Managerial Economics · Week 4

Monopolistic markets

How does a firm act when it has market power?

1

Market power

What does it take to set price?

One seller, no close substitutes, a barrier to entry.

2

Monopoly

Three conditions

  1. A single seller.
  2. No close substitutes.
  3. A barrier that keeps rivals out.
3

Barriers to entry

How persistent is the position?

BarrierExamplesDurability
LegalPatents, licenses, exclusive contractsStrong, but the law can change
StructuralScarce inputs, natural monopolyLasts as long as the cost advantage
StrategicExcess capacity, threatsDepends on credibility (Week 8)
4

Market power

Who has market power?

Any firm that produces a unique product and solely dictates its demand dynamics.

5

The key difference

Price-taker and price-setter

Competitive firm

Faces a flat demand curve at the market price. Chooses quantity only.

given \(p\)
Monopolist

Faces the market demand curve. Chooses a price and quantity pair on it.

\(p=p(Q)\)
6

Main example

Ride On

Children's rides in a shopping mall

\(Q^d(p)=140-40p\) rides per day

\(C(Q)=40+0.5Q\)

Daily rental 40, cost per ride 0.5

7

Ride On

Inverse demand

\(\displaystyle \begin{aligned}Q&=140-40p\\ 40p&=140-Q\\ p(Q)&=3.5-\frac{Q}{40}\end{aligned}\)

If Ride On wants to sell \(Q\) rides, the price must be \(p(Q)\).

8

Marginal revenue

What does one more sale change?

Selling more means charging less on every unit.

9

Ride On

10

Dissect the change in revenue

11

From \(Q\) to \(Q+\Delta Q\) rides

Demand curve with three areas. A is the revenue lost on the first Q rides when the price falls from p to p plus delta p. B is revenue that stays the same. C is the revenue from the extra delta Q rides.
12

Marginal revenue

New revenue minus lost revenue

\(\displaystyle \begin{aligned}\Delta R&=C-A\\ C&=(p+\Delta p)\times\Delta Q&&\text{new revenue}\\ A&=-\Delta p\times Q&&\text{lost revenue}\end{aligned}\)
\(\displaystyle \begin{aligned}\frac{\Delta R}{\Delta Q}&=\frac{(p+\Delta p)\times\Delta Q-(-\Delta p\times Q)}{\Delta Q}\\ &=\frac{(p+\Delta p)\times\Delta Q+Q\times\Delta p}{\Delta Q}\\ &=p+\Delta p+Q\times\frac{\Delta p}{\Delta Q}\end{aligned}\)
13

Marginal revenue

When revenue is continuous

Changes can be infinitesimally small: \(dQ\) and \(dp\).

When \(dQ\searrow0\), \(dp\searrow0\)
\(\displaystyle MR(Q)=p(Q)+Q\times\frac{dp}{dQ}\)

\(p(Q)\): the price at which the extra unit sells

\(Q\times dp/dQ\): the discount on the units that were already selling

14

Linear demand

Same intercept, twice the slope

\(p(Q)=a-bQ\)
\(MR(Q)=a-2bQ\)
\(MR(Q)=3.5-\dfrac{Q}{20}\)

Ride On: \(MR=0\) at 70 rides, halfway to 140.

15

Monopoly pricing

16

Marginal comparison

Should Ride On run one more ride?

  1. \(MR>MC\): expand.
  2. \(MR\lt MC\): contract.
  3. \(MR=MC\): profit is at its peak.
17

Ride On

The monopoly solution

\(\displaystyle \begin{aligned}3.5-\frac{Q}{20}&=0.5\\ Q^m&=60\\ p^m&=3.5-\frac{60}{40}=2\end{aligned}\)
\(\displaystyle \begin{aligned}\pi&=2\times60-(40+0.5\times60)\\ &=50\end{aligned}\)
18

Check the neighbors

Profit peaks at 60 rides

RidesPriceRevenueCostProfit
402.50100.0060.0040.00
502.25112.5065.0047.50
602.00120.0070.0050.00
701.75122.5075.0047.50
801.50120.0080.0040.00

Revenue peaks at 70 rides, profit at 60. Maximizing revenue isn't maximizing profit.

19

Two things the answer says

Above cost, below the maximum

Price above marginal cost

Since \(MR\lt p\) and \(MR=MC\).

\(2>0.5\)
Not the highest price

At $3, Ride On sells 20 rides and earns 10.

\(\pi(20)=10<50\)
20

The mall raises the rental

Rent rises from $40 to $60

Demand and the cost per ride don't change.

What happens to Ride On's price?
21

Fixed costs

The price stays at $2

A cost that doesn't vary with output affects whether the firm operates, not how much it sells.

22

Marginal cost rises

A ride now costs $1 to run

\(\displaystyle \begin{aligned}3.5-\frac{Q}{20}&=1\\ Q^m&=50\\ p^m&=2.25\end{aligned}\)

Marginal cost rose by 50 cents; the price rose by 25 cents.

23

In-class exercise

Fenway hotdogs

\(Q^d(p)=55{,}000-10{,}000p\) per game

\(MC=1.50\), fixed cost 500

Find price, output and profit

Then: only 10,000 hotdogs; a $3 price cap

24

Welfare

What does monopoly cost?

Separate the transfer from the loss.

25

Surplus at market scale

Consumer and producer surplus

Consumer surplus

Below demand, above the price.

\(\sum (WTP-p)\)
Producer surplus

Above marginal cost, below the price.

\(PS=\pi+\text{fixed cost}\)
26

Ride On

Monopoly against the efficient outcome

MonopolyEfficient
Price2.000.50
Rides60120
Consumer surplus45180
Producer surplus900
Total surplus135180

Consumers lose 135. Ride On gains 90. The remaining 45 is deadweight loss.

27

Ride On

28

Deadweight loss

The loss is not the profit

Profit is a transfer from buyers. Deadweight loss is the value of trades that never happen.

29

Price controls

Same policy, opposite effect

Competitive roses (Week 3)

A ceiling below equilibrium creates a shortage.

Fewer roses sold
Monopoly rides

A cap above marginal cost removes the reason to restrict output.

More rides sold
30

Patents

A monopoly created on purpose

Cost

Deadweight loss while the patent lasts.

Easy to measure
Benefit

Inventions that would not otherwise exist, and disclosure.

Hard to measure
31

Elasticity

How large is the monopoly markup?

Can we estimate it without the whole demand curve?

32

Price elasticity of demand

A measure that doesn't depend on units

\(\varepsilon=\dfrac{dQ}{dp}\times\dfrac{p}{Q}\)

Elastic: \(|\varepsilon|>1\)

Unitary elastic: \(|\varepsilon|=1\)

Inelastic: \(|\varepsilon|<1\)

33

Ride On

34

Marginal revenue and elasticity

The markup rule

\(MR=p\left(1+\dfrac1\varepsilon\right)\)
\(\dfrac{p-MC}{p}=-\dfrac1\varepsilon\)

Ride On: \(\varepsilon=-\tfrac43\), so \((2-0.5)/2=\tfrac34\).

35

A diagnostic

Never on the inelastic part of demand

If demand is inelastic, a price rise raises revenue and lowers cost.

36

In-class exercise

U-Strap

At \(p=1{,}200\), \(\varepsilon=-4\) and \(MC=1{,}000\).

Produce more or less?
37

Assignment for Quiz 4

Carnegie Hall

Choose a concert hall and a ticket price, then evaluate a new contract.

38