Managerial Economics · Week 2

Demand and supply in competitive markets

How do price-taking consumers and firms respond to price?

1

Individual Demand

The most preferred affordable bundle

Preferences rank bundles.
The budget and prices determine which bundles are affordable.

2
3

Individual demand

From WTP to demand

At each price, the buyer chooses the highest-value bundle the budget allows.

4

Choice problem

Maximize value subject to the budget

Choose \(q\) and \(b\) to maximize \(V_C(q)+V_B(b)\)
such that \(pq+4b\leq 30\)

\(V_C(q)\): Maya’s total value from \(q\) cups of coffee.

\(V_B(b)\): Maya’s total value from \(b\) biscotti.

The coffee quantity in each optimal bundle is a point on Maya's demand curve.

5

Maya's daily coffee

Coffee in the best bundle

PriceQuantity
$45
$54
$63
$73
$82

Each price has a unique best bundle.

6

Change in quantity demanded

Along or shift?

Own price

The buyer chooses another point on the same curve.

Movement along
Fundamentals

Quantity changes at every price.

Shift
7

A rise in own price · income unchanged

Ordinary and Giffen goods

Ordinary good

A higher own price reduces quantity demanded.

Price rises → purchasing power falls, while alternatives become relatively cheaper → the buyer switches away and buys less.

Quantity demanded falls
Giffen good

A higher own price increases quantity demanded.

Price rises → purchasing power falls → the buyer cuts costlier foods and buys more of this staple to get enough to eat.

Quantity demanded rises

Veblen good: A higher price can make the good more desirable (higher status)

8

Demand shifts

Changes in fundamentals

  1. Income
  2. Preferences
  3. Price of a substitute
  4. Price of a complement
9

A rise in income · prices unchanged

Normal and inferior goods

Normal good

Higher income increases demand.

Income rises → purchasing power rises → the buyer chooses more of this good at each price.

Demand shifts right
Inferior good

Higher income reduces demand.

Income rises → purchasing power rises → the buyer can afford preferred alternatives and buys less of this good at each price.

Demand shifts left
10

Individual supply

From WTA to supply

At each price, the seller chooses the production level to maximize profits.

11

Economic profit

Revenue minus economic cost

\(\displaystyle \begin{aligned} \pi(q)&=pq-C(q)\\ &= [p-AC(q)]\times q \end{aligned}\)

Average cost determines the margin; quantity scales it.

12

Firm supply

Two steps

  1. Determine the shutdown threshold
    What is the minimum price above which the seller finds it profitable to produce?
  2. Determine the optimal quantity
    What is the quantity that maximizes the firm's profits at a price above the shutdown threshold?
13
14

Output choice

Compare price with marginal cost

\(p\gt MC(q):\;\text{produce more}\)
\(p\lt MC(q):\;\text{produce less}\)
\(p=MC(q^*)\)
15

Auto Eco

One electric-vehicle maker

\(C(q)=80+10q+5q^2\)

\(AC(q)=80/q+10+5q\)

\(MC(q)=10+10q\)

16

Auto Eco

Shut-down threshold

\(\displaystyle \begin{aligned} MC(q)&=AC(q)\\ 10+10q&=\frac{80}{q}+10+5q\\ 5q&=\frac{80}{q}\\ q^2&=16\\ q&=4 \end{aligned}\)
\(\displaystyle \begin{aligned} \text{At }q=4,\quad MC(4)&=AC(4)\\ \min AC&=50 \end{aligned}\)
17

Auto Eco

Optimal quantity

\(\displaystyle \begin{aligned} p&=MC(q)\\ p&=10+10q \qquad \text{rearrange to find }q\\ q&=\frac{p-10}{10} \end{aligned}\)
\(p\geq 50\)
18

Auto Eco

Auto Eco’s supply

\(\displaystyle q^s(p)=\begin{cases} 0 & p\lt 50\\ \{0,4\} & p=50\\ \dfrac{p-10}{10} & p\gt 50. \end{cases}\)
19

Auto Eco’s supply

20

Aggregation

Market demand and market supply

21

Market demand

Add buyers horizontally

Hold price fixed and add quantities demanded.

22

Aggregation

Many individual demands

\(Q^d(p)=\sum_{i=1}^{N}q_i^d(p)\)
23

Ann and Bob

Horizontal addition

PriceAnnBobMarket
$20304070
$40203050
$60102030
$8001010

At each price, market quantity is the sum of individual quantities.

24

Aggregating demand

25

Market demand shifts

What shifts market demand?

ChangeShift in market demand
Income risesRight for a normal good; left for an inferior good
Price of a substitute risesRight
Price of a complement risesLeft
Preferences move toward the goodRight
Expected future price risesCurrent demand may shift right
Number of buyers risesRight

Market demand shifts by the sum of individual shifts. Buyers may respond in different directions.

26

Demand as a managerial object

Diagnosing a change in sales

The firm's own price changed: movement along demand.
Quantity changed at the same price: demand shifted.
Price and quantity both changed: we need more information.

27

Market supply

Add firms horizontally

Hold price fixed and add quantities supplied.

28

Aggregation

Many individual firms

\(Q^s(p)=\sum_{j=1}^{N}q_j^s(p)\)
29

Multiple homogenous firms

30

Generic medication

Two producer groups

Apex-type firms

100 producers

Capacity: 100 packs a month

\(C_A(q)=1{,}000+10q\)

Fixed cost: $1,000
Boulder-type firms

300 producers

Capacity: 200 packs a month

\(C_B(q)=6{,}000+10q\)

Fixed cost: $6,000
31

Step 1: Apex

Apex’s minimum average cost

\(\displaystyle \begin{aligned} AC_A(q)&=\frac{C_A(q)}{q}=\frac{1{,}000+10q}{q}\\ &=\frac{1{,}000}{q}+10,\qquad 0\lt q\leq100\\[6pt] \frac{1{,}000}{q}&\text{ falls as }q\text{ rises}\\ AC_A(q)&\text{ is smallest at }q=100\\[6pt] \min AC_A&=AC_A(100)=\frac{1{,}000}{100}+10=20 \end{aligned}\)

Average cost falls with output, so its minimum occurs at capacity.

32

Step 1: Apex

Apex’s supply

\(\displaystyle q_A^s(p)=\begin{cases}100 & p\gt20\\[2pt]\{0,100\} & p=20\\[2pt]0 & p\lt20\end{cases}\)

At $20, Apex is indifferent between producing 0 and 100 packs.

33

Step 2: Boulder

Boulder’s minimum average cost

\(\displaystyle \begin{aligned} AC_B(q)&=\frac{C_B(q)}{q}=\frac{6{,}000+10q}{q}\\ &=\frac{6{,}000}{q}+10,\qquad 0\lt q\leq200\\[6pt] \frac{6{,}000}{q}&\text{ falls as }q\text{ rises}\\ AC_B(q)&\text{ is smallest at }q=200\\[6pt] \min AC_B&=AC_B(200)=\frac{6{,}000}{200}+10=40 \end{aligned}\)

Average cost falls with output, so its minimum occurs at capacity.

34

Step 2: Boulder

Boulder’s supply

\(\displaystyle q_B^s(p)=\begin{cases}200 & p\gt40\\[2pt]\{0,200\} & p=40\\[2pt]0 & p\lt40\end{cases}\)

At $40, Boulder is indifferent between producing 0 and 200 packs.

35

Step 3: Aggregate each technology

Technology A and B firms’ supply

\(Q_A^s(p)=100q_A^s(p)\)
\(Q_B^s(p)=300q_B^s(p)\)

The Apex group can supply up to 10,000 packs a month.

The Boulder group can supply up to 60,000 packs a month.

At a threshold, total supply depends on how many identical firms choose to operate.

36

Market supply

Aggregate the supply of two technologies

\(\displaystyle Q^s(p)=\begin{cases}70{,}000 & \text{if }p\gt40\\[2pt]\left[10{,}000,70{,}000\right] & \text{if }p=40\\[2pt]10{,}000 & \text{if }40\gt p\gt20\\[2pt]\left[0,10{,}000\right] & \text{if }p=20\\[2pt]0 & \text{if }p\lt20\end{cases}\)
37

Market supply

38

Health department

More than 10,000 packs requires a price of at least $40

Below $40, only the Apex group operates. At $40, Boulder can add up to 60,000 packs per month.

39

Supply shifts

What changes firms' costs?

  1. Input prices
  2. Technology
  3. Taxes and subsidies
  4. Natural events
  5. Number of firms
40

Competitive markets

When does price-taking make sense?

Four assumptions support one central consequence.

41

Perfect competition

Four assumptions

  1. Homogeneous goods
  2. Price-taking buyers and sellers
  3. Zero search cost
  4. No barriers to entry or exit
42

Farmer's market

Tomatoes as the running example

Buyers regard tomatoes as identical.

Every stall's price is visible.

Each grower is small relative to the market.

New growers can enter and incumbents can leave.

43

Time horizon

Short run and long run

Short run

At least one commitment and the number of firms are fixed.

Adjust output
Long run

All inputs and the number of firms can change.

Capacity, entry, exit
44