In the United States, sugar production relies on two crops: sugar cane and sugar beet.

Sugar cane can be grown only in a few regions, primarily Hawaii and Louisiana. There are twenty plantations that can grow sugar cane. Each plantation can produce at most 5 pounds of sugar per day at a cost of $0.05 per pound. There are no fixed costs, so marginal cost and average cost are both constant at $0.05 per pound.

There are also 100 potential sugar beet farms. The farms are identical. Each farm has a daily fixed cost of $1 and the following variable cost:

Variable cost\(VC(q)=q^2-0.9q\)

The government pays each sugar beet farmer a subsidy of $1 for every pound of sugar produced that day.

Question 1

What is the short-run supply of one sugar cane plantation? What is the short-run supply of one sugar beet farm? What is the industry supply of sugar?

Reveal the solution

Sugar cane

There is no fixed cost, so \(C_c(q)=0.05q\). Average cost and marginal cost are both constant:

Cane plantation costs\(AC_c(q)=MC_c(q)=0.05\)

Each plantation can produce at most 5 pounds per day. Below $0.05 it produces nothing. At exactly $0.05 it is indifferent among all quantities from 0 to 5. Above $0.05 it produces at capacity:

One cane plantation\(q_c^s(p)=\begin{cases}0&p<0.05,\\ [0,5]&p=0.05,\\ 5&p>0.05.\end{cases}\)
TikZ graph of one sugar cane plantation's supply, horizontal at a price of 0.05 up to five pounds and vertical at five pounds above that price
Supply of one sugar cane plantation.

There are twenty plantations, so their combined supply is

All cane plantations\(Q_c^s(p)=\begin{cases}0&p<0.05,\\ [0,100]&p=0.05,\\ 100&p>0.05.\end{cases}\)

Sugar beet

A beet farm has variable cost \(q^2-0.9q\), a fixed cost of $1 and a subsidy of $1 per pound. We can treat the subsidy as a reduction in the farm's cost:

Cost after the subsidy\(C_b(q)\)\(=\)\(q^2-0.9q+1-q\)\(C_b(q)\)\(=\)\(q^2-1.9q+1\)

Average cost and marginal cost are

Beet farm costs\(MC_b(q)\)\(=\)\(2q-1.9\)\(AC_b(q)\)\(=\)\(q-1.9+\dfrac{1}{q}\)

At the minimum of average cost, \(MC_b(q)=AC_b(q)\). This gives \(q^2=1\), so \(q=1\) and \(\min AC_b=AC_b(1)=0.10\). Above this threshold, setting \(p=MC_b(q)\) gives \(q=(p+1.9)/2\). The supply of one beet farm is

One beet farm\(q_b^s(p)=\begin{cases}0&p<0.10,\\ \{0,1\}&p=0.10,\\ \dfrac{p+1.9}{2}&p>0.10.\end{cases}\)
TikZ graph of one sugar beet farm's supply beginning at one pound and a price of 0.10 and rising with output
Supply of one sugar beet farm.

Adding the supplies of the 100 identical beet farms gives

All beet farms\(Q_b^s(p)=\begin{cases}0&p<0.10,\\ \{0,1,\cdots,100\}&p=0.10,\\ 50p+95&p>0.10.\end{cases}\)

Industry supply

Below $0.05, neither technology operates. At $0.05, the cane plantations can supply up to 100 pounds. Between $0.05 and $0.10, they supply 100 pounds while beet farms remain inactive. At $0.10, each beet farm chooses either zero or one pound. Above $0.10, beet output rises with price.

Sugar industry\(Q^s(p)=\begin{cases}0&p<0.05,\\ [0,100]&p=0.05,\\ 100&0.05<p<0.10,\\ \{100,101,\cdots,200\}&p=0.10,\\ 50p+195&p>0.10.\end{cases}\)

Concept atlas