Managerial Economics · Week 1
Value, exchange and economic cost
What makes an exchange possible?
Economic value and exchange
When does an economic exchange occur?
Economic value
The benefit a good or service provides
Economic value is often measured in monetary terms and differs across individuals.
Two sides of value
Buyer and seller
Maximum amount the buyer is willing to pay.
\(\mathrm{WTP}\)Minimum amount the seller is willing to accept.
\(\mathrm{WTA}\)Surplus
When is exchange possible?
WTP must exceed WTA.
Anne and Brook
The bicycle
Anne wants to buy a new road-racing bicycle priced at $1,600.
Anne will not sell below $1,300.
A similar bicycle sold for $1,450.
Brook has a $2,000 budget but will not pay more than $1,500.
Exchange and price
Price allocates surplus
Changing a feasible price changes the allocation, not total surplus.
At p = $1,400
Who receives the surplus?
Calculate buyer surplus and seller surplus.
Methods of exchange
Markets · auctions · bargaining
Three ways to determine the terms of exchange.
Market
A stock exchange
A share trades at $50.
A market order for 100 shares costs $5,000.
The exchange matches buyers and sellers at the market price.
Auction
First-price sealed bids
Bidders submit one secret bid.
The highest bid wins.
The winner pays the submitted bid.
Bargaining
A salary negotiation
Job seeker asks for $80,000.
Employer offers $70,000.
Agreement: $75,000 plus a performance bonus.
Two antique daggers
Which exchanges are possible?
| Harrow · WTA $25k | Calder · WTA $50k | |
|---|---|---|
| Smith · WTP $40k | $15k surplus | No positive surplus |
| Blackwood · WTP $60k | $35k surplus | $10k surplus |
Compare the number of exchanges with total surplus.
Antique daggers
Which allocation creates the most surplus?
Two exchanges can create $25,000. One can create $35,000.
Dealer incentive
$1,000 for each completed exchange
The buyer and seller each pay the dealer $500.
Dealer incentive
5% of the surplus created
The dealer's fee now rises with total surplus.
Determinants of value
Why do WTP and WTA differ?
Consumer value and producer value have different determinants.
Consumer value
What affects WTP?
- Preferences and tastes
- Needs
- Situational factors
- Market conditions
- Related goods
Producer value
What affects WTA?
- Cost of production
- Technology
- Rules and regulations
- Access to markets
Economic value and exchange
Value determines possibility.
The method of exchange determines the terms.
Decisions and alternatives
Economic cost
Which resources are relevant, and what are they worth?
Economic cost
Ask two questions
- Which resources are affected by the decision?
- What is the opportunity cost of each relevant resource?
The Wood Whisperer
A new chair project
Raw materials · labour · machinery · workshop
Utilities · safety equipment · packaging · transport
Avoidable cost
Which resources change if the project is rejected?
Current workers and workshop space are underutilised.
Opportunity cost
Value the best alternative use.
Opportunity cost is the highest value a resource generates among its alternatives.
Audience poll
Apple's DRAM chips
Ordered for $38. Current market price $23.
Audience poll
An inherited house in Fitzroy
The owner pays no rent, but the house could be rented to someone else.
Economic cost
Avoidable resources valued at opportunity cost
Include monetary costs and opportunities given up.
Syndicate exercise
Ted's future
Read the case, identify the relevant economic costs and decide which option Ted should choose.
Ted's future
Background
Ted is finishing the MBA at Melbourne Business School and weighing his next career move.
Before the MBA, he spent seven years in the United States working for a successful real estate entrepreneur.
The business bought non-performing mortgage loans from banks at a discount, foreclosed on the properties, renovated them and sold them at a substantial profit.
When that line of business tapered off, Ted returned to Melbourne to strengthen his management skills.
Ted's future
The venture
With the real estate market on an upswing, a former associate proposes a joint venture to develop a prime property.
The project would cost $1 million: $400,000 for land and $600,000 to build a five-unit apartment building, the largest the zoning laws allow.
Ted and his associate would each contribute $500,000.
They expect to sell the finished property after one year for $1.4 million and split the proceeds equally.
Ted's future · Exhibit 1
Key figures
| Westpac offer | Joint venture |
|---|---|
| Annual salary: $125,000 | Total project cost: $1,000,000 |
| Signing bonus: $25,000 (only if Ted accepts now) | Land: $400,000; construction: $600,000 |
| Expected first-year performance bonus: $25,000 | Ted's contribution: $500,000 |
| About 60 hours per week | Projected sale price after one year: $1,400,000 |
| Ted's share of proceeds: 50% | |
| About 70 hours per week |
Ted can fund $200,000 from savings and $300,000 with a loan at 7%. His savings could otherwise earn 5%.
Ted's future
Financing and trade-offs
Ted has $200,000 in savings. His mother, who heads commercial lending at ANZ, can arrange a $300,000 loan at 7%, secured against the property.
If Ted leaves his savings where they are, they earn 5%.
The venture offers independence and casual clothes, but Ted expects to work about 70 hours a week, compared with about 60 at Westpac. The extra time would take up much of his weekends.
Ted expects that, after the project, he could return to Westpac or secure a comparable offer from another investment firm.
Syndicate question 1
Westpac or the venture?
Should Ted accept the Westpac offer or join the joint venture?
Syndicate question 2
Do living expenses matter?
Rent is $2,000 a month and food is $1,000 a month.
Cost functions
Economic cost at each output
Linear and quadratic functions.
Cost classification
Fixed and variable
Does not depend on quantity produced.
\(FC\)Depends on quantity produced.
\(VC(q)\)The bakery
Build the linear cost function
Rent · oven · insurance · manager
Ingredients · packaging · labour · utilities
Linear bakery
Constant variable cost per loaf
In \(C(q)=a+bq\), \(a\) is fixed cost and \(b\) is variable cost per unit.
Quadratic bakery
Overtime labor
The cq² term is overtime labor. Congestion makes each extra loaf require more overtime minutes.
Average and marginal cost
The minimum of average cost
If AC is differentiable and reaches its minimum at \(q^*\) inside the feasible output range, then \(MC(q^*)=AC(q^*)\). Equality need not occur with discrete output, a kink or a boundary minimum.
Assignment for Quiz 1
TV News Magazine
Hobart · Ballarat · Gold Coast