Week 2: Assignment

Brewing up a Storm

The North Storm Brewing Company of Brunswick, Victoria produces high-quality ales in the Melbourne beer market. It is one of many brewers serving this market. The company must decide on technology for its newest ale, Harbor Seal Ale.

Building the first technology (technology 1) would cost North Storm $30,000. With this technology, the firm can produce each unit at a cost of $10 per unit (North Storm sells beers in special 4-packs); however, with this technology, North Storm would be limited to a capacity of 50,000 units.

The alternative technology (technology 2) would have an initial cost of $70,000, variable costs of

Variable cost\(VC(q)=8q+\frac{q^2}{20{,}000}\)

where \(q\) is the total number of units, and a capacity of no more than 100,000 units. With either technology, the investment would last for one year.

Since North Storm is small relative to the total market, they can sell their total output of Harbor Seal Ale at prevailing market prices. Market research suggests that the market will either be strong with a price of $18 per unit or weak with a price of $11 per unit.

Assume that the managers of North Storm Brewing observe the market price before deciding which technology to choose and how much beer to produce.

Question 1

Which technology should they choose in a weak market?

Reveal the solution

North Storm chooses its technology after observing the market price. So it should compare the profit from each technology at the weak-market price of $11.

Technology 1

The cost, average cost and capacity are

Technology 1\(C_1(q)\)\(=\)\(30{,}000+10q\)\(AC_1(q)\)\(=\)\(\dfrac{30{,}000}{q}+10\)\(q\)\(\leq\)\(50{,}000\)

Average cost decreases as output rises, so its minimum occurs at capacity:

Minimum average cost\(\min AC_1\)\(=\)\(AC_1(50{,}000)\)\(=\)\(\dfrac{30{,}000}{50{,}000}+10\)\(=\)\(10.60\)

Since $11 is above $10.60, Technology 1 is profitable. The firm produces at its capacity of 50,000 units:

Technology 1 profit\(\pi_1\)\(=\)\(11\times50{,}000-[30{,}000+10\times50{,}000]\)\(=\)\(20{,}000\)

Technology 2

For Technology 2, average cost and marginal cost are

Technology 2 costs\(AC_2(q)\)\(=\)\(\dfrac{70{,}000}{q}+8+\dfrac{q}{20{,}000}\)\(MC_2(q)\)\(=\)\(8+\dfrac{q}{10{,}000}\)

At the minimum of average cost, \(MC_2(q)=AC_2(q)\). This gives

Technology 2 threshold\(q^2\)\(=\)\(1{,}400{,}000{,}000\)\(q\)\(\approx\)\(37{,}416\)\(\min AC_2\)\(\approx\)\(11.75\)

The weak-market price of $11 is below this threshold, so Technology 2 isn't profitable. North Storm chooses Technology 1, produces 50,000 units and earns a profit of $20,000.

Question 2

Which technology should they choose in a strong market?

Reveal the solution

At the strong-market price of $18, both technologies are profitable. North Storm should compare their profits.

Technology 1

Since price exceeds the constant marginal cost of $10, the firm produces at its capacity of 50,000 units:

Technology 1 profit\(\pi_1\)\(=\)\(18\times50{,}000-[30{,}000+10\times50{,}000]\)\(=\)\(370{,}000\)

Technology 2

Set price equal to marginal cost to find the profit-maximizing output:

Technology 2 output\(18\)\(=\)\(8+\dfrac{q}{10{,}000}\)\(q\)\(=\)\(100{,}000\)

This is exactly the capacity of Technology 2. Its profit is

Technology 2 profit\(\pi_2\)\(=\)\(18\times100{,}000-\left[70{,}000+8\times100{,}000+\dfrac{100{,}000^2}{20{,}000}\right]\)\(=\)\(1{,}800{,}000-[70{,}000+800{,}000+500{,}000]\)\(=\)\(430{,}000\)

Technology 2 earns $60,000 more than Technology 1. North Storm chooses Technology 2, produces 100,000 units and earns a profit of $430,000.

Concept atlas